Margaret C Sullivan

There Must Be Murder

Dedicated to the members of Team

(Henry and Catherine) Tilney everywhere.

"Government," said Henry, endeavouring not to smile, "neither desires nor dares to interfere in such matters. There must be murder; and government cares not how much."

— Northanger Abbey by Jane Austen, Volume I, Chapter XIV

Chapter One

Winter Pleasures

The Reverend Henry Tilney, the rector of Woodston parish in Gloucestershire, looked up from his book and addressed his wife. “Catherine, do you know what day this is?”

Catherine Tilney smiled at her husband. “It is Saturday, beloved.”

“Yes, it is, but this is no ordinary Saturday. This is Saturday, the ninth day of February.”

Though they had been married but a short time, Catherine knew that Henry was not in the habit of stating the obvious without a particular reason; thus, she looked at him expectantly, her needle suspended above the fabric.

“My sweet, I am surprised at you. Do not you remember? We met exactly one year ago tonight, in the Lower Rooms at Bath.”

“Did we?” Catherine was delighted with this intelligence.

“We did. I presumed that you were already aware of this anniversary, as you have recourse to your journal to remind you of it. I dare say you were certain to record such an important event as meeting your future husband.”

“Henry, you know perfectly well that I keep no journal. Besides, I did not know then that you were my future husband.”

“Some husbands would be injured at such an admission, but not I; after all, I did not know that you were my future wife. I remember that I was wandering about the rooms like a lost soul, having no acquaintance there. The master of ceremonies, Mr. King, took pity upon me and asked if I would like an introduction to a clergyman’s daughter who was in need of a partner. In Christian charity, I could not decline; though from my past experience of ladies described as ‘clergymen’s daughters,’ I expected to be presented to an elderly spinster with a squint. You may imagine my relief when Miss Morland turned out to be rather a pretty girl, and I considered myself fortunate that no other gentleman had already claimed the honor of dancing with her.”

Catherine’s eyes were shining. “You thought me pretty?”

“Indeed.” Henry reached for her hand and kissed it. “Emily and Valancourt await us, my sweet. Shall we retire?”

“I am ready.” Catherine neatly folded her sewing.

“I beg your pardon, MacGuffin,” Henry addressed the Newfoundland curled up at the foot of his chair. “It is time for bed, lad. I cannot rise while you are sleeping on my feet.”

MacGuffin raised his shaggy head and gazed up at his master adoringly, his tail thumping the floor. A string of saliva glistened at the corner of the dog’s mouth, trailing down to the old blanket placed on the floor expressly to absorb the excess. Henry gently lifted his foot in an encouraging nudge, and the dog uttered a weary moan and heaved his massive bulk to a standing position.

“Shall you let the dogs out?” Catherine asked her husband. The house terriers, lying in a tangled heap by the fire, looked round at her utterance of that favored word, “out.”

“Matthew will attend to that.”

As they passed out of the drawing room, followed by the clicking of canine claws on the wooden floor, a figure loomed from the shadows of the passage. Catherine started and gave a strangled cry.

“Beg pardon, Mrs. Tilney,” said Matthew. Matthew was the rector’s groom, clerk, and factotum; an accomplished huntsman, he glided about the parsonage as silently as he moved through the woods, frequently (and quite inadvertently) startling his mistress. However, Catherine liked Matthew, and it was not in her nature to bear a grudge, so she smiled her forgiveness.

Matthew snapped his fingers at the dogs, and they followed him down the passage toward the rear of the house as the Tilneys climbed the stairs to their bedchamber.

***

Henry had a genius for piling the pillows so that he could sit up in bed and read comfortably, even with one arm round Catherine’s waist and her head resting upon his shoulder. The fire burned brightly, and the Tilneys curled up warmly together under the quilts as Henry read aloud from Mrs. Radcliffe’s novel, The Mysteries of Udolpho.

“Valancourt,” Henry read, “between these emotions of love and pity, lost the power, and almost the wish, of repressing his agitation; and, in the intervals of convulsive sobs, he, at one moment, kissed away her tears — ”

Henry stopped reading and scattered several quick kisses across Catherine’s face. She giggled and prodded him in the chest. “There are no tears here, sir. Pray continue.”

“I would much rather kiss you.”

“Read!”

“I hear and obey, madam.” Henry returned to Udolpho. “Now, where was I? Oh, yes — kissed away her tears, then told her cruelly, that possibly she might never again weep for him, and then tried to speak more calmly, but only exclaimed, ‘O Emily — my heart will break! — I cannot — cannot leave you! Now — I gaze upon that countenance, now I hold you in my arms! A little while, and all this will appear a dream. I shall look, and cannot see you; shall try to recollect your features — and the impression will be fled from my imagination; — to hear the tones of your voice, and even memory will be silent! — I cannot, cannot leave you!’”

The first time Catherine read Udolpho, she had wept over this passage; but when Henry read Valancourt’s dialogue, he used such a simpering, affected voice that she found herself laughing at the poor Chevalier’s distress.

“‘Why should we confide the happiness of our whole lives to the will of people, who have no right to interrupt, and, except in giving you to me, have no power to promote it? O Emily! Venture to trust your own heart, venture to be mine for ever!’ His voice trembled, and he was silent; Emily continued to weep, and was silent also, when Valancourt proceeded to propose an immediate marriage, and that, at an early hour on the following morning, she should quit Madame Montoni’s house, and be conducted by him to the church of the Augustines, where a friar should await to unite them.”

Henry stopped reading and pondered for a moment. “The banns were not published? No license obtained? A curious business; I dare say that the brave Valancourt might have found the Augustine friar less receptive to his scheme than he anticipated.”

“It is only a story, Henry,” said Catherine in the patient tone used to educate the slow-witted.

“Forgive me, my sweet. It was a matter of professional interest. To continue: The silence, with which she listened to a proposal, dictated by love and despair, and enforced at a moment, when it seemed scarcely possible for her to oppose it; — when her heart was softened by the sorrows of a separation, that might be eternal, and her reason obscured by the illusions of love and terror, encouraged him to hope, that it would not be rejected. ‘Speak, my Emily!’ said Valancourt eagerly, ‘let me hear your voice, let me hear you confirm my fate.’ She spoke not; her cheek was cold, and her senses seemed to fail her, but she did not faint. To Valancourt’s terrified imagination she appeared to be dying; he called upon her name, rose to go to the chateau for assistance, and then, recollecting her situation, feared to go, or to leave her for a moment.”

Henry paused and glanced down at his wife’s rapt face. “I am glad that you are not of a swooning disposition, Cat. It must be terribly uncomfortable to have a girl forever falling insensible at inconvenient times, when she is most in need of all her faculties. It is well that you did not swoon when I offered you marriage. It might have put me off my mission.”

Catherine sighed in delight. “I assure you, I felt no inclination to swoon. That was the happiest moment of my life. I should not have liked to miss it because I was insensible.”

Henry smiled and gently touched her chin. “Then I am glad that you did not miss it.”

“It all seems so long ago, and yet we met for the first time just one year ago tonight! Henry, we should go back to Bath someday, present ourselves to Mr. King, and tell him what a successful introduction he made that night.”

“You would like to return to Bath?”

“Oh, yes! I think it would be very pleasant to return to Bath as a married woman. I should not have to worry about sitting out at the balls for lack of a partner.”

“Very well. I will write to my curate and enquire whether his schedule will allow me a fortnight in Bath, which we naturally shall extend to six weeks.”

Catherine’s delight with the scheme could not be expressed in words; fortunately, she needed no words to express that delight as admirably as her husband could desire.

Chapter Two

An Unexpected Meeting

The morning post contained a letter of great import; Henry paused only to issue a particular order to Matthew, and then went to share the news with Catherine.

He found her in the parsonage drawing-room, a very different apartment from that which she had seen on her first visit to Woodston. Fitted up with wallpaper and draperies in various shades of green and elegant new furniture, the room now indeed deserved the encomium of “the prettiest room in the world,” bestowed upon it by its then-future mistress.

Catherine did not immediately notice Henry’s entrance. She lay upon the sofa in an attitude that even the most generous observer might consider unladylike: her chin rested upon her hands, which were crossed over the arm of the sofa, and a slippered foot extended carelessly from a froth of petticoats as she gazed out of one of the big windows towards the little cottage beyond the orchard. She had been reading, but the forgotten book had dropped to the floor, where Ruby Begonia, the terrier most attached to Catherine, slept in a patch of sunlight. Henry wondered what made her smile so; his vanity did not extend to imagining that she was thinking of him.

He said her name; she started, and then laughed. “You have caught me daydreaming!” Ruby Begonia yawned, stretched, and jumped up to run to her master to have her ears scratched.

Catherine made as if to sit up, but he said, “Nay, my sweet, stay as you are. I should hate to lose sight of such a pretty ankle.”

“Henry!” she exclaimed in austere tones as she sat up and arranged her skirts demurely. She was accustomed to his teasing, but not yet to the liberties that a husband might take.

“Well, it is a very pretty ankle; but I suppose your scruples are as they should be. But that is not why I looked for you. The post has just arrived, including a letter from Naughton.” Mr. Naughton was Henry’s curate. They had been fellows together at Oxford until Henry took over the Woodston living. Mr. Naughton was content with the academic life, and had no thought of marriage; however, he had a widowed mother and unmarried sister to help support, and was happy to receive a yearly stipend in return for riding to Woodston on Sundays when the rector could not be present. “He is happy to take Sunday services for as long as necessary, so we are free to pursue our scheme for Bath.”

“Delightful! How soon can we leave?”

“As soon as you can pack your trunks. Matthew is readying the curricle, but I shall procure a chaise to carry us and our luggage.”

Catherine bent to scoop the little terrier into her lap. “May I bring Ruby Begonia?”

“She will be happier here in the country, I think, where there are squirrels and rabbits to chase, but MacGuffin would enjoy a visit to Bath. The waters might do him good; he is looking a trifle gouty lately, do not you think?”

“By all means let us bring MacGuffin. Dove says that he pines when you go away without him. Have my trunks sent up to my dressing-room, and I shall begin packing directly.” With the assistance of Mrs. Dove, the housekeeper, Catherine’s new wedding-clothes were wrapped in tissue and folded into the trunks, and the chaise, loaded with their luggage and a sleepy Newfoundland dog, was ready to carry them to Bath the following morning. Matthew had left at dawn, driving Henry’s curricle, and would be in Bath to receive them.

A pair of pistols, primed and loaded, hung inside the chaise where Henry could easily reach them. The presence of these firearms did not unsettle Catherine in the least; indeed, she experienced a private shiver of delight over the idea of being waylaid by highwaymen. Fortunately for Henry, who had no share in that particular species of delight, the journey was uneventful, and they entered Bath early in the afternoon.

Catherine found the sights, sounds, and smells of the city as overwhelming and delightful as they had been the first time she had entered Bath, and she looked about her with an eager smile, trying to take it all in. Henry watched her with a smile of his own, finding new delights in Bath as seen through his beloved’s eyes. Even MacGuffin caught their excitement and heaved himself to his feet, from which height he could see through the side glasses of the chaise as easily as his master and mistress.

Matthew awaited them at a coaching-inn near the Abbey courtyard, and they were quickly established in a private room. After refreshing himself with hot tea and sandwiches, Henry set out to secure lodgings, and by nightfall the Tilneys were in possession of first-floor lodgings in one of the stately houses of Pulteney-street. The large sitting-room looked down over the street and the wide pavements; there was another room comfortably fitted out as a dining parlor, and a bedchamber with a view over Bathwick. There was a dressing room for each of them, and the maidservant was already unpacking Catherine’s trunk and looking askance at the Newfoundland, who took a quietly polite interest in the proceedings.

“Come away from there, Mac,” said Catherine. “Do not drool on my gowns. Come and lie here on your blanket, there’s a good lad.” She managed to coax him away from the trunks with the help of a good fire in the sitting-room, before which the Newfoundland settled himself peacefully.

“There is a ball at the Lower Rooms tomorrow,” said Henry, who was reading the paper. “I suppose you must visit all the shops before we make our appearance.”

“Oh, no, not all the shops; Papa was so generous with my wedding-clothes that I have plenty to wear.”

Despite such sartorial riches, Catherine did find herself in need of a few indispensible items the next day; and Henry, all good nature, escorted her to Bond-street and Milsom-street, where the best shops in Bath were located.

Catherine noticed Henry look up at the windows of the lodgings he had engaged for his family the previous winter. His expression was inscrutable; he was not a man to brood, but Catherine sensed that Henry’s relationship with General Tilney had none of the easy affection of hers with Mr. Morland.

“Would you have preferred to take lodgings here on Milsom-street?” she asked him.

“No, my sweet; my taste runs to the newer parts of Bath. I would have preferred to take lodgings on Pulteney-street last year, but General Tilney particularly wanted Milsom-street. Have you everything you need? The time for your public debut of the season approaches.”

They arrived at the Lower Rooms as the minuets were ending. The season was full, and the crowd ringing the dance floor numerous; the last couple retired, and the throng pushed onto the dance floor, forming sets for the country dances to follow. As Henry guided Catherine expertly through the mob, the ebb and flow of humanity brought them suddenly face-to-face with the master of the ceremonies.

“Mr. Tilney!” he cried. “I am delighted that you have returned to Bath, sir. And. . . Miss Morland, is it?”

“You see before you the success of your endeavors, Mr. King,” said Henry. “This is Mrs. Tilney, who was Miss Morland when you introduced me to her last year. I dare say you have made a few matches in your time, and here is one more to add to your list.”

“Indeed I have made a fair few matches,” said Mr. King, “though my exertions are not entirely directed toward such permanent arrangements. I felicitate you, Mr. Tilney; and give you joy, madam. Pray forgive me, but I must give directions to the musicians. The country dances will begin momentarily.”

Henry took Catherine’s hand and led her to one of the sets that were forming. Mr. King announced that the dance would be “Haste to the Wedding,” and the dancers swept into motion as the music began.

“A fitting choice,” said Henry. “This is our first dance as a married couple, Cat. We are proof of the parallel between marriage and a country dance. From the vantage point of being an old married man of nearly two months, I flatter myself that the metaphor holds up admirably. Here we are, at the Lower Rooms, surrounded by other ladies and gentlemen but with no other thought than to dance together — at least for the first two dances.”

“Just remember, if you dance with any other ladies here tonight, that you are married to me.”

“I am not likely to forget, my sweet, for a hundred reasons.”

Catherine made the agreeable discovery that dancing with Henry had not lost its charm, and that two dances with him as her partner passed as quickly as they had the previous winter — in other words, all too quickly.

As the musicians finished with a flourish, Mr. King appeared at Catherine’s elbow in the mysterious way that belonged to truly accomplished masters of the ceremonies, and to her surprise asked her to lead the next two dances. “It is a bride’s right,” he told her, “and I hope not a disagreeable duty, as I have taken pains to procure for you a partner whom you already know.”

The only young man amongst Catherine’s acquaintance who might be in Bath was John Thorpe; and it was with a sinking feeling that she agreed to lead the dance, thinking it a very onerous duty indeed; but then she realized that Mr. King was looking expectantly at the young man standing beside him, who was smiling at her in a very familiar manner, though she did not know him at all.

Henry’s voice came from behind her. “Mr. King, your scruples are very kind indeed; but I am afraid that Mrs. Tilney is not yet acquainted with my brother-in-law. Do not trouble yourself, sir, for it is the work of a moment. Catherine, may I present Eleanor’s husband, Lord Whiting?”

Mr. King was all apologies; but Catherine’s real delight at meeting Eleanor’s husband, and the Viscount’s own good breeding and charming manners soon did away with all the discomfort of the moment, and Mr. King soon bustled off to inform the musicians of Mrs. Tilney’s choices.

“Eleanor’s over that way,” said his lordship to Henry, nodding towards the chairs. “Sitting out this dance, and I have been strictly charged to send you to her.”

“Yes, of course,” said Henry, his eyes already eagerly scanning the chairs. “You are in good hands, my sweet; enjoy your moment in the sun. I will watch with Eleanor.”

“Give her my love,” said Catherine, “and tell her that I shall come to see her directly the set is finished.”

Henry immediately disappeared into the crowd, and his lordship gave Catherine his hand to the top of the set, where Mr. King stood waiting. “Mrs. Tilney has chosen ‘Mrs. Darcy’s Favorite,’” he informed the other dancers, and Catherine blushed at the attention, kind though it was, turned upon her.

Lord Whiting turned out to be an excellent dancer, perhaps even better than Henry, though Catherine would scarcely have credited such a notion. The demands of leading the dance precluded conversation until they reached the bottom and had a turn out. His lordship said, “You will forgive me if I am too familiar, Mrs. Tilney; I have heard so much about you from Eleanor and from Henry’s letters, that I feel as though we are already very well-acquainted.”

“And I have heard much about you, sir; Eleanor’s happiness is clear in her letters. I am surprised to learn that you have come to Bath, though.”

“It was an unexpected trip and arranged with great haste, as was your own, I apprehend. We arrived only today.”

“You are not unwell, sir? But I suppose you would scarcely be dancing if you were gouty.”

“No, I am very well, I thank you; and you are correct, madam. Considering that most visitors to Bath claim to be here for their health, it really is astonishing how many of them turn up at the rooms when there is a ball.”

Catherine assented, thinking his lordship quite a clever young man; and as another couple had reached the bottom of the set, they rejoined the dance and had no more opportunity to speak except for the usual commonplaces of a ballroom until their two dances were over.

The viscount led Catherine to the chairs; Henry, taller than those around him, saw her before she reached the chairs and moved as if to intercept her, but when Catherine saw Eleanor seated nearby, she ran past Henry to bestow a warm embrace upon her.

Eleanor returned the embrace, but she looked past Catherine with an expression of apprehension, an expression that Henry, who now stood beside Eleanor’s chair, shared; an expression that Catherine had seen before on both brother and sister.

She took a deep breath, tried to ignore the sudden nervous patter of her heart, and turned to make her curtsy to General Tilney.

Chapter Three

Spoilt by Great Acquaintance

“How do you do, General Tilney?” said Catherine in a voice that was more composed than she felt.

The general’s answer held the barest hint of civility. “Very well, I thank you.”

“I am glad to hear it. I am glad that you are not in Bath for your health, sir.”

Lord Whiting made a noise that sounded suspiciously like a laugh smothered with a cough.

“Ma’am,” the general said to a woman dressed in half-mourning who was seated next to him, “May I present Mrs. Tilney?”

“So this is the paragon that has captured dear Henry!” the woman cried. “Why, she is adorable! So very young!”

“Lady Beauclerk,” the general informed Catherine, “is a neighbor and a very old friend of the Tilney family.”

“We so longed to see you when you were staying at Northanger Abbey last year,” said Lady Beauclerk, fixing Catherine with her bright eye. “But we were in mourning then for dear Sir Arthur and not paying calls. But oh, did I wonder about this Miss Morland who had at last conquered Henry Tilney! The neighborhood had quite despaired of either of the Tilney boys finding women good enough to suit their fine taste. I confess I nurtured a hope that dear Henry might take pity on my Judith and offer for her. My love,” she called to a young woman who had just stepped off the dance floor, “come here and be presented to Mrs. Tilney. I must present you to her, though she is so much younger than you, for she is a married lady, and you are not.”

Miss Beauclerk was fair and delicate, ethereally pale; one of those graceful, fluttering creatures who make an ordinary mortal, even one in a new gown of the most delicate muslin, feel like a plodding beast. Catherine, confused by Lady Beauclerk’s speech and disconcerted at meeting this lovely woman who apparently had once been a rival for her husband’s hand, could do nothing but curtsy. As she rose, she felt a hand under her elbow, and knew with a triumphant certainty that Henry stood beside her.

“We were unprepared to meet so many old friends, sir,” Henry said to his father, “but I am happy to perform the introductions for my wife.”

“As you choose,” said the general with every appearance of fashionable boredom.

“I hope you will not forget to introduce me, Tilney,” said a young exquisite standing behind Lady Beauclerk’s chair.

Henry’s hand tightened on Catherine’s elbow momentarily. “With the greatest pleasure. My sweet, may I present Sir Philip Beauclerk?”

“Your servant, Mrs. Tilney,” said Sir Philip. He held out his hand, and Catherine, unsure what else to do, gave him hers; in a single, graceful movement, Sir Philip bowed and raised her hand to his lips.

“Henry dear, you are remiss in explaining family history to dear Mrs. Tilney,” said Lady Beauclerk. “Philip is my late husband’s nephew and heir, and has put us out of our home.”

“You will give Mrs. Tilney the idea that I am the world’s greatest scoundrel, ma’am,” said Sir Philip. “I was happy to have you and Judith stay on at Beaumont, and am still, but you would remove to the Dower House.”

“I dare say Mrs. Tilney understands that if I had only myself to consider, I should have been very happy to stay and act as your hostess, but it would have been most improper for Judith to live with her unmarried cousin.”

“As you say, ma’am,” said Sir Philip with another graceful bow.

“If only you had taken Judith off my hands years ago, Henry! The least you can do is dance with her.”

Well and truly caught, there was nothing else for Henry to do but request Miss Beauclerk’s hand in the set that was forming, and nothing for Miss Beauclerk to do but accept, which she did as gracefully as she did everything. With another squeeze of the elbow and a significant, apologetic look, Henry was gone — gone to the dance floor, with another woman on his arm — and such a lovely woman!

Lord Whiting also gave Catherine an apologetic look, but she understood it would not have done to stand up again with him so soon; instead he took Eleanor to the other set forming. Catherine was left alone, with such feelings of discomfort as can be imagined: the general set to ignore her, Lady Beauclerk set to tease her, and Henry gone; but a rescuer was at hand.

Sir Philip stepped close to her, his voice a murmur for her ear only. “As my aunt has left you bereft of your partner,” he said, “perhaps you will accept me as a substitute, however inferior.”

Catherine accepted, all gratitude for such kindness. She hoped to follow her brother-in-law’s example and join the other set, but as they passed behind Miss Beauclerk, she reached out to touch Catherine’s arm. “Mrs. Tilney, will you stand next to me? Pray pay no attention to my mother’s rattle. Henry — Mr. Tilney and I have been friends for a long time, and I am very happy for you both.”

Catherine looked at Henry, who nodded and smiled; thus assured, she took the place to which she had been invited.

Sir Philip turned out to be the sort of partner in whom Catherine normally delighted: a graceful dancer who did nothing to draw undue attention to himself, scrupulously polite, certainly handsome; but instead of giving her attention to her partner, she found herself watching Henry dance with Miss Beauclerk, watching him lean close to say something that made her laugh. Common sense told her that in such a crowded room, Henry had to lean close to be heard, but she could not be comfortable.

Sir Philip did not seek to engage her in conversation beyond the commonplace civilities of a ballroom, for which Catherine was grateful, though she felt she should be making more of an effort. She felt it even more acutely after their two dances were over, and Mr. King presented gentleman after gentleman who wished introductions to the pretty young bride who had been singled out by a man of fashion such as Beauclerk. Catherine danced with them all, and conversed politely with them all, and was obliged to speak very severely to one of them, who appeared to be in liquor and seized her waist with more familiarity than allowed by a country-dance. Mr. King hustled the offender away directly with profuse apologies; Catherine heard the man say to the master of the ceremonies, “But she was dancin’ with Beauclerk!” She could not begin to understand him.

She had made up her mind to not dance any more that evening, when Henry appeared before her like a miracle. “I hope you saved two dances for me,” he said.

“Any two you wish.”

“The next two, then.”

Her flagging spirits revived, they had their two dances, and then everyone was going in to tea. Though the room was crowded, Henry managed to find a table, and sent a waiter to fetch their tea.

“How delightful that we were dancing together just now,” said Catherine. “I would not have liked to be obliged to drink tea with someone else just because he happened to be my partner for the last dance.”

“Nor I, my sweet; and that is why I gave Mr. King a half-crown to tell me which would be the last dance before tea.”

Catherine gasped, and then laughed, and poured her beloved a cup of tea as they were joined by Lord and Lady Whiting.

“Oh, how very comfortable,” said Eleanor. “Here we all are together, when we despaired of finding a place!”

“The General will not join us?” asked Henry.

“The General,” said Whiting, “waits upon Lady Beauclerk’s party, of course.”

Catherine let out a sigh of relief and smiled at Henry.

“Now that we can speak more freely, I may ask: what brings you all to Bath?” Henry asked, passing a cup of tea to his sister.

“I wrote to you that we were visiting at the Abbey over Christmas,” said Eleanor. “My father pressed me to stay on after the holiday to act as his hostess.”

“What my lovely wife has left out of the story,” said his lordship, “is that General Tilney needed a hostess at the Abbey so that he could continue to receive Lady Beauclerk and her daughter, who have been frequent callers at the Abbey, at least on the days that the general was not haunting Beaumont.”

“Indeed?” asked Henry, exchanging a speaking glance with his sister, who bowed her head and sipped her tea. “But you have not yet answered my question: what brings you all to Bath?”

His lordship smirked. “Her ladyship thought the waters might do her good, and the general decided soon after that the waters would do him good.”

“John,” said Eleanor in a warning tone.

“Do not look so despondent, my love,” said his lordship. “If the general marries Lady Beauclerk, he will no longer be able to exploit your very proper daughterly scruples to keep you at the Abbey for months on end. He will have a hostess permanently installed.”

Eleanor shook her head. “I cannot like it. It is not seemly, so soon after Sir Arthur’s death.”

“You refine too much upon trifles, my love. You may be sure that the neighborhood had them married off before Sir Arthur was cold in his grave. ‘So suitable!’ the old biddies cry. ‘Such old friends! Such fine fortunes!’”

“I know you cannot like it, Henry,” said Eleanor.

“It is none of my affair, I am sure,” said Henry. “My mother has been dead these ten years. It is not wonderful that the general should seek a wife.”

“I would have had him look elsewhere.”

“Do we have the right to dictate to him, Eleanor, when we did not allow him to dictate to us?” said Henry, with a smile at Catherine.

“But John and Catherine are not — ” Eleanor bit off the words.

“Hateful shrews?” supplied her husband.

Even Eleanor laughed at his sally.

“I would not worry overmuch,” said his lordship, finishing his tea. “I am not so sure that her ladyship will accept an offer from General Tilney. She is enjoying single blessedness too much to give it up very soon. Do you know what they call her? The Merry Widow.”

“Do they indeed?” murmured Henry.

Catherine did not expect much enjoyment from the remainder of the evening, but more dances with the viscount, and Sir Philip, and especially with Henry, brought back all the happiness with which she had anticipated this visit to Bath, alloyed only by Miss Beauclerk taking Catherine’s hand at the close of the ball and begging her to call at their house in Laura-place on the morrow. Her manner was so perfectly frank and friendly that Catherine could not refuse, though she shrank from a more intimate acquaintance.

Matthew and MacGuffin waited for them outside the rooms; Matthew had already procured a chair for Catherine, but Henry walked ahead of the chair, deep in conversation with Matthew, who held a lantern to light the way. The chair-men kept a careful distance, unsure what to make of the very large Newfoundland dog, so their progress was slower than usual.

Catherine watched Henry’s evening cloak swinging gently in the shadows. Perhaps she dozed a little; though her dreams were not of brigands and abductors, but of their comfortable lodgings, a warm fire, a glass of wine mixed with water, and Henry reading Udolpho. . . they were almost to the black veil. . . which held no fears for Catherine while Henry was there.

Chapter Four

No Enemy to Matrimony

“Are you prepared to receive your beaux this morning, Cat?” Henry asked his wife at breakfast the next morning.

“My beaux? Whatever do you mean?”

“Your dance partners from last night, who no doubt will call this morning, bringing you nosegays, and poems of their own composition dedicated to your beauty, and other tributes.”

“I hardly think so, Henry. I am barely acquainted with any of them.”

“I think it a very hard thing indeed when a man must bribe the master of the ceremonies in order to secure a dance with his own wife. Not that half a crown is too much to pay to dance with you, my sweet.”

“If you wish, I shall tell the other gentlemen I am engaged to you from now on. I would prefer to dance only with you — well, and with John, and perhaps Sir Philip, who was very obliging when I was left without a partner.”

“Yes; Beauclerk can be most obliging. I would not keep you from your partners at the rooms, my sweet, but if you are not at home to morning-callers, may I engage you today for a country walk?”

Catherine’s face fell. “Oh! I should like that very much; but I promised Miss Beauclerk I would call upon her.” It seemed a hard duty indeed, when it kept her from a country walk with Henry.

“I shall come with you, as I must do my duty to Lady Beauclerk as well. We will stay the proscribed half-hour and then be free for our walk.”

The breakfast things had just been cleared when Mr. King was announced. “Though we met at the ball last night,” he said, “I saw your names in the pump-room book today and determined to pay my call in form. And may I take this opportunity as well to offer you my congratulations, Mr. Tilney?”

“On my marriage, Mr. King? You congratulated me last night, but I am happy to accept your kind wishes as many times as you care to express them. Marriage is, after all, a lasting blessing, and perhaps more worth the congratulations as it gains in duration.”

“Indeed, sir; but I had a different wedding in mind. Everywhere I go this morning, it is said that General Tilney will marry Lady Beauclerk. I saw them together at the pump-room not half an hour past, drinking water and looking very contented.”

“My father,” said Henry, “has not shared such hopes with us; but we only met for the first time in several months last night, and perhaps he felt that such a delicate family communication was not best made in a ballroom; and I believe that Lady Beauclerk has not yet cast off her mourning for Sir Arthur.”

“Oh! of course. When one sees a lady out everywhere, one forgets that she is in mourning. I do beg your pardon, sir, if I have given offense.”

Henry assured Mr. King that he had taken no offense. The affable little man left after fifteen minutes, and the call on the Beauclerks could be put off no longer.

As they prepared to leave, MacGuffin was at the door; seeing his master booted and great coated and his mistress in her bonnet and pelisse, he not unnaturally expected to achieve that particular species of canine happiness known as “Out.”

Henry looked down at the dog’s beseeching eyes and wagging tail. “I ask you, Cat, can one resist such supplication? If beggars were equipped with these powers, they should live like kings. Very well, lad, but you go to a lady’s house, and I charge you to be on your best behavior.”

“May we take him with us to Lady Beauclerk’s house?”

“Lady Beauclerk usually has several lapdogs about, so Mac will have company, and he will enjoy a walk afterward; that is, if we can keep him out of the river.”

The walk to Lady Beauclerk’s establishment was not long; Laura-place was situated at the end of Pulteney-street, set diagonally, like a jewel, into the base of the grand avenue. However, even on a short walk the Newfoundland created a stir amongst the pedestrians on the wide pavement. One stately matron ran into the street, heedless of the hem of her gown and the leavings of horses, to avoid meeting them; a fashionable young man stopped Henry to ask where he might procure a puppy for himself; and a small boy, not even as tall as MacGuffin, was pulled past briskly by his nurse as he called out in a high, piping voice that he desired to pet “the pony.”

Catherine had never looked very closely at the grand houses of Laura-place. As they approached the house that Lady Beauclerk had taken for two months, she saw that they were wider and taller than even the grand houses of Pulteney-street; and Lady Beauclerk had taken the entire house, not a mere single floor of rooms. They sent up their cards and were admitted; the footman who conducted them to her ladyship’s breakfast-room did not even deign to notice the Newfoundland who followed him up the stairs, his master and mistress trailing behind. Despite Henry’s assurances, Catherine was apprehensive at the reception that the dog would receive; as they entered the breakfast-room, and she perceived several visitors already arrived — including General Tilney, who favored her with a haughty nod of the head — her apprehension increased.

“Oh, the dear creature!” cried Miss Beauclerk as they entered. She immediately knelt to pet MacGuffin, who received her adoration as his due. “But I’m afraid that Lady Josephine will not like him as much as I do.”

“Surely you have not forgotten Lady Josephine, Henry,” said Lady Beauclerk.

Catherine wondered who the mysterious Lady Josephine might be; perhaps an elderly spinster companion to Lady Beauclerk or her daughter. All the callers beside themselves were gentlemen of Lady Beauclerk’s generation. As Catherine considered the question, a loud hiss from behind her ladyship’s chair answered the puzzle. A striped cat stood howling on the back of the chair, her fur standing on end. MacGuffin, accustomed to the tyranny of three active terriers, ignored this sally and lay down next to Miss Beauclerk’s chair.

“I was mistaken,” Henry murmured to Catherine. “Her ladyship keeps cats, not dogs.” A certain gleam in his eye made Catherine suspect that Henry remembered Lady Josephine very well. She gave him an answering smile, and then noticed that Miss Beauclerk was smiling at him knowingly as well.

Lady Josephine paced back and forth across the back of the chair a few times, emitting an occasional cry of dislike; at last she settled into her mistress’ lap.

“I am glad that you came today,” Miss Beauclerk said to Catherine as Henry exchanged polite nothings with Lady Beauclerk. “Mamma and I are so dull! We have been to the pump-room for our glass of water, and took four turns about the room, and inspected the book to see who has arrived, and are now at the mercy of those friends kind enough to take pity on a poor widow and orphan.”

Catherine looked round her surreptitiously at the grand appointments of the house, and thought it the very opposite of poor, and indeed quite replete with interesting ways one might spend one’s time when one’s callers went away. A stack of uncut books lay waiting for some lucky reader on a table; a grand pianoforte and an ornate harp stood ready to be played (and Catherine did not doubt for a moment that Miss Beauclerk played both, exquisitely); and Miss Beauclerk sat with a froth of white muslin in her lap, onto which she was rapidly dropping tiny whitework stitches. She saw Catherine looking at it, and said, “You catch me quite dissipated, Mrs. Tilney! I dare say you keep busy with good works, making clothing for the poor of your parish, and here I am embroidering a new shawl for myself. It will be a pretty thing, though, will it not?”

“It is very pretty,” said Catherine, recalling that she had never given a thought to the poor-basket and determining to start directly she got home.

“When you get to know me you will learn that I am very vain and like pretty things. Am not I, Mr. Tilney?” she said, interrupting his conversation with her mother.

“You hardly can expect me to answer such a question,” said Henry. “Whether I agree or disagree, I will be ungentlemanlike; either I call you vain, or accuse you of dissembling. Determining how I might appear to the best advantage in such a situation will take more time than a morning-call provides.”

Miss Beauclerk burst into a musical trill of laughter. “How you must enjoy being married to him!” she said to Catherine. “How I should enjoy dining every day with such a charming rattle!”

“Henry is not a rattle,” said Catherine. “His conversation is always very amusing, and often instructive.”

“I dare say it is,” said Miss Beauclerk, smiling at Henry in what Catherine considered a very familiar way.

Some of the visitors took their leave, and General Tilney had a whispered conversation with his son that ended with Henry saying to Catherine, “I am sorry, my sweet, but I must postpone our walk. My father requires me to attend him to Milsom-street.”

Catherine, remembering Mr. King’s news, thought the general might have something particular to tell Henry. “Of course you must go with your father. We shall have our walk another time.”

Miss Beauclerk, listening to this conjugal tete-a-tete with what Catherine thought a rather impertinent interest, said, “May I claim you for an hour or two, then, Mrs. Tilney? I have some commissions in town that cannot wait, and I would like it very much if you would accompany me.”

“There is no need to trouble Mrs. Tilney, Judith,” said Lady Beauclerk. “Married women have so many things to do; dear Mrs. Tilney has no time to chaperone a spinster nearly ten years her elder about Bath.”

Miss Beauclerk winced at her mother’s words, and Catherine felt the sting of them herself. She had been on the verge of refusing, of pleading letters and household matters requiring her attention, but instead she said, “I have some commissions of my own, ma’am, and I should be very glad of Miss Beauclerk’s company.”

Henry smiled down at her, a smile in which Miss Beauclerk had no part, and pressed her hand. “Very well, then. You two shall look after one another, and MacGuffin shall look after you both.”

“Delightful!” cried Miss Beauclerk. “What a handsome fellow we shall have beauing us about, Mrs. Tilney!” She scratched the dog’s ear, and he put back his head, eyes closed in ecstasy.

***

“Will you take some claret, Henry?” asked the general.

Henry accepted the glass of wine and sipped it silently. On the walk to Milsom-street, the general had spoken of some improvements he had recently made to the offices at Northanger Abbey and asked after Henry’s shrubbery. Henry let the general lead the conversation, waiting for him to introduce the subject of Lady Beauclerk, but the general seemed more interested in asking after his tenants at Woodston.

“You are very quiet today,” said the general. “Surely you do not still hold a grudge about that misunderstanding last year with your wife? I allowed your marriage, and that should be an end to it. No one can say I am a tyrannical father.”

“No one is saying you are a tyrannical father. The gossips of Bath have much more interesting news to retail. Tell me, sir: when may I offer you my congratulations on your impending marriage to Lady Beauclerk; and why did I not hear this news from your lips, but as common gossip known to everyone in Bath except your own children?”

“Gossip? Who gossips about the Tilneys?”

“Everyone who saw you conduct Lady Beauclerk to the Lower Rooms last night and to the pump-room this morning, and who knows you have been daily in her company for the past several months.” The General was silent. “Do you deny it, sir? Do you deny that you are trying to fix your interest with Lady Beauclerk, before her husband has been dead a year?”

The General poured another glass of wine. “No. I do not deny it.” He took a deep draught.

“It is well that you have been on the spot, as they say, for I see you have a few rivals here in Bath. Lady Beauclerk’s fortune is a handsome one, is it not? And will remain hers in the event of a remarriage?”

“Lady Beauclerk is a handsome woman, and a good neighbor and friend. It is not to be wondered at that she would have — admirers.”

Henry stared at his father. Could it be that this misguided courtship had more than financial motives? “I dare say the Abbey is a rather lonely place these days.”

“Some might find it so, but the military man has resources, Henry. Do not forget that.” He paused, thoughtful for a moment. “You suspect me of trying to acquire Lady Beauclerk’s fortune for my own, do not you? I confess that it is a handsome fortune, and not a small consideration.”

“Are you distressed for funds, sir? Has Frederick been extravagant, or got into debt? If that is the case, you must allow me to assist however is in my power — ”

The General waved his hand dismissively. “No, no; the estates are producing very well, as you know, and your brother has not overspent his allowance quite yet this quarter. Not that I could not use a little extra; who cannot? But Lady Beauclerk is a very pleasant woman, and very good company; very good company, indeed. I would be proud to have her bear the Tilney name.” He sipped his wine thoughtfully.

Henry Tilney was rarely at a loss for words; but finding his father in the midst of a romance served to rob him of speech completely.

Chapter Five

Something Very Shocking Indeed

The ladies’ departure from Laura-place was delayed first by Miss Beauclerk’s “running up for a moment” to fetch her bonnet, pelisse, and parasol, a moment that turned into a quarter-hour, during which time the general and Henry left for Milsom-street.

They were further delayed by Lady Beauclerk’s insistence that her daughter’s maid accompany them, and her daughter’s insistence that they did not need such escort. “Mrs. Tilney and I will be one another’s chaperone, and MacGuffin here will provide us with more protection than Marie-Louise can.” The struggle of wills went on for several minutes whilst Catherine stood by, awkward at being forced to bear witness to it, but at last they made their escape.

By the time they reached Argyle-street, Catherine regretted her impulsive offer to accompany Miss Beauclerk. Miss Beauclerk floated along the pavement, everything about her as light as air, from the filmy lace that trimmed her pelisse to her delicate satin slippers. Catherine stumbled along, her thick leather shoes chosen with a mind to a country walk rather than to a city promenade, tethered to a living ten-stone weight that propelled her forward relentlessly and lurched off to either side whenever it smelled anything interesting.

As they crossed the bridge, Miss Beauclerk said, “Thank you for agreeing to be my companion, Mrs. Tilney. My maid reports all my movements to my mother. Not that there is anything to report, but it is a relief to feel oneself not constantly under the scrutiny of a servant with suspect loyalties. Now, what commissions have you? The linen-drapers, I dare say?”

“Truthfully, I have no commissions,” said Catherine. “I only said I did because Lady Beauclerk — ” she stopped, confused.

Miss Beauclerk laid a gloved hand on Catherine’s arm. “How very kind you are! I can see why Mr. Tilney is so wild about you; but you must not mind Mamma. She would very much like to talk to her friends about her daughter, Mrs. This or Lady That, but I have thwarted her. I am a regular old maid now, at seven and twenty, and she sometimes lets her disappointment get the better of her.”

“I do not see why you feel it so hopeless a case,” said Catherine. “Many girls marry who have not your advantages; you have a fortune, and you are very pretty.”

Miss Beauclerk looked at Catherine, startled, and then laughed. “Why, you dear creature! How funny you are. I dare say I could find a husband if I settled for the first fortune-hunter to make an offer; but I am, perhaps, too nice. We not all of us have a Henry Tilney in our sights.”

“Now that you are in Bath, I am sure you will meet someone. There are many young men here, and you had several partners at the assembly. But I dare say you have had seasons in Bath before, and even London.”

“There were no seasons in London for me, Mrs. Tilney! My father did not like cities, and disliked even more what he would have considered unnecessary expenditure. During his lifetime there were no trips to Bath, and certainly no houses taken in Laura-place. My mother is making up for a lifetime of deprivation.”

Such talk, so disrespectful of a father so lately dead, did not please Catherine, and she was silent. Miss Beauclerk did not seem to notice her disapproval, or at least was determined to ignore it. “Well, if you have no commissions, will you accompany me to the apothecary? I must have some of my special beauty tonic made up. The shop is a little out of the way, I am afraid.”

The apothecary’s shop was indeed out of the way, and Catherine was grateful for her canine escort as they entered a part of Bath she had never before seen. Close to the river, the buildings slouched and leaned upon one another, as did the individuals lounging in doorways and sauntering down the pavement. Some appeared as though they might approach the two ladies, and not with kind intentions, but a look from the shaggy Newfoundland kept them at a careful distance.

Catherine glanced at Miss Beauclerk, who appeared to take no notice of their singular surroundings. “There is a very good apothecary in Milsom-street,” she said. “Perhaps we could turn back, and you can obtain your potion there.”

“No,” said Miss Beauclerk, rather sharply. “It is a very particular kind of potion, and only can be trusted to someone who — oh, here it is.”

The apothecary’s premises turned out to be a dark little building at the end of a row of similarly mean-looking shops. Catherine did not feel right leaving MacGuffin on the pavement, at the mercy of passersby, so he accompanied them inside the shop and, at her command, sat by the door. Miss Beauclerk went to the counter whilst Catherine stopped to stroke the dog’s head and whisper, “I am sorry I brought you here, darling. We shall not be long.” He looked up at her trustingly, his feathery tail gently thumping the grimy floor.

As she turned away from MacGuffin, Catherine heard a man’s voice say, “Judith! What are you — ”

“Good day, Mr. Shaw,” said Miss Beauclerk, glancing consciously over her shoulder at Catherine.

The man to whom she spoke was extremely handsome — everything a hero should be: tall, dark, and mysterious; Valancourt verily come to life, though the practical part of Catherine’s mind could not help thinking that Emily would never have seen Valancourt in shirtsleeves and a green baize apron. But even Valancourt could not have gazed at his heroine with more obvious adoration than Mr. Shaw; his expression was one of mingled surprise, admiration, and something else — something hungry, thought Catherine, and then laughed at herself for being fanciful.

The man struggled for speech. “You are — you are in Bath?”

“Yes, my mother is here to take the waters, and how lucky that I was able to find your shop, since I have run out of the beauty tonic that you so obligingly made up for me.” She turned to Catherine. “Mrs. Tilney, may I present Mr. Shaw? He is a very clever apothecary — too much so for Beaumont, where he used to reside, and he has moved his practice to Bath, which I’m sure you will agree is just the place for an apothecary. He was invaluable during my father’s illness; poor Papa was in so much pain at the end, we were grateful for anything that would bring him relief, and Mr. Shaw’s potions always did so.”

“I was happy to be of service to you, Miss Beauclerk,” said Mr. Shaw. “And to your family, of course.”

“Of course,” said Miss Beauclerk with a smile, which Mr. Shaw returned; he stood staring at her for a moment, quite dazzled, until Miss Beauclerk reminded him gently, “My potion?”

“Yes! Yes, of course; right away; it will not take a moment to mix it up. Will you wait, or can I have it sent to — ?” The end of his sentence trailed off suggestively.

“We have taken a house in Laura-place,” said Miss Beauclerk. “But today, I shall wait.”

Mr. Shaw went into the back of the shop, and Miss Beauclerk said in a low voice. “Mr. Shaw comes from a very good family, really; but he must make his living. Younger son, you know.”

“Yes,” said Catherine. “Henry is a younger son.”

“So he is,” said Miss Beauclerk, smiling at her.

Just then a voice came from the back; not Mr. Shaw’s, but one of much more vulgar accents. “What do you need that for, then?”

A low murmuring followed; and the voice said, “What? You make that up for a young lady? What are you thinking, you fool?” More murmuring; and the voice said, “She’s right here in the shop? I’ll talk to her, you never mind.”

An elderly man in a frizzled wig and a green baize apron like Mr. Shaw’s emerged from the back of the shop, followed by the protesting Mr. Shaw.

“Introduce me to the lady, Ned, there’s a good lad,” said the older man.

“Miss Beauclerk,” said Mr. Shaw in tones of resignation, “may I present Mr. Walton?”

“I’ve been compounding since long before you were born, ma’am,” said the older man earnestly, “and I’m here to tell you that these beauty potions you young ladies will take do you no good, ma’am, you mark my words. They may make your skin white for a time, but the arsenic builds up in the humors, and poisons you in the end. You look like a good girl; you’ll listen to old Sam, you will, and leave off this potion.”

“Arsenic?” cried Catherine in alarm. “My dear Miss Beauclerk — you take arsenic?”

“It is trace amounts, ma’am,” said the harassed Mr. Shaw. “Not enough to harm anyone, I assure you; just enough to freshen the complexion; I would never harm — ” he broke off, confused.

Mr. Walton was much amused by his lackey’s confusion. “Oh, yes, that’s right, Neddy. You understand. You won’t let the young lady poison herself. If it’s a fresher complexion you’re seeking, miss, I recommend a bit of Gowland’s Lotion. For a patent potion it’s very effective; apply it every day, and keep out of the sun, and your skin will stay white and soft without the poison. You listen to old Sam.”

“Come, Mrs. Tilney,” said Miss Beauclerk coldly. “If we cannot procure the item we seek here, we must find it elsewhere.” She left the shop immediately, Catherine and MacGuffin following hastily behind.

They had not got far when they heard running footsteps behind them. MacGuffin pressed against Catherine’s legs and turned back to face their attacker; but it was only Mr. Shaw. He seized Miss Beauclerk’s hand. “Judith,” he said, “I have been in hell since I came here. You see the depths to which I have fallen.”

“I wonder why you stay there, then; I thought you came to Bath to open your own establishment.”

“I will require much more than I thought to set up my own shop. I am working at Walton’s only until I save enough — only a few more months, I swear it. Then I will be my own man. And now that our obstacle is removed — ”

Miss Beauclerk gave Catherine another conscious side-glance. “No! No, sir, do not speak so. My mother would not allow it, any more than my father did.”

“You are of age, Judith — ”

“I would be cut off from my family, and all good society. Do not ask this of me, sir. You know I have not the courage.”

Mr. Shaw’s handsome head drooped over her hand, still held tightly within his own. “Will I see you at the theatre tonight, at least?”

“Yes, we will be there.”

“May I sit with you?”

“You know that is not within my power.”

“But you will slip away and meet me, then?” His voice lowered. “I shall bring your potion.”

She sighed and gave a little toss of her head. “I shall try.”

He raised her hand to his lips and kissed it with violent affection. “Do I have your promise, my love?”

“Yes. Yes, you have it. Just be sure to bring the potion.”

Catherine thought a lover should look happier to make an assignation than Miss Beauclerk looked at the present moment, but she had not had experience of such clandestine romance before; nor of a gentleman who made love to a lady in the street, in front of several interested loungers and passersby.

“Until tonight, then.” He bobbed a sort of bow at Catherine and hurried back towards the shop.

As they walked back to Laura-place, Miss Beauclerk seemed inclined to be quiet, and Catherine allowed her to be so. Finally she said, “Mrs. Tilney, I must ask you a favor; on such a short acquaintance as ours, I have no right; but I pray you will not mention this to my mother.”

“Yes, I suppose she might worry if she knew about your tonic.”

Miss Beauclerk looked her surprise. “She knows about my tonic, and what it contains. She uses something similar herself. It was due to her influence that I asked Mr. Shaw to provide it. Mother has her own supplier. But I meant meeting Mr. Shaw. She does not quite approve of my seeing him. I did not intend to — but it is too late for that. I pray you will not mention it.”

Catherine promised that she would not as they entered Laura-place.

“Will you come in for a moment?” asked Miss Beauclerk. “You may take leave of Mamma, and let her know that I have not been wandering the streets of Bath alone, and getting into mischief.”

Catherine thought her request rather extraordinary, but did not know how to refuse it.

They arrived at the door of Lady Beauclerk’s house at the same time that a dowdy chaise, drawn by a pair of shaggy horses, drew up. An elderly servant in well-worn livery climbed down heavily from his perch and, seeing Miss Beauclerk staring at him, waved and grinned toothlessly.

“Oh, Lord,” said Miss Beauclerk under her breath.

Catherine looked at the servant curiously. “Who is that?”

“He is my aunt Findlay’s man. Well, Mrs. Tilney, it seems that you will have the opportunity to meet one of the more eccentric members of my family, arrived with her usual fortunate timing just as we thought to pass ourselves off creditably in Bath.”

Catherine, unsure how to respond, said, “I have a great-aunt who likes to read me lectures.”

“Then you understand what it means to have a relative whose main purpose in life is to mortify one.”

The servant opened the chaise door and let down the steps, and his mistress emerged: a woman tall and solidly built, with a great beak of a nose and a long chin to match. She looked up at the house and said, “Of course she took one of the grandest houses in Bath. Such unwonted extravagance! But that is your mother all over, Judith. What my poor brother would have thought of it, I am sure I do not know.”

“Good day, aunt,” said Miss Beauclerk.

“Good day, indeed! Do not think I have not heard what you all have been up to, aye, and that ne’er-do-well nephew of mine, too. I have my informants, miss.”

“I am sure you do, aunt.” Seeing how Mrs. Findlay stared at Catherine, she added, “May I present Mrs. Tilney to your notice?”

“Tilney, eh? I have heard that name, oh yes indeed. I know what your set is up to.” Mrs. Findlay swept past both ladies and the footman who held the door. “I trust I need not send up my card; I trust the dowager will see her poor widowed sister.”

“Oh, dear,” whispered Miss Beauclerk. “Mamma will not like it if my aunt insists on calling her ‘the dowager.’”

“Perhaps I should just go back to our lodgings,” said Catherine.

“No, no; Mamma will take it amiss if you do not come up, just for a moment. Pray do, ma’am.”

Catherine could not resist a supplication made with such softly pleading eyes; and she was herself interested in seeing her ladyship’s reaction to being called “the dowager.”

The footman said to her, “Begging your pardon, ma’am, but your dog looks like he could use a drink of water. I can take him to the kitchen if you like.”

Catherine looked at MacGuffin’s hanging tongue and agreed, and the Newfoundland padded down the hall behind the footman as the ladies climbed the stairs to her ladyship’s sitting-room.

Sir Philip was there, paying his daily duty call upon his aunt; he acknowledged Catherine with a nod and a smile, which she returned, still grateful for his kindness of the previous evening.

Mrs. Findlay was berating her sister-in-law. “It had to be Laura-place, did it not, Agatha? No Queen-squares for you, ma’am! And my poor brother not cold in his grave. ’Tis not enough that one of you disposed with him, but you must revel in it by making merry with his fortune!”

“I am sure that I do not know what you are talking about, Fanny,” said her ladyship; though her blush did not escape Catherine’s sharp eye.

“I believe you do, Agatha; I know one of you does. You,” she said, looking at Sir Philip, “or you,” turning a glare upon her niece.

“What are you suggesting, madam?” asked Sir Philip, his voice low and dangerous.

“I suggest nothing, sir; I state it for all to hear. I am come to Bath to determine which of you murdered my brother.”

Chapter Six

Murder and Everything of the Kind

Mrs. Findlay’s words shocked all present into silence.

“Really, Fanny,” said Lady Beauclerk in a faint tone of voice. “You must be reading horrid novels to imagine such a thing. Poor Sir Arthur, murdered! After he suffered so! I am sure that no man could have been more tenderly nursed by his wife and daughter.”

“Giving you the perfect opportunity to assist his exit from this world. And you,” said Mrs. Findlay, rounding on Sir Philip, “always hanging around and ingratiating yourself with the old man. You did not think he would hear about your unsavory adventures, did you? You are fortunate he did not cut you out of the will!”

“Beaumont is entailed,” said Sir Philip. “Whatever my uncle thought of me — and I think, and hope, he thought well — he did not have the power to disinherit me.”

“From the title and the estate, perhaps not; but what of the funded monies? I know of a few provisions in the entailment that would have put you in a very uncomfortable situation indeed: master of a great estate, and unable to afford to run it!”

“There was no reason for my uncle to change the provisions of his will,” said Sir Philip with a touch of impatience.

“No reason? After the way you carried on in Brighton last summer? To think I would live to see a Beauclerk involved in a criminal conversation!”

Catherine was paying little attention to the argument between Sir Philip and his aunt. She was thinking over everything she had learned that afternoon: that Sir Arthur’s sister thought his death had not been natural; that both Lady Beauclerk and her daughter had private, secret access to strong poison; and that the apothecary who provided Miss Beauclerk with that poisonous potion had tended Sir Arthur in his last days. A younger Catherine might have reached a most alarming conclusion indeed; but as Henry had once bid her, she now consulted her own sense of the probable. It did not seem possible that a man such as Sir Arthur Beauclerk, tended by a retinue of servants and physicians, could be the victim of a murderous plot; but the Beauclerks were an unhappy family, and who could tell to what measures the desperate might resort?

Sir Philip, mistaking Catherine’s thoughtfulness for distress, or perhaps just embarrassed that an outsider was witnessing the incident, said, “Mrs. Tilney should not have to listen to this.”

Mrs. Findlay whirled about. “Tilney! I have heard that name. You may tell General Tilney, madam, that he is in my sights as well. Sniffing round the widow before my poor brother had been dead half a year! I dare say that fancy Abbey of his costs a pretty penny to run. He’ll have a mind to your jointure, Agatha, you may depend upon it.”

“That is enough, aunt,” said Sir Philip. He crossed the room to where Catherine stood and took her elbow. “Let me procure a chair to take you home, ma’am.”

“Yes, let Philip help you,” said Miss Beauclerk. “Thank you for coming out with me this morning, Mrs. Tilney, and I hope to see you tonight at the theatre.”

Catherine hastily took her leave; Sir Philip escorted her down the stairs and waited with her while the footman went off to fetch MacGuffin.

“May I get you a chair?”

“Oh, no; my lodgings are just a few steps away, and I have my dog.”

“One of the footmen could bring your dog to your lodgings, and you are distressed by my aunt Findlay’s nonsense. Pray let me procure you a chair.”

“Oh, I am not distressed,” said Catherine.

He looked at her closely. “Are you not?”

“No, sir; I am perfectly able to walk; but is very kind of you to think of it.”

“Most women would have a fit of the vapors at overhearing such an extraordinary declaration as my aunt’s. I salute you, Mrs. Tilney.”

Catherine smiled and blushed as the footman returned, leading MacGuffin.

Sir Philip looked at the Newfoundland and said, “Good Lord. No, you need no chair, Mrs. Tilney; you could ride this fellow home.”

Catherine considered this. “Henry talks of training him to pull a little cart to give rides to the children of our parish. But that would not do for me.”

Sir Philip smiled. “Indeed not, madam; though he is a handsome lad.” He bent to pet MacGuffin, but the dog pressed against Catherine and made a sound somewhere between a snort and a growl.

“For shame, Mac!” cried Catherine. “Sir Philip means me no harm.” MacGuffin looked up at her with sorrowful eyes. To Sir Philip she said, “He really is a very good-natured creature in general.”

“He probably caught a scent of Lady Josephine upon me. That deuced creature will get my coat all over hair when I call upon my aunt.”

“Yes, that must be the case. Good day, Sir Philip, and thank you again for your kindness.”

“It was my pleasure, ma’am. Did I hear my cousin say that you would be at the theatre tonight?”

“Yes, Lord Whiting procured a box and invited us to join him.”

“May I look forward to the pleasure of visiting your box between acts?”

Catherine was unsure of the proper response to such a proposal. “Why — yes, I dare say his lordship will not mind.”

“That is very good of you to say.” He raised her gloved hand to his lips. “Until tonight.”

Catherine, blushing at such attention, hastily said good-bye and left the house. As she reached Pulteney-street, she could not help looking back; Sir Philip still stood in the doorway of his aunt’s house, watching after her with a little smile.

***

The maidservant had just placed the final touches on her hair when Henry entered Catherine’s dressing-room. He surveyed her with pleasure. “Very lovely, my sweet. Whiting and Eleanor join us for dinner; I saw them at Milsom-street, and did not think you would mind.”

“No, of course not.” She dismissed the maid and turned to Henry eagerly. “What did your father say?”

“As we suspected, he is considering marriage with Lady Beauclerk, but has made no declaration.”

“Will he, do you think?”

“I cannot say; I do not think he knows his own mind.”

Catherine had a brief struggle with her conscience, trying to decide if she should tell Henry about the scene in Laura-place; but since General Tilney was involved, she reasoned he would hear about it soon enough. She related her adventure of the afternoon: the visit to the apothecary, Miss Beauclerk’s beauty potion, her aunt’s accusations. At the end, Henry looked thoughtful.

“Do you think Sir Arthur was murdered, Henry?”

“He had been ill for many months before his death.”

“Well, I am sure General Tilney was not involved.”

“As we were in Bath last year when Sir Arthur died, I dare say not; a circumstance that casts doubt on the rest of Mrs. Findlay’s allegations.”

“But Henry, what of the potion? Miss Beauclerk and her mother use a beauty potion that contains arsenic.”

“As do many ladies, as your Mr. Shaw pointed out.”

“He is not my Mr. Shaw.”

“I am glad to hear it; I would not like to be forced to nurture jealousy of this Adonis of an apothecary.”

“He is in love with Miss Beauclerk at any rate.”

“And much good may it do him.”

Catherine looked curiously at Henry, who was frowning at his reflection and adjusting his cravat. “You speak as though Miss Beauclerk is a great flirt.”

“You have been in her company long enough to discover that for yourself, Cat.”

“Yes; but — you seem to have personal knowledge.”

Henry looked down at her, smiling. “Could it be that you suspect me of nurturing a broken heart? I do not like to make myself appear less heroic to you, my sweet; but until I met you, the only romance in my life took the shape of four duodecimo volumes from Mrs. Radcliffe and her sisterhood.”

“But, Henry, Lady Beauclerk said that the neighborhood wondered who would catch you. I thought you must have had many flirts.”

“Lady Beauclerk exaggerated. I had no flirts, and the young ladies of Gloucestershire were much more interested in the Tilney heir than the cadet. Is there room for me?” She slid over on the bench in front of her dressing-table, and he sat next to her. “That’s better.”

“Even Miss Beauclerk? She is always saying how much she would like to be married to someone like you.”

“Very complimentary of Judith! I must remember to thank her for it.” Seeing Catherine’s grave expression, he continued, “We were childhood playmates, until we both were sent away to school. When I was at Oxford, she was the belle of the neighborhood, and paid no attention to me whatsoever, which suited me perfectly. Judith is not without ambition, and that ambition does not include a younger son and a country parsonage.”

”Then why does she flirt with you now, when you are married?“

“Perhaps she flirts because I am married; she knows I am safe from her arts. I think Miss Beauclerk is unable to interact with my sex without flirtation, and I suspect it does not always serve her well. Witness poor Mr. Shaw. He may harbor hope, Cat, but I assure you that he will never take Judith Beauclerk to wife.”

Catherine thought of the expression on Mr. Shaw’s face when he looked at Miss Beauclerk. “The poor man! But I am glad to hear that Miss Beauclerk has not used you ill. If she had, I could not be her friend.”

Henry smiled, put his arm around her waist, and murmured, “My darling defender!”

She obliged him in a kiss, but drew back immediately; at his surprised expression, she said, “I do not want to spoil your cravat.”

“Thwarted by my own vanity! There is a lesson hard-learnt. And I suppose I should have a similar care for your gown.” He released her with obvious reluctance.

“You should; besides, Eleanor and John will be here soon, and I must finish dressing. Help me with my necklace, and then I will be ready.”

Henry obligingly stood and moved behind her to fasten the chain; if he placed a few kisses on the nape of her neck while he performed this service, I hope the generous reader will not find it wonderful.

Chapter Seven

Brittle and Beautiful

The maidservant brought out trays of fruit and sweetmeats and a decanter of sweet wine and slipped away, leaving them to talk freely.

“Tell Eleanor and Whiting about your adventure today, Cat,” said Henry.

Catherine related her tale, which entertained his lordship mightily but left Eleanor frowning. “If my father intends to marry Lady Beauclerk,” she said, “it will not do to have such talk about. And you know Mrs. Findlay will not scruple to repeat it to everyone in Bath.”

“Consider the positive, my love,” said her husband. “Perhaps if the talk gets about, General Tilney will change his mind about marrying the Merry Widow.”

“Naturally I wish my father to be happy,” said Eleanor, “but I confess I would rather he found happiness elsewhere.”

“Indeed,” said Henry. “I am glad that Lady Beauclerk has procured her own box tonight at the theatre, and we need not share it with her traveling circus.”

“Oh dear,” said Catherine, distressed at Henry’s words. “Sir Philip asked if he could visit me in our box, and I did not quite know what to say — I told him he might do so.”

“Never mind,” said Lord Whiting. “Those awkward moments always put one at a loss. It would have been better for Beauclerk to wait for an invitation rather than putting himself forward so. Tilney and I will send him to the rightabout, Catherine; your reputation will not be compromised.”

“My reputation?”

Henry and his lordship exchanged glances.

“Beauclerk,” said Henry, “likes to — entertain himself with married women.”

Catherine turned to Henry with a look of alarm. “You do not think that I — ”

“Of course not,” said Henry with a smile.

“I wish you had told me,” said Catherine. “I would not have danced with him last night, even if it meant that I would sit out. Perhaps my reputation is already compromised! And he will be looking for me at the theatre tonight!”

“As far as things have gone, a few dances at a public assembly, there is no harm done,” said Eleanor.

Catherine remembered liberties taken by a drunken gallant at the rooms, and thought there had been harm done enough.

“Beauclerk was named in a divorce last summer,” said his lordship. “Apparently a servant overheard an incriminating conversation.”

“Mrs. Findlay said he was involved in a criminal conversation in Brighton,” said Catherine.

“A nasty business, and he refused to marry the lady involved after her husband obtained a divorce, so she was obliged to retire to the country.”

“How dreadful! I shall not accept any invitations from him in future, to dance or anything else. He was so kind to me! How mistaken I have been.”

“It is never wrong to respond to kindness with gratitude,” said Henry. “But you need feel no lingering obligation, my sweet.”

“But if General Tilney should marry Lady Beauclerk, I dare say we shall see a great deal of him.”

“We shall concern ourselves with that when the happy event occurs.”

“I hate the idea of that woman in my mother’s place,” said Eleanor with unaccustomed warmth.

“As do I,” said Henry. “But we have no right to interfere.”

“But do we have the duty? When she will bring such profligacy into our family?”

“Your notions of duty have always been very nice, Eleanor,” said Henry. “Were you still unmarried, I would protest, or take you to live at Woodston should the general marry Lady Beauclerk, but as we both are no longer living under his roof, I think we must let him make up his own mind. And I remind you, Eleanor: his mind is not yet made up. It is by no means determined that this marriage will happen.”

“But in the meantime he makes us the subject of unkind gossip,” said Eleanor. “We must speak to him, Henry. We must convince him that he is pursuing an unwise course.”

“Not yet,” said her brother. “The General has long military experience and is a wily opponent. A well-led army’s first weapon is good intelligence. We need more information before we plan our campaign.”

Catherine looked at her husband thoughtfully. Henry spoke lightly, but he seemed to have given the matter a great deal of thought; indeed, one might say he already had conceived a scheme.

***

Lord Whiting’s carriage brought them to the theatre in good time, and they were established in their box before the curtain raised on the first act. Catherine was prepared to enjoy herself, and the comings-and-goings and incessant noise made by those who had no interest in the stage did not interfere in her pleasure.

Midway through the first act, Lady Beauclerk’s party arrived, including General Tilney and several of Lady Beauclerk’s other suitors; as Henry had pointed out, the general was a wily campaigner, and managed to secure the seat directly next to her ladyship’s. Sir Philip attended his cousin; he caught Catherine’s eye, and bowed and smiled.

She did not dare to look in his direction again until the intermission; when she looked, he was gone, and she prepared herself to receive his visit.

Several of Lord Whiting’s friends had joined them, and the box was crowded. When Sir Philip made his appearance, Henry stood and blocked him from entering the box.

“It is very obliging of you to stop by, Beauclerk,” he was saying, “but you see we are a full house at the moment.”

Sir Philip looked at Catherine, who sat with her head down, blushing, her eyes fixed upon her fan. “Yes; full indeed. Pray convey my compliments to Mrs. Tilney.”

“I will be sure to do so.”

Sir Philip left, and Catherine let out a sigh of relief. Henry sat next to her, and she squeezed his hand gratefully.

Henry whispered, “All well, Cat?”

“Yes; thank you for sending him away, Henry. I could not bear his compliments after what I learnt of him today.”

“If he does not take the hint, a few more repetitions ought to do the trick, unless he is a blockhead, or very much in love with you; for which I cannot fault him.”

“You always know the right thing to say; and you were so dignified, so completely civil!”

“I thank you for the compliment, my sweet; and I am always at your service to dispose with your persistent suitors.”

“I hope you will not have to do so another time.”

“Alas, I fear I will; it is the price paid when a man takes a pretty wife.”

Catherine blushed and disclaimed, but her eyes were bright with happiness and affection. Henry could ask nothing more.

***

Catherine hung onto Henry’s arm as they exited the theatre in the crush of merry, chattering humanity all attempting to do the same thing.

Henry looked around. “I fear we have become separated from Eleanor and Whiting, Cat.” He expertly steered them into a gap, past a couple of stately matrons desperately clutching at the nodding feathers in their hair. “There is no need for you to get tossed about in this crowd,” he said. “Wait here by this column; I will find Whiting’s servant and come back for you.”

Glad to be out of the tumult, Catherine stood close to the column and watched the ladies, inspecting their gowns for details she might copy for her own wardrobe.

A familiar voice came from the other side of the column. “Judith, I beg you — ”

“I must go. My mother will be looking for me.”

“I can take you away from her oppression forever, my love, my heart! I cannot live without you, Judith! Say you will be mine!”

Catherine peeked around the column; the lovers proved to indeed be Mr. Shaw and Miss Beauclerk. She listened in spite of herself, because she had never before heard a man who talked so exactly like the hero of a novel.

“I am grateful for the services you have performed for me,” said Miss Beauclerk. “But I find your continued declarations most tiresome in the face of my previous professions on the subject.”

“Services? You can talk of services? When I would do anything for you, my own heart? When I have done for you — ”

“Do not speak of it,” said Miss Beauclerk in a low, urgent voice. “Not here.”

Catherine’s eyes widened in spite of herself. What services could Mr. Shaw have performed that must not be discussed in a public place? Could it be — could Mrs. Findlay’s accusations have merit? Henry and Lord Whiting had laughed at the idea, but —

“Mrs. Tilney,” said a familiar voice, low and familiar, in her ear. She jumped, startled, and whirled about to see Sir Philip.

“Oh!” she cried. “You startled me!”

“Indeed? If so, I beg your pardon, madam. I would not make you feel any discomfort for the world; unlike, I think, some others.”

Catherine had no idea what he meant, and looked her surprise.

“Do you not understand me? Ah, you are young; but I saw your blush tonight when your husband prevented me from meeting you. I suspect the apple does not fall far from the tree in the Tilney family.”

She blushed again, remembering what she had learnt of Sir Philip. “I beg your pardon, sir, but I must go; Henry will be looking for me.”

“Oh, well, then. I should not like to be the agent of unpleasantness for you. Until another time.” He bowed, and Catherine turned away, confused by his words, only to be startled by Mrs. Findlay’s manservant, clutching a lamp and leading his mistress.

Mrs. Findlay looked from Catherine’s blushing countenance to Sir Philip and back again, and smiled most unpleasantly. “Oho!” she said. “Caught in the act!”

“You have caught nothing, ma’am. I wish you good night.” Catherine hastily curtsied and proceeded outside the theatre as quickly as she could through the thinning crowd.

She met Henry by the door. “What is it?” he said upon seeing her expression.

“Sir Philip and Mrs. Findlay,” she said. “Please take me home, Henry.”

“With all possible speed, my sweet.” He put his arm around her waist and swept her through the crowds and into Lord Whiting’s carriage, where his lordship and Eleanor waited to receive her and make her comfortable. Catherine leaned against Henry’s sleeve and sighed.

“Better now, Cat?” he asked.

“Yes, thank you.”

“What is it, Catherine dearest?” asked Eleanor gently.

“Sir Philip would talk to me, and though I put him off, Mrs. Findlay saw us, and I believe she has drawn the wrong conclusion.”

“Never mind,” said his lordship. “Everyone must know that Mrs. Findlay’s gossip is nonsense. First, accusations of murder, and now adultery! No one family has so much melodrama in these modern times. No one will pay her any mind.”

“I hope you are right,” said Catherine. “I overheard Miss Beauclerk and Mr. Shaw talking about services that he performed for her. It sounded most sinister; but I am sure he only meant making up her potion.” She shook her head. “Such nonsense! I liked the play very much. Did not you?”

His lordship looked chagrined, and Eleanor laughed at him. “You paid no attention to it, did you, my love?”

“Well, no; but that is not why one goes to the theatre.”

“Catherine likes a play very well,” said Henry.

His lordship bowed. “Another time I shall be quiet and let you enjoy it.”

“I could hear perfectly well, sir; I thank you for inviting me.”

“I am sorry your evening had a sad end,” said Lord Whiting.

“To make up for tonight,” said Henry, “Tomorrow we will have our walk. Eleanor, Whiting, will you join us? We thought to walk along the river and up to Beechen Cliff, retracing our steps from last year.”

They agreed to meet at the pump-room at noon, and Catherine’s evening had a happier ending than she would have thought when she first entered the carriage.

***

At this moment, Emily’s dislike of Count Morano rose to abhorrence. That he should, with undaunted assurance, thus pursue her, notwithstanding all she had expressed on the subject of his addresses, and think, as it was evident he did, that her opinion of him was of no consequence, so long as his pretensions were sanctioned by Montoni, added indignation to the disgust which she had felt towards him. She was somewhat relieved by observing that Montoni was to be of the party, who seated himself on one side of her, while Morano placed himself on the other. There was a pause for some moments as the gondolieri prepared their oars, and Emily trembled from apprehension of the discourse that might follow this silence. At length she collected courage to break it herself, in the hope of preventing fine speeches from Morano, and reproof from Montoni. To some trivial remark which she made, the latter returned a short and disobliging reply; but Morano immediately followed with a general observation, which he contrived to end with a particular compliment, and, though Emily passed it without even the notice of a smile, he was not discouraged.

“I have been impatient,” said he, addressing Emily, “to express my gratitude; to thank you for your goodness; but I must also thank Signor Montoni, who has allowed me this opportunity of doing so.”

Emily regarded the Count with a look of mingled astonishment and displeasure.

“Why,” continued he, “should you wish to diminish the delight of this moment by that air of cruel reserve? — Why seek to throw me again into the perplexities of doubt, by teaching your eyes to contradict the kindness of your late declaration? You cannot doubt the sincerity, the ardour of my passion; it is therefore unnecessary, charming Emily! surely unnecessary, any longer to attempt a disguise of your sentiments.”

“If I ever had disguised them, sir,” said Emily, with recollected spirit, “it would certainly be unnecessary any longer to do so. I had hoped, sir, that you would have spared me any farther necessity of alluding to them; but, since you do not grant this, hear me declare, and for the last time, that your perseverance has deprived you even of the esteem, which I was inclined to believe you merited.”

Catherine sat up. “Henry, please read that again,” she said.

“Which part?”

“Emily’s last part.”

“Very well,” said Henry, and repeated the last paragraph.

“That is very good,” said Catherine. “It is just the thing for me to say to Sir Philip when you are not there, do not you think?”

Henry looked at her, his brow creased. “Did Beauclerk impose upon you?”

“Oh, no! But I think he has formed a — a wrong idea. I just need to explain it to him. Do not you think that is a good way to say it?”

“The meaning could not be clearer.”

“Let me see the book.” She took the volume and read it over several times, repeating it aloud. She handed the book back to Henry. “Will you hear me recite?”

“With pleasure.”

“Sir Philip,” said Catherine solemnly, “Hear me declare, and for the last time, that your perseverance has deprived you even of the esteem which I was inclined to believe you merited.”

“Full marks. You make an excellent pupil, my sweet.”

Catherine laid her head upon his shoulder with a happy sigh. “Now I shall not be at a loss if he makes me uncomfortable again. I shall say to myself, ‘What would Emily do?’ and I shall have my guide.”

“You would be better guided by your own good sense, Cat. There is more worth here,” touching her head gently, “and here,” brushing his fingers over her heart, “than in all of Mrs. Radcliffe’s works, charming as they are.” He lifted her chin gently with a finger and kissed her.

“Oh, Henry,” said Catherine with a sigh. “I do not want to think about Sir Philip any more.”

“I am very glad to hear it.” He reached out to extinguish the candle.

Chapter Eight

Most Alarming Adventures

Catherine prepared for church the next morning with a lingering expectation that the expedition to Beechen Cliff would be put off by some emergency; the general requiring his son’s company, or a summons from the Beauclerks that could not be ignored. Indeed there was almost a delay, as Eleanor wished to call briefly in Laura-place to leave a receipt for rosewater cold cream in which Lady Beauclerk had expressed an interest.

“Matthew can take the note to her ladyship,” said Henry, and Eleanor, who did not relish that duty, was happy enough to surrender it. Catherine thought she saw a significant look pass between Henry and Matthew as the note was handed over, but it was soon forgotten in a flutter of anticipatory pleasure. The charm of a country walk with Henry had not abated upon her marriage, and Catherine was as happy as she had been during a similar walk a year earlier; it could be argued she was even happier, as she now had the right to take Henry’s arm and walk beside him, talk to him and be the first object of his interest; a state which Henry enjoyed no less than she.

Most of Bath was promenading upon the Royal Crescent, and they were nearly alone by the river, so Henry let MacGuffin off the leash. In his delight at being outside and unrestrained, the Newfoundland reverted to rather puppyish behavior, cavorting along the edge of the river and chasing some mallards who lounged on the bank.

The mallards, indignant at their Sunday repose being spoiled, squawked and flapped their wings at MacGuffin; undaunted, he barked and teased them, challenging them to a game they had no desire to play, ending it by the simple expedient of entering the river and swimming away. MacGuffin stood on the riverbank, barking after them; there was a splash, and MacGuffin was in the river, swimming after the ducks.

“I suspected he would end up in the water,” said Henry, not at all disturbed by his pet’s behavior.

“Oh! Henry! Get him out!” cried his sister. “Will he not drown?”

“Newfoundlands are famous swimmers, Eleanor. I have trained Mac to retrieve in the pond at home.”

MacGuffin was indeed a strong swimmer, but the ducks were in their natural element, and soon outstripped him. He made a wide turn in the water, became caught a little in the current — Eleanor gasped, and Catherine’s heart was in her mouth — but he soon was climbing up onto the riverbank and running back towards them, bounding with energy and canine happiness.

“That will do very well, lad,” said Henry. “You have had your swim, and now must stay with your master.”

MacGuffin shook himself violently, spraying water all over them. He stood before them, his fur standing on end; his tail wagged wildly, thick strings of saliva suspended from his panting mouth, but his joy was obvious; to Catherine, he looked almost as though he were laughing. He turned and bounded ahead of them along the riverbank towards the steep climb up to Beechen Cliff.

Catherine could not help laughing at the dog’s comical appearance; her companions, busily employing their handkerchiefs to dry themselves as best they could, looked at each other and burst into laughter.

“Trained him to retrieve, did you, Tilney?” said his lordship. “I think you need to train him a little more.”

“Mac is a good dog,” said Catherine, remembering how he had tried to protect her from Sir Philip Beauclerk the previous day. “He is still a puppy, really.”

“Indeed he is; and we must all be forgiven our youthful trespasses,” said Henry with a smile. Catherine took his arm once again, and the party proceeded to where MacGuffin stood waiting for them at the base of Beechen Cliff.

* * *

Lady Beauclerk’s butler gave Matthew a careful once-over. The young man was clean, plainly dressed, unremarkable in every way, and his demeanor was respectful; there was no reason to make him wait outside like a common tradesman. He stood back from the open door and said, “You may wait here whilst I ascertain if her ladyship wishes to respond.”

Matthew entered and stood in an out-of-the-way corner in the entry. The butler nodded approvingly, placed the note on a silver tray and carried it off.

A maidservant walked past, her arms full of folded sheets. She paused when she saw Matthew, and her gaze traveled over his person. “Beg pardon,” she said, curtseying.

Matthew noticed the shapely ankle she managed to display as she did so, and her no less shapely figure. As she looked up from the curtsey, she caught his eye boldly, and he winked at her.

“Oh!” she said, not at all put out. “Bold as brass, aren’t you? See something you like?”

“Perhaps,” he said.

“Who’s your governor, then?”

“Mr. Tilney,” said Matthew.

“Mr. Tilney?” asked the maidservant. “General Tilney’s son?”

“Yes.”

The maidservant giggled behind her hand; a habit that Matthew normally found distasteful, but knew it would not be wise for him to say so at the present juncture.

“That will do, Biddy,” said the butler, returning to the entry. “There is no reply,” he said to Matthew.

Matthew nodded and made as though to leave, but Biddy said, “Come down to the kitchen, Mr. Perhaps, if you’ve no other duty right now; Cook’ll give you a mug of beer.”

Matthew glanced at the butler, who sniffed disdainfully and walked away. He followed Biddy down to the kitchens, a level below the street in the back of the house.

“That’s more than His Nibs up there will give you, ducky,” said Biddy as they descended. “Won’t get a farthing out of that one, run all over Bath though you will, fetching and carrying. They keep you running, these Tilneys, do they?”

“Mr. Tilney keeps me busy, yes.”

“He seems a right one; not too high in the instep. Not like the old man.”

“Mr. Tilney is a very kind — governor.”

“Oh, I’ve heard no ill of him. Here, Cooky,” she said, entering the steaming kitchen, “I’ve got a gentleman caller. Give him a mug of beer while I take these to the linen-room.”

“A gentleman caller?” The cook looked over Matthew with a sharp eye. “He looks too good for the likes of you, Biddy Johnson.”

“He’s Mr. Tilney’s man, brought a note to her ladyship.”

“Oh, aye. Sit down, love, we’ll give you a bit of bite and sup.” And within a few moments there were a mug of foamy ale and some bread and cheese before him on the wooden table. He found he was hungry, and partook heartily, which the cook watched with approval before turning to the counter where her underlings cut vegetables and cleaned fowl in preparation for the evening meal.

Biddy had disappeared briefly, but soon came back and sat disconcertingly close to him on the long bench.

“What’s your name, then?” she asked.

“Matthew.”

“Is that your Christian name or your family name?”

He smiled at her and said, “It will do for both.”

“Have it your way, then, Mr. Perhaps. Have you been in the Tilney family long?”

“Two years, since Mr. Tilney took the Woodston living.”

“So you know General Tilney, then?”

“Aye.”

“He’s not very friendly, is he?”

Matthew, who had particular reason to know, said, “I find him a fair-minded man.”

“Mmm,” said Biddy. Under the table, she slid a slippered foot up the back of his leg, then down again. “I hear her ladyship is going to marry him.”

“I did not know the business was so far forward,” said Matthew.

“What’s to stop it? He’s a rich man, and you know one great fortune always looks out for another.”

“Her ladyship’s fortune is a large one?”

Biddy snorted. “Not as large as she wants people to think. I was dusting the hallway and happened to overhear her talking to her solicitor. That’s why she’s looking to make a great marriage. She’s living on credit right now; expects to get the money that Sir Arthur left in the Funds.”

“I thought Sir Philip was his heir.”

“Of the old pile he is, that was entailed. But apparently Sir Arthur didn’t like his nephew’s profligate ways. He had it put in his will that Sir P. only gets the money in the Funds if he marries his cousin.”

“Miss Beauclerk?”

“Aye. Though I don’t know as she’s so keen on the deal. That’s why her mamma thinks she will get the money; and if Miss Judith does marry her cousin, her ladyship will make a great marriage for herself with a rich man, one who will keep her in fine style, not like her husband. That one still had the first sixpence his papa gave him under his pillow when he popped off. Never spent a farthing he didn’t have to, and her ladyship’s making up for it now. I hope Miss Judith does marry Sir Philip, and takes me back to Beaumont with her. It’s hard enough for those in service to a pleasant family, but I don’t fancy having that General Tilney for a governor. I tried to act friendly-like to him, you know, just trying to get on his good side, and he drew up all prim around his mouth, as though I’d affronted him.”

Matthew tried to imagine the general’s reaction to Biddy’s “friendly-like” overtures, and had to hide his laughter in his mug of ale. When he had recovered, he asked, “Did you hear that Sir Arthur’s sister thinks someone murdered her brother?”

“Oh, aye!” cried Biddy, leaning forward and placing her hand on his knee. A lesser man might have jumped in alarm, but Matthew remained steady. “If the rest of them are out of the way, hanged or transported, you know old lady Findlay will come in for the fortune. A pretty good reason to start throwing about accusations, if you ask me. I bet Sir P. would pay a pretty penny to keep that away from the magistrate.”

Matthew grinned at her. “Do you act friendly-like to Sir P., then?”

“What, are you jealous?” Biddy laughed, and the impertinent foot began its travels once again.

“Have I anything to be jealous of?”

She leaned close and whispered, her breath warm in his ear, “Not hardly.”

Matthew judged her sufficiently distracted to return to the subject at hand. “Were you at Beaumont when Sir Arthur died?”

“I was, and the poor man suffered something terrible. I say it was a judgment on him for making his family so unhappy.”

“You do not think it was murder, then?”

“Who knows? They was all of them miserable enough to do him in.”

The cook looked over and said, “That’s enough of your gossiping, Biddy Johnson. See your young man out and get back to work, or the housekeeper will be after me.”

Biddy took Matthew by the hand and showed him out by the service entrance. She made it very clear that she expected him to steal a kiss, and he felt obligated to try; after all, if she were to remain a viable source of future information, it would be useful to be considered an interested suitor. Biddy’s protests at this assault on her virtue were rote and quite ineffectual, and if Matthew enjoyed the exercise more than was strictly necessary, we hope the reader will recall the young lady’s words about the hard life of those in service, and allow him a little indulgence.

Chapter Nine

The Most Unpromising Circumstance

The Tilneys and the Whitings separated at Argyle-buildings, and despite the fatigue of their long walk, their good-byes were cheerful. With MacGuffin, shaggy-haired and muddy-pawed from the day’s exertions, once more on his lead, Henry and Catherine turned towards Pulteney-street.

As they walked through Laura-place, they noticed a disturbance outside Lady Beauclerk’s house. A man stood in the doorway, arguing with the butler. As they passed, Catherine recognized him; she squeezed Henry’s arm and whispered, “That is Mr. Shaw.”

Apparently the butler had grown tired of the argument, and the door was closed with a stately finality that did not bode well for Mr. Shaw. He turned away and looked around the little square, as though wondering what to do next; the Tilneys had already passed when they heard him shout, “Miss! Miss! Please, miss!”

He caught up to them and touched Catherine’s arm. “It is you, is it not? Judith’s friend? I remember your dog.”

“Your dog, but not your name, apparently,” Henry murmured.

“Please, Miss, you must help me!” cried Mr. Shaw in urgent tones. “I beg you! Be my friend, as you are hers, Miss — Miss — ”

“Mrs. Tilney,” said Catherine. “Mr. Tilney, may I present Mr. Shaw, Miss Beauclerk’s — ” she cast about for the proper word — “friend.”

“Friend!” cried Mr. Shaw, raking his hands through his handsome mop of hair and disarranging it sadly. “I cannot even call myself that! Once so much to each other! Now so cold to me! Dismissed without even a glimpse — I would think that her mother or her cousin had intervened, but after my treatment at her hands last night, I know not what to think. You must help me, ma’am; intercede on my behalf. You must tell my angel what a dreadful mistake she has made in casting me off!”

“I think Miss Beauclerk must be left to make her own choice,” said Catherine.

“She made her choice, ma’am. She loved me, until her mother turned her head with seasons in Bath and houses in Laura-place, and a mere apothecary, even one of an ancient and noble family, though a lesser branch of course, is no longer good enough to be her husband.”

“Mr. Shaw,” said Henry, “I have known Miss Beauclerk and her family all my life. I assure you that if she truly wanted to marry you, she would not let inconsequential things such as duty and the honor of her family name stand in her way. She has given you her answer, and I advise you to accept it as best you can. I have rarely known Miss Beauclerk to turn from a path upon which she was determined.”

Mr. Shaw stared at him wildly. “You are one of them!” he cried, tearing at his hair once again. “You are one of the false friends who has contrived to separate us! You may fill my angel’s head with false ideas, you may introduce her to men of fortune and property who will shower her with riches, but you will fail, sir. One day you will learn that no one will ever love her as I do!” He turned on his heel, walked a few steps, and then stopped and turned back. “And one day she will regret casting me off, when she remembers the services I have performed for her!” He left them with all the dignity he could muster, leaving the Tilneys staring after him.

“Upon my word, Cat,” said Henry. “Your description of Mr. Shaw was very apt. He talks exactly like a hero in a novel.”

“That may do very well for Miss Beauclerk, but I think I should not like it in a husband.”

He smiled at her. “That is fortunate, for I should not be up to the task.”

MacGuffin, wearied of hard pavements and longing for his dinner and a long sleep by the fire, pulled impatiently on the lead, and they resumed their journey to Pulteney-street.

They had put off their coats and the maidservant had just left the tea things when Matthew appeared in the sitting room, almost between one blink and another, springing up like a hothouse plant.

“Were you able to procure any intelligence?” Henry asked him.

“Yes, sir; quite what you wished to learn, I believe.”

“Come in, sit down. Will you take tea?” He turned to Catherine. “I asked Matthew to take on the persona of a common servant in order to gain the confidence of Lady Beauclerk’s domestics and obtain what intelligence they were willing to share.”

Catherine passed Matthew a cup of tea. “I thank you, Mrs. Tilney. I made the acquaintance of a young maidservant, who has been in her ladyship’s service for some time. She also has developed a habit of listening at closed doors.”

“A valuable habit for our purposes,” said Henry.

“Yes, sir,” said Matthew, not quite approving. “Miss Biddy — the maidservant — told me that Lady Beauclerk’s fortune is not as extensive as her manner of living indicates.”

“Indeed? I understood that Sir Arthur controlled a large amount of funded money. One assumes he would have given his widow a comfortable jointure.”

“It may be comfortable, sir, but not lavish.”

“An important distinction. Pray go on.”

“The largest part of the funded money has been left to Sir Philip conditionally. He must marry Miss Beauclerk in order to gain control.”

“That must be why she has sent away Mr. Shaw!” cried Catherine. “It is all for ambition!”

“Judith had plenty of ambition before her father died,” said Henry. “She needed no such encouragement.”

“You did say that before,” said Catherine. “You said that she would never marry an apothecary.”

“Indeed. I tried to tell Mr. Shaw, but he had not ears to hear it. Matthew, did you learn what would happen if Beauclerk did not fulfill the provisions of his uncle’s will?”

“In that case, the money goes to Lady Beauclerk. She seems convinced that her daughter will refuse to marry Sir Philip, my informant said, and counts the fortune as very likely her own. However, she also is making alternative arrangements.”

“In the shape of a rich husband, I dare say.”

“As you say, sir.” He hesitated, and then said, “One more thing that Miss Biddy told me, sir; it is not directly applicable to this situation, but you may find it of interest. If the Beauclerks were not in a position to inherit the funded monies — for instance, if they were hanged or transported — the fortune will pass to Sir Arthur’s sister, Mrs. Findlay. Miss Biddy thought Sir Arthur a hard man, begging your pardon, sir. She expressed an opinion that the Beauclerks were an unhappy family, and that she would not be surprised at such an outcome.”

“And it gives Mrs. Findlay an excellent reason to make false accusations,” said Henry. “You look troubled, my sweet.”

“Beware getting too close to the truth,” said Henry. “Next you will receive a mysterious unsigned note warning you off, and any heroine worth her smelling salts cannot resist such a challenge. Matthew, you have done very well. I hope the formation of your acquaintance with Miss — Biddy, was it? — was not onerous.”

Matthew coughed and did not meet Henry’s eye; if he had, he might have seen the teasing humor lurking there. “I did my best to fulfill my duty, sir.”

“I hope your zealous pursuit of intelligence did not lead you to make overhasty declarations. But if it has, we shall make your lady welcome at Woodston. Mrs. Tilney has provided for you; it was her word that saved the little cottage beyond the orchard from being pulled down. It could be fitted up for a young family, I dare say — ”

“Oh, no, sir,” said Matthew, his face deep red.

“Do not tease him, Henry,” said Catherine. “Matthew deserves a much better wife than a mere maidservant who cannot even be trusted to keep her employer’s secrets.”

“Thank you, ma’am,” said Matthew with a gratified look.

Henry smiled, and said, “He does indeed deserve better; and I know he will seek better.”

“I have no such plans at present, sir, to — seek,” said Matthew, still blushing.

“A man never does,” said Henry.

***

The dark pressed in early, and even in the hour before dinner, Catherine needed candles to light her sewing. Henry had gone down to the kitchen to make sure MacGuffin had been brushed, fed, and watered after his adventures of the morning. She knew that Henry probably would end up brushing MacGuffin himself, and get his coat all over dog hair, but such a circumstance was not unusual and did not trouble her.

As was her custom while working, her mind ran on other matters than the task at hand, and her needle slowed as she considered all that had happened that day. When she had defended Matthew, Catherine had spoken instinctively; she did not know Matthew well. He was always pleasant and respectful, but his disposition was not open. It had never before occurred to her to wonder about his situation. He was Henry’s clerk, and wrote in a strong, elegant hand, so clearly he was an educated man; but then why had he been obliged to go into service? He had worked for Henry since he had taken over the living at Woodston, and was always there, dependable and steady, but so unobtrusive that she rarely thought of him except when he was needed or present. She realized she did not even know his surname.

Such an unremarkable young man — and yet so completely capable of gaining access to Lady Beauclerk’s house and the confidence of her servant! Mr. Shaw, for instance, could not have done such a thing. His first concern was himself, his own wishes and concerns, and he was not able to put those aside for duty. No wonder he worked for a vulgar apothecary, while Matthew had a comfortable, if not prominent, place at Woodston parsonage, where his singular skills were valued.

Such skills were not commonplace; yet how had someone like Matthew acquired them? Immediately a romantic past for Matthew sprung up in her imagination: perhaps he was a younger son from a great family, now fallen on hard times, or perhaps his mother had died and his father remarried to a cruel woman who would not allow him to assist his own children. Young Matthew, forced from his far-flung, retired home, had learned woodcraft for survival; thus his general reserve and silent movement. During a snowstorm, he was forced to ask for shelter at a country parsonage (a comfortable yet unpretending place, rather like Woodston), and the kind rector had taken in the orphan and given him the final polish on his education. Catherine smiled over her sewing, lost in dreams of romance and adventure.

Her solitude was broken by the little maidservant coming in with a note. Catherine did not recognize the handwriting; she broke open the wafer and read.

You have not been asking the right questions. If you wish to know all about the murder of Sir Arthur Beauclerk, go outside now. All will be explained.

The note was unsigned.

What had Henry just said about a mysterious, unsigned note? “Beware getting too close to the truth. Next you will receive a mysterious unsigned note warning you off, and any heroine worth her smelling salts cannot resist such a challenge.” Her mind swirled with possibilities: Lady Beauclerk, weary at a lifetime of harsh treatment; Miss Beauclerk, resisting overbearing parental authority with the help of a besotted apothecary; Sir Philip, desperate to keep his uncle from changing his will; Mrs. Findlay herself, attempting to set into action a cunningly planned series of events. It was just like a book! Though Catherine’s disposition was mostly quite unheroic, when presented with such a delicious adventure, what heroine could resist?

She went to the window and peered down onto Pulteney-street, looking for lurking figures; the darkness was almost full, and a fog swirled off the river, making it impossible to see anything. Catherine hesitated, then decided; someone was trying to tell her something, and she must know what happened. She threw a shawl about her shoulders and went downstairs.

She opened the door and peered outside; she saw no one. She took one step, then another, down the short path that crossed over the vaults below; as she drew close to the iron archway that marked the edge of the pavement, a hand reached out of the fog and seized her wrist. “You come with me now,” said a voice, and bore her inexorably away before she could breathe a word.

Chapter Ten

The Shades of Udolpho

The ruthless grip on her arm propelled Catherine down the pavement. In the swirling fog, she could not see where she was being taken or even identify her captor. One of Mrs. Radcliffe’s heroines might have swooned at such a moment, but Catherine had no idea of doing so.

“Who are you?” she demanded. “Let me go! Where are you taking me?”

Her abductor stopped and turned. A face came leering at her out of the mist; instinctively she raised her hand and prepared to cry out. . .

***

MacGuffin’s coat gleamed; all traces of mud and the Avon had been removed, and he was once again a pampered house pet rather than the wild-looking creature of nature he had been only a little while earlier. MacGuffin had no vanity, but he enjoyed the sensation of being brushed and the attention he received from his master, and wagged his tail gratefully.

Henry attempted to brush away some of the hair that had traveled from the dog to his own coat, but it soon proved a hopeless business.

“Matthew,” he said, “another time, remind me to take off my coat before brushing Mac.”

“Yes, Mr. Tilney,” said Matthew, who had done precisely that on the present occasion, but had not been heeded.

“Come along, Mac,” said Henry.

MacGuffin followed him very willingly upstairs, where, he knew, there would be scraps from his family’s evening meal and a warm fire to lie beside. He trotted ahead of his master in the entrance hallway and stopped to sniff at the door, which stood ajar.

Henry looked outside, and saw nothing but swirling fog; he wondered for a moment, and then shut the door. He went up the stairs to the drawing room, MacGuffin close behind.

“I think we must speak with the landlady, Cat,” said Henry as he entered the drawing room. “One of the servants left the door ajar — ” He stopped as he realized that Catherine was not in the room. “Cat?” he called out, thinking she must have stepped into their bedchamber. There was no answer. “Catherine?” he called, not alarmed, but curious as to where she might be.

He noticed an unfolded letter abandoned on the table with Catherine’s sewing, which showed signs of hasty abandonment. He was not the sort of man who read his wife’s correspondence without permission; but it was lying open on the table where anyone might see it; and combined with Catherine’s absence and the state of the shirt she was making for him, he thought the note might contain news of a distressing nature that would require some sort of husbandly comfort, so he picked it up and read it.

“Cat?” he called again when he had finished. “My sweet?” Now there was a note of alarm in his voice. “Catherine!” He strode from room to room, searching for her. There were not many rooms to search. He ran down the stairs, MacGuffin at his heels.

He knocked on the door of the ground floor apartment that the landlady occupied. “Ma’am,” he said as soon as the door opened, “is Mrs. Tilney here, by any chance?”

“No, sir,” said the landlady. “I have not seen her since you returned from your walk.”

MacGuffin went to the door, pawed it gently, and let out a little groan.

“Hush, lad,” said Henry. MacGuffin sat down, his nose pressed against the crack between the door and the jamb.

Matthew came through the door that led to the stairs from the kitchens at that moment. Henry handed him the letter. “Do you know what this could be about?”

Matthew read the note quickly and shook his head. “No, sir; I do not recognize the handwriting.”

MacGuffin pawed at the door again, whimpering. Matthew snapped his fingers, and the dog looked around alertly, but did not move away from the door.

“When I came upstairs, the front door stood ajar,” said Henry quietly. “I believe Mrs. Tilney has gone out to meet whomever wrote this note. She has such faith in the essential goodness of man — perhaps too much. I want you to — ”

His words were cut off by MacGuffin, who stood and barked at the door repeatedly. When they looked at him, he wagged his tail and whined, pushing his nose against the door.

Matthew and Henry exchanged a look.

“Get his lead,” said Henry, and Matthew returned with not only the lead but also a lantern and two loaded pistols. He handed one of the pistols to Henry, who raised his eyebrows.

“I hope we will not find them needful, sir,” said Matthew, “but in my experience it is best to be prepared for all eventualities.”

“Yes, of course,” said Henry. He thrust the pistol in his pocket, slipped the lead over MacGuffin’s head, opened the door, and said in an urgent voice, “Find her, Mac. Find Catherine.” MacGuffin pulled him out into the fog, with Matthew following close behind.

***

The cry died in Catherine’s throat; she dropped her hand and peered at the face before her. “You — I know you,” she said.

The man grinned, revealing several missing front teeth, and nodded vigorously. “How d’ye do, miss,” he said. “Mistress is wishful to talk with ye. Bring miss, she said, so I be bringin’ ye, see?”

“You are Mrs. Findlay’s man,” said Catherine.

“Aye, aye,” he said, grinning and nodding.

“She wants to talk to me? Why did she not simply send up her card? I would have been happy to see her.”

The elderly servant placed a finger over his lips. “Shh,” he said, looking around and then leaning close to her. “’Tis a secret, miss. You come with Barney now, miss.” He turned and pulled her behind him, around a corner to one of the little streets that extended off Pulteney-street. Catherine let him; he seemed harmless enough, though quite odd.

Barney brought her to a chaise stopped by the pavement. He rapped on the door, which opened. “You go in, miss,” he said.

Catherine was a great deal too well-read to climb into an unknown carriage so trustingly. “Mrs. Findlay?” she called. “Are you in there, ma’am?”

“Hush, you silly girl,” said Mrs. Findlay, leaning out of the chaise. “All of Bath can hear you. I know things that in the wrong hands could — well, get in.”

Reassured, Catherine climbed into the chaise, and Barney shut the door behind her.

The little moonlight that penetrated the fog cast harsh shadows across Mrs. Findlay’s face, giving her a mysterious appearance. Catherine swallowed. “You — you said in your note that you had news of — of — ”

“My brother’s murderer. Yes.” She leaned forward. “I have a warning for you.”

Catherine held her breath.

“I saw you with my nephew at the theatre,” she said. “He is like his father, a wastrel and a libertine. I know we live in a degenerate age, when young women no longer cleave to their husbands — ”

“Oh, no, ma’am,” cried Catherine eagerly, “you are mistaken! Sir Philip and I are not — that is — Henry is my husband.”

“Oh, yes, I know how it is with young people these days.” She wagged a finger accusingly. “But it is none of my concern. You just should know that when Philip wants to be rid of you, he might do the same thing he did to my poor brother.”

“Ma’am, are you suggesting that Sir Philip killed Sir Arthur?”

“Suggesting? I know it, ma’am.”

“But why would he do such a thing?”

“My brother was about to disinherit him.”

“Sir Arthur told you so?”

“My brother did not need to tell me! He knew that I knew what must be done to preserve the good name of the Beauclerks.” She leaned forward and spoke in a confidential tone. “You know the provisions of my brother’s will; your husband’s man got it from that silly maidservant.” Catherine’s face must have registered her surprise, for she said with smug satisfaction, “I have my spies in that house, too. Very clever of your husband to introduce the young man; I knew then that you would be the very person with whom I should share my theory, should — ” she held her handkerchief to her mouth for a moment — “should anything happen to me.”

“But, ma’am, with respect — is it not possible that Sir Arthur had no intention of disinheriting his nephew? Especially since the provisions of his will ensured that his money would stay in his immediate family.”

“My brother was a good man, a moral man, Mrs. Tilney, but he had one weakness: his wife. He countenanced her extravangances, and let her teach her worldly ways to his daughter. The right thing would have been to disinherit Philip after he disgraced the family at Brighton, but instead Arthur provided for his daughter so she should no longer be a spinster on the shelf, an embarrassment to her family. And a good thing too, for what might she have got up to with that apothecary of hers?”

“I do not think that Miss Beauclerk has any intention of marrying Mr. Shaw.”

“Marry him? Oh, no! But where do you think Philip got the poison that he used to murder my brother?”

“Sir Philip poisoned his uncle?”

“Yes, ma’am; with the connivance of my sister and my niece.” Her face took on a dreamy expression. “A slow poison was administered, and he fell a victim to the jealousy and subtlety of — of a woman.”

Mrs. Findlay’s words struck a chord with Catherine. Where had she heard them before? But she had no time to think of it. Confused and doubtful, she tried to imagine the vivacious, fluttering Miss Beauclerk convincing her lover to give her sufficient poison to murder her own father; certainly, Mr. Shaw had provided her with arsenic; but then, gleaming like the light thrown from a welcoming doorway on a moonless night, she found a flaw in Mrs. Findlay’s theory. “But ma’am, Miss Beauclerk has received poison from the apothecary quite recently. He brought it to the theatre last night. I overheard them speaking.”

Mrs. Findlay’s eyes gleamed. “I knew it! My sister-in-law will soon learn the wages of sin when her own daughter turns on her! She will be next to die, and then my niece and nephew will be free to take my brother’s money and do what they like!”

“Ma’am, you go too far!”

“Do I, Mrs. Tilney?” She grew dreamy again. “The moment of Lady Beauclerk’s triumph, the moment to which she looked forward for the completion of all her wishes, will prove only the commencement of suffering, that never will leave her to her dying hour.”

“Laurentini!” cried Catherine. “‘The moment of Laurentini’s triumph’! I remember now where I have heard this before — Mrs. Findlay, you read Mrs. Radcliffe’s novels!”

“Novels? I never read novels, ma’am.”

“You must — you do! That is from Udolpho! ‘A slow poison was administered, and she fell a victim to the jealousy and subtlety of Laurentini.’ Ma’am, you have been reading horrid novels, and imagining plots where there are none!” Catherine’s face grew warm even in the dark cold of the chaise, remembering a time when she had done the same thing.

“I, imagine? I imagine nothing.”

Suddenly, there was a scratching noise at the door of the chaise, and they both jumped a little. Raised voices could be heard outside. “It is they!” cried Mrs. Findlay. “They have sent brigands to apprehend me! Oh, where is that wretched Barney?” She raised the blind; something like a masked face was pressed hazily against the glass, and a loud knocking sounded. Mrs. Findlay screamed and swooned, very much like one of Mrs. Radcliffe’s heroines, a comparison that no doubt would have given her great pleasure.

“Mac!” cried Catherine joyously, recognizing the countenance of her Newfoundland pressed against the glass and smearing it with his saliva. “Ma’am, it is my dog — please rouse yourself!” She opened the chaise door. “Henry, is that you? I need assistance — where is Barney?”

Henry’s face appeared in the doorway. “Is that you, Cat? Are you well?”

“I am very well, but Mrs. Findlay has fainted, and I have not my reticule or salts.”

Mrs. Findlay uttered a little moan.

“Well, she seems to be coming round,” said Henry, “and I would take you home — you’ve no coat, and it’s quite cold and damp. Come along, and let — Barney, is it? — take care of his mistress.”

“Aye, miss,” said Barney, “I take care of the mistress now. Ye go home, miss.”

Catherine climbed down eagerly and let Barney climb in. She hesitated at the open chaise door. “Can you look after her, Barney?”

“Aye, miss, I will rouse her, and then take her home. Go and have your tea, miss.”

Henry put up the steps and shut the chaise door, and they set out along the pavement, MacGuffin and Matthew leading the way with the lantern and Henry and Catherine further back.

“Are you warm enough?” said Henry.

“Yes, I have my shawl. Where are we?”

“Just around the corner from our lodgings. You did not get far on your little adventure, and Mac took us right to you. An unsigned note, Cat! I can see why you were tempted to meet with the sender, but I wish another time you would tell me first.”

“I did not intend to meet anyone. I only wanted to see who had sent the note, and Barney pulled me down the pavement to his mistress’ carriage before I knew what I was about. He is a very odd sort of servant. I am sorry if I worried you, Henry.”

His arm around her tightened. “Only for a few moments. I take it Mrs. Findlay wanted a private audience? Would she not send up her card?”

“She wanted to be secret. She thinks they are plotting against her — oh, Henry! She thinks that Lady Beauclerk, Miss Beauclerk, and Sir Philip conspired to poison Sir Arthur!”

“Indeed?”

“But it is all from horrid novels. She reads Mrs. Radcliffe, and imposed Signora Laurentini’s plot against the Marchioness of Villeroi onto her brother’s situation.” Henry made a noise like a cough, and Catherine looked at him suspiciously. “You should not laugh. It is very wicked to make such accusations upon no evidence. And to think I almost believed her!” She was silent for a moment. “My own imaginings last year were just as wicked.”

“It was not quite the same thing, Cat. As you said, you made no public accusations, and you never truly believed Mrs. Findlay.”

“My thoughts were bad enough.”

They had reached the lodgings, and Matthew opened the door. “I will have your dinner sent right up, sir, ma’am,” he said, and disappeared into the back of the house with MacGuffin.

Henry and Catherine ascended the stairs to their rooms, and Catherine immediately went shivering to the fire.

“You were cold,” said Henry. He brought her shawl and wrapped her in it warmly, then put his arms around her and kissed her on the top of the head. “Better, my sweet?”

“Yes.” She leaned her head against his shoulder. “What is this?” Her hands found the pistol in his coat pocket.

Henry removed the pistol and placed it on the table. “Matthew is a cautious sort of fellow. He gave me this before we set out to look for you.”

Catherine bowed her head and huddled into her shawl. “It was very stupid of me to go looking for the person who wrote that note; it could have been anyone! When will I learn to think things through? Mamma is right; I am a sad, shatterbrained simpleton.”

He went to her and again took her in his arms. “I do not believe Mrs. Morland ever called you a simpleton. You have good sense, Cat, and a good heart. You would not think anyone would try to harm you, because you would not harm another person with malice aforethought. You think the best of everyone, and I would not have you lose that quality. It was the first thing I truly loved about you.” He lifted her chin and kissed her.

Catherine was quiet for a moment, wrapped in warmth and happiness. Finally she said, “Although the accusations of murder have been proven wrong, Henry, I think I should not like to have much more to do with the Beauclerks.”

“Nor I, my sweet; but they may be family soon enough, if my father persists in his courtship.”

She lifted her head and looked up at him in alarm. “I forgot. Now that you have your intelligence, what will you say to General Tilney?”

Henry sighed and shook his head. “I do not know. I am not sure I have the right to tell him anything. His happiness is not in my keeping, and it would not be right to prevent it.”

The maidservant knocked on the door at that moment, and they went to have their dinner and talk of happier things.

Chapter Eleven

Speaking Well Enough to be Intelligible

By prearrangement, the Tilneys were to meet the Whitings in Milsom-street the next morning and proceed to the pump-room. Accordingly, Henry and Catherine set out from Pulteney-street, leaving behind a very sad MacGuffin, who had come to consider himself an indispensable part of any expedition out of doors. Fond as the Tilneys were of their pet, he could not go to the pump-room, so they left him with much petting and extravagant promises of an afternoon walk. MacGuffin lay by the fire as they departed, his chin resting on his paws and his eyes reproachful.

As they passed through Laura-place and into Argyle-street, there was a commotion on the pavement ahead of them: exclamations of surprise, laughter, heads craning for a better view. At last they saw the object of this public amusement, one that astonished them both.

General Tilney stood on the pavement, holding a lead with Lady Beauclerk’s cat on the end of it. Unlike MacGuffin, or dogs in general, Lady Josephine did not eagerly pull on the lead, seeking out the next interesting-smelling thing in her path; she meandered, she leapt up on posts and stoops, and otherwise made little progress. At the present moment she sat on her haunches in the middle of the pavement, cleaning her paw very carefully, stretching her claws apart so that her tongue could reach every place between them; she was fully absorbed in her task, and took no notice of either the general or the leering crowd.

General Tilney stood waiting, his posture ramrod straight, his expression dignified and proud, as though he were an ensign in formation. Catherine had to bite her tongue quite hard to keep from laughing, feeling herself at the same time to be an undutiful daughter. She glanced at Henry; besides a slight crease in his brow, he did not seem to think his father’s behavior odd. Growing up in a military family had taught him to control his expression.

“Good morning, sir,” he said. “I see you have called upon Lady Beauclerk. May I inquire after her health?”

“She was very well when I left her,” said the general stiffly.

“I am glad to hear it. Pray convey my compliments, and Catherine’s, too,” he added, looking down at her.

Catherine said, “Oh, yes, sir, if you please.”

“Very well.”

Lady Josephine finished her toilette, stood, stretched, and finally took notice of her attendant. She wound herself around his legs, rubbing against them and purring loudly. The briefest expression of something like revulsion crossed the general’s face. “I believe Lord and Lady Whiting are waiting for you in Milsom-street,” he said.

“Yes, we are to meet by appointment. Good day, sir.”

“Good day, Henry, Mrs. Tilney.” He bowed, but as Lady Josephine was still rubbing against his legs, he made an awkward job of it.

They continued on their way down Argyle-street. Catherine glanced up at Henry, wondering what she might say; she judged it best to let him start any conversation, but he seemed lost in thought.

The General’s servant showed them into the sitting-room; his lordship received them there and sent the servant to fetch her ladyship, preparing them with a murmured, “We have had some bad news.”

Eleanor rushed into the room and went to Henry directly. “My father told me this morning that he intends to make Lady Beauclerk an offer. You must speak to the him, Henry,” she said. “You must tell him what Matthew learned from the maidservant. It is the only chance we have to stop this.”

“I fear it is too late for that. Depend upon it, Eleanor, when a man humiliates himself in public for the sake of a woman, he is too much in love to stop for worldly reasons.”

“What do you mean?”

Henry told the Whitings what he and Catherine had seen in Argyle-street. His lordship seemed to find it a very good joke, but a look at his wife’s face stopped his laughter. He did, however, exchange a covert, sympathetic smile with Catherine.

Eleanor sat as if stunned. “You are right, Henry; it is too late. We must consider this settled. They must be. . . engaged. How strange to talk of one’s father as engaged! And what a mother-in-law we shall have! But at least we have the comfort of knowing that there is affection in the match. There must be.”

“Indeed. We must take our comfort where we can find it.”

“I cannot help thinking of my poor mother,” said Eleanor quietly. After a moment, she roused herself and smiled at them. “Well, as there is nothing else to be done, we must make the best of it. Shall we go to the pump-room, then, and let all of Bath gossip about our family behind our backs?”

The Whitings led the way down Milsom-street toward the pump-room, and Henry and Catherine walked a little behind. The day was fine, and being young and in Bath and the happiness of walking on Henry’s arm put Catherine in high spirits that could not be dampened even by General Tilney’s intended nuptials. She asked Henry, “Did you ever humiliate yourself for me?”

“No, I do not think so; other than a fist-fight with John Thorpe outside the Upper Rooms when he said something about you that I did not quite like.”

“Henry! You did not!” A closer look at his expression let her know he had not, and she laughed in her relief; though a little something else would persist; a feeling that she might like Henry to have engaged in fisticuffs with John Thorpe for her honor.

Henry, with that disconcerting habit he had of guessing her thoughts, said, “Would you like that, my sweet?”

She blushed, but said, “No, I should not like it. Neither John Thorpe nor his opinion mean anything to me.”

“Very sensibly said.”

“ — but not very romantic.”

“Everyday life provides little in the way of romance, Cat; we must make our own.” He gave her a significant look and a smile that made her shiver pleasantly.

The pump-room was pleasantly crowded with all those in Bath who had come to see and be seen. They drank their water, and Henry and Lord Whiting joined a group of men discussing politics and the news of the day, while Eleanor and Catherine circled the room arm in arm. They drew not a few appreciative glances, being young and pretty and fashionably dressed; Eleanor’s rank did not discourage this appreciation, Bath being a place where rank is given consideration — perhaps more than its due.

They met some women of Eleanor’s acquaintance, and stood comfortably chatting when a familiar voice behind her gave Catherine a start.

“Mrs. Tilney,” Sir Philip Beauclerk murmured in a low, confidential voice meant only for her ear. “It is not often that I find you without your keeper.”

“I am sure I do not understand you, sir.”

“Fear not, madam; your husband is across the room, and engaged. Your sister is occupied; you can slip away very easily.”

Catherine had no notion of “slipping away” with Sir Philip, but she knew, with a sinking feeling, that he must be told of his misapprehension, and this was the best opportunity she was likely to have. Eleanor looked at her at that moment, looked at Sir Philip, and then back at Catherine, her brow creased in concern. Catherine nodded and smiled to send a message that all was well, and Eleanor returned the nod, though not the smile.

Sir Philip took her elbow and steered her away from the chattering ladies. “Your sister approves, then? She in your confidence?”

He would have steered her toward the door, but Catherine said, “I would stay in the pump-room, sir.”

He glanced over to the part of the room where Henry stood, and said, “If you insist, madam; but I had hoped for a private audience.”

“We do not need privacy, sir, for what I have to say.” He gazed at her steadily, and Catherine discovered that her carefully prepared speech from Mrs. Radcliffe had abandoned her. “I — that is — ”

Sir Philip’s eyes flicked somewhere behind her, and she knew, without looking, that Henry was there; and the knowledge of that was like a burst of warmth within her.

“Too late,” said Sir Philip, confirming her guess. “Your watchdog has sniffed us out, and stands ready to interfere, as always.”

Catherine turned then, and met Henry’s eye. She smiled, and he smiled in return, and nodded to her encouragingly, but did not approach. He knew that Catherine wished to address the problem herself, but he was there if she needed him. Henry was so kind, and sensible, and dependable! That thought cheered her and at the same time made her angry. How could Sir Philip think that — ? She turned back to him, and found she no longer needed to borrow Mrs. Radcliffe’s words; her own would do.

“My husband only has ‘interfered,’ as you put it, because I asked him to; because I could see that you had formed certain ideas — I know little of the world or of flirtation, sir, and I believe you have misunderstood what only was meant as civility. I have hinted, but I see now that only plain speaking will do. Thus I say to you as plainly as I can, sir, that I have no intention of being your latest amusement. I am a married woman, and I shall keep my vows.”

Sir Philip’s eyes flicked again to Henry. “Madam, I am familiar with the methods that General Tilney employs with his family. If you have been coerced — ”

“General Tilney is different from Henry. I have always been a little afraid of the general, but I could never be afraid of Henry. He has all my confidence, and all my affection.” The last sentence was said with such warmth of expression and such a smile that could leave no man in doubt that Catherine’s words were sincere.

Sir Philip looked at Henry and said, “You have a faithful little wife, Tilney, and I give you joy of her.”

Only then did Henry approach them. “I thank you, Beauclerk; I have great joy of her, I assure you.” He took Catherine’s hand and raised it to his lips.

“Forgive me, madam,” said Sir Philip. “I hope my misapprehension has not caused you undue distress.”

“Oh, no,” said Catherine, who in the flush of her success could not imagine ever feeling distressed again. “I am glad that we understand one another at last.”

“Yes; at last.” He bowed to her, nodded to Henry, and left the pump-room.

The Whitings joined them almost immediately. “Is everything well, Catherine?” Eleanor asked anxiously.

“Yes, I thank you. I forgot the speech I had planned, but I made Sir Philip understand me at last.”

“You were magnificent, my sweet,” said Henry. “Plain speech can do as well, and sometimes better, than the most learned oratory, or even one of Mrs. Radcliffe’s speeches.”

“It will be uncomfortable to be in company with Sir Philip, however. I wish I could have nothing more to do with him, but if General Tilney is determined on marrying Lady Beauclerk, I cannot see how we will be able to avoid him. I am sorry to say it, as they will soon be part of the family, but I do not like the Beauclerks.”

“We need have little to do with any of them beyond her ladyship,” said Henry.

“Will Miss Beauclerk go to live at Northanger Abbey when her mother is married, do you think?”

Eleanor exclaimed, and she exchanged a dismayed look with her brother.

“I had not thought of that,” said Henry.

“Surely my father would not — ” said Eleanor.

Catherine wondered at their words; why would it be so dreadful for Judith Beauclerk to live at Northanger Abbey with her mother?

“Perhaps Miss Beauclerk will marry Sir Philip,” said Lord Whiting. “He has lost his distraction — ” bowing in Catherine’s direction — “and may now remember what is expected of him and come up to scratch.”

“Oh, poor Mr. Shaw,” said Catherine.

Their attention was claimed at that moment by some acquaintances of the Whitings, and Catherine was left to her own thoughts. Though Mrs. Findlay’s accusations of murder had proved to be the workings of an imagination overly stimulated by horrid novels, that did not explain some of the other mysteries that surrounded the Beauclerk family. Mr. Shaw had spoken darkly of “services” he performed on his beloved’s behalf; could they have had anything to do with Sir Arthur Beauclerk’s death? Would Miss Beauclerk buy his silence with the money gained by a marriage to Sir Philip? And why were Eleanor and Henry so alarmed at the idea of Miss Beauclerk living at Northanger Abbey? Even without a murder in the case, there was no doubt that the Beauclerks were a very odd and mysterious family. Catherine had grown up a great deal since her adventures at Northanger Abbey, but there still was a part of her that longed to discover the truth of those mysteries; though in the social crush and swirl of a fine day of high season at the pump-room, murder and mystery seemed laughably improbable.

Chapter Twelve

Going to One Wedding Brings on Another

Friday night arrived as scheduled, and as Catherine’s pleasure in dancing had not been diminished by several exercises, the Tilneys went to the Lower Rooms for the weekly ball. The first set was forming as they arrived; Judith and Sir Philip Beauclerk stood at the top, ready to lead the dance. They took their places and the music began; too late, Catherine saw Eleanor waving to them.

“I should have liked to be next to Eleanor,” Catherine said to Henry.

“We will find them before the next,” he said, and then they were obliged to attend to the dance. Catherine watched Miss Beauclerk carefully so that she would be able to copy her figures, and was a little surprised to see that she was behaving towards her cousin — well, there was no other word for it but flirtatiously; and even more surprisingly, Sir Philip’s behavior was not much different. Henry also was watching the Beauclerks, his brow creased.

When the lead couple reached the Tilneys, Miss Beauclerk reached out and took Catherine’s hand, squeezing it quickly as she crossed over. She said, “Mrs. Tilney, I am so glad to see you!” and went around Henry with her usual light-footed grace. She crossed back and said, “I believe you have not heard my good news. You must wish me joy, for I am to be married.”

Catherine, startled, said, “To whom?” Had Mr. Shaw been able to convince Judith to accept his offer? But that romantic hope was dashed immediately.

“Why, to my dear Philip, of course!”

Catherine looked at Sir Philip, her eyes wide and her mouth open in surprise. How could he — it had not been a week since Sir Philip had acted towards herself as — oh! How could it be?

Sir Philip smirked at her confusion and gave her a little bow. “I thank you for the kind wishes you no doubt wish to bestow, Mrs. Tilney; the demands of the dance, I know, make it difficult.”

“I give you joy, Beauclerk,” said Henry. Only Catherine and Lady Whiting would have recognized the ironic edge of his words.

Certainly Sir Philip did not. “Dashed civil of you, Tilney,” he said, and they were gone, dancing with the next couple in the set.

“How could she do such a thing?” Catherine asked Henry. “She does not know about — ” She stopped, unable to discuss Sir Philip’s behavior in so public a place.

Henry, however, showed perfect comprehension. “Do not fret, my sweet. I suspect she knows more than you think.”

Catherine found such a thing hard to believe. How could Miss Beauclerk take a husband who did not scruple to seduce a married woman?

The Tilneys reached the top of the set and began to dance down; when they reached the Whitings, Eleanor gave Catherine a rueful smile. “I am sure that Judith Beauclerk was full of her news,” she said to Catherine. “Had I the opportunity to speak with you before the dance, I would have given you due warning, so you could meet Sir Philip with composure.”

“Thank you, but I do not think it would have made any difference,” said Catherine.

“One of our problems is solved, at least,” Henry said to his sister. “Judith will not be living at Northanger after a certain happy event. We should be grateful that she has so obligingly disposed of herself.”

“And given her mother an incentive to hasten that happy event,” said Eleanor.

They were then obliged to separate, and when they met again for the next dance, they spoke of more pleasant topics, but Miss Beauclerk and her cousin were never far from Catherine’s mind. It was all so unaccountable! She determined to give Miss Beauclerk a hint, a warning of some kind, but did not encounter her again until they were coming out of the tea room. She felt someone take her elbow and steer her away from Henry.

It was Miss Beauclerk, who whispered in her ear, “I wanted so much to speak with you before the dancing began. One can hear nothing over the musicians. Let us chat now before they start again. What do you think of my news? Is it not a surprise?”

“I am sure I wish you every happiness,” said Catherine.

“I thank you, Mrs. Tilney; that is most kind of you. It is all so exciting! Word got round so fast — as soon as we came in tonight, Mr. King engaged us to open the dance. By the bye, I think Philip would like to dance with you.”

“Please convey my thanks to Sir Philip, but I am engaged for the rest of the evening.”

“You have only been dancing with Henry,” said Miss Beauclerk, laughing. “I have no hope at keeping my husband so much at my side, I fear.”

Here was the opening Catherine had been waiting for. “Miss Beauclerk, have you thought about this very seriously? Are you sure that Sir Philip will make you a good husband?”

“Why should he not?” said Miss Beauclerk with a smile.

Catherine turned to face her, took her hands and leaned close so that no one could overhear; she had forgotten how much taller she was than Miss Beauclerk. She whispered, “I hope I am not saying anything wrong, but I must speak. Sir Philip — that is — he — ” Words failed Catherine, and she blushed deeply.

Miss Beauclerk looked at her with a knowing smile. “Oh, Mrs. Tilney, you are adorable! You mean to warn me about my rakehell cousin! I dare say he has been amusing himself by flirting with you, is that it?”

“I believe he intended more than a flirtation, ma’am.”

Miss Beauclerk smiled, her head tilted to one side, as if Catherine were some exotic foreign animal that she was observing at a zoo. “I do not understand; what has that got to do with me?”

“Are you not afraid he will continue to — flirt — with other women after you are married?”

Miss Beauclerk shook her head and laughed. “You are a dear thing! But you need not worry about me, Mrs. Tilney. I am no romantic young miss. I shall take good care that my husband does not tire of me; and if he does, I shall accept it with good grace. And who knows, perhaps I shall have flirtations of my own!”

Desperately, Catherine played her last card. “But what of Mr. Shaw?”

“What of him?”

“I believe he has a great deal of affection for you; and I believe you gave him to understand that you had great affection for him as well.”

“I am very sorry if Mr. Shaw has deluded himself so far, but I made him no promises, and he has nothing with which to reproach me. He knew that Miss Beauclerk of Beaumont could not marry an apothecary.”

“He said he had performed services for you — and Mrs. Findlay said — ”

Miss Beauclerk gave a trill of laughter. “Neddie is such a foolish thing! When he worked at Beaumont, he made my potion up for me from his employer’s stores and then refused to take payment. He got turned off when his employer found out about it, and he came to the house, expecting us — expecting me — to take him in. My aunt heard of it, and embroidered it with her own wild imagination. Now, I hope to see you again before we leave, Mrs. Tilney; Philip and I will be married at Beaumont in two weeks’ time by special license, and then we shall take a tour of Wales. Mamma and I are frantic over my wedding-clothes, as I dare say you can imagine. Now, I see your partner looking for you; I shall not keep you away.” And she was gone in a whirl of filmy muslin and perfume.

Catherine could tell that Henry knew exactly what had happened; he could have said something like, “I told you that Judith knew all about Beauclerk, and decided to marry him anyway, as her ambition has overcome her good sense,” but to his credit and her relief he said only, “The set is forming, Cat.”

She reached out to him. “Dance with me, Henry, please!”

“With the greatest pleasure.” He took her hand and led her to the set.

***

“Well, if it isn’t Mr. Perhaps.”

Matthew stopped, surprised, and turned; he had a way about him that made it unusual for most people to notice him on a crowded street, but then most people were not looking for him. He bowed to the young lady who had accosted him. “Miss Biddy.”

She curtsied. “I shouldn’t talk to you. I’m very put out, sir. You never came to see me.”

Mentally asking his master’s forgiveness for a white lie in a good cause, Matthew said, “I apologize, but Mr. Tilney has kept me very busy.”

“Oh, aye, I don’t doubt it. You’re lucky you saw me here, for I’m back to Beaumont on Monday, and you wouldn’t have had a chance to say goodbye.”

“To Beaumont? Indeed?”

“Aye. I don’t know if you heard, Miss is getting married to Sir Philip. They’re all in uproar, getting her clothes made and all. They sent me out for ribbon.” She held up a package.

“Our paths lay on the same route; I shall walk back with you.” Biddy seemed pleased with this gallantry, and accordingly they turned their steps towards Laura-place.

“At least her ladyship won’t need clothes made before her wedding. She bought a dozen gowns, or more, since she came to Bath, and I can’t tell you how many caps and bonnets.”

“I did not know things were so far forward with Lady Beauclerk’s wedding. There has been no announcement.”

“No, she’s letting Miss have her day; or so she says. After all her complaining about Miss not getting married, she’s getting her own back. Miss’ll be Lady Beauclerk, and Lady Beauclerk will be a mere Mrs. And don’t think Miss is letting her forget it, either.”

“Surely Lady Beauclerk could keep her title after marrying General Tilney?”

Biddy reached out and grabbed Matthew’s arm. “Haven’t you heard, ducky? She’s not marrying General Tilney! She’s marrying that Mr. Hornebolt, him as has more money than the Duke of Devonshire, or so they say. She says General Tilney’s fortune doesn’t compare; but she really did like him best, until they had the row about Lady Josephine.”

As Matthew had heard of the general’s humiliation in the service of Lady Josephine, he expressed his surprise that they would have had an argument over the creature.

“He said she had humiliated him in front of all of Bath, and he wouldn’t be able to show his face in public again; and she cried and said if he loved her, he would love her cat, but he swore he wouldn’t have a cat for a pet, they were only fit for chasing mice in the kitchens, and that Lady J. was a lazy, ill-natured creature who would tease his dogs and plague his life out. Her ladyship said she couldn’t abide a man who could be cruel to dumb animals, especially one so affectionate as Lady Josephine, and the general said if that was her notion of affection, then she had no business being married, and the shocking amount of money she spent at her mantua-maker would bankrupt any man in a year anyway, and her ladyship said he could just leave if he felt that way, and not darken her doorstep ever again. And so he did leave, and hasn’t been back. She accepted Mr. Hornebolt’s proposal the next day.”

“Surely Lady Beauclerk has since regretted the argument with General Tilney, if she felt true affection for him?”

“Oh, no; Mr. Hornebolt dotes on her ladyship, and on that cat, too. Says Lady J. is a superior creature of her kind, and that his dear Agatha can spend just what she likes on her bits of muslin, and any jumped-up half-pay officer who won’t stand the expense of his wife’s fitting-out should be run through with his own sword. I dare say he was talking about the general. But he won’t stand for Lady Beauclerk keeping her title. He’s an old-fashioned man, his mother was Mrs. Hornebolt and his wife will be Mrs. Hornebolt. Miss don’t let her forget it, either; she will have precedence over her own mother when she is Lady Beauclerk and her mamma is Mrs. Hornebolt.”

She stopped for breath, and Matthew regarded her with admiration. “My dear Miss Biddy, have you been listening at doors again?”

“Of course! How else could I learn anything? You like to listen to my gossip well enough, I’m sure. I’ll wager you carry it back to your master right smart, too.”

The sudden, simple truth of her words shamed Matthew; so much so, that when they reached Laura-place, he allowed her to draw him into a dark niche by the kitchen door “to say good-bye proper-like” with very good grace, and gave her a good-bye kiss that left her dreamy-eyed and giggling.

***

The previous Sunday walk to Beechen Cliff had been so successful that the Tilneys and the Whitings determined to repeat it. The day was fine and sunny, and while the walk beside the river was not as crowded as the Royal Crescent, they were not alone, so MacGuffin remained on his lead. Henry and Eleanor both were in fine spirits, having had good news from Matthew about their father.

“I cannot help feeling a little sorry for General Tilney,” said Catherine. “What if Lady Beauclerk had made him very much in love with her?”

“I think he was, after his own fashion,” said Henry. “But your amiable habit of putting yourself in another’s place, and attributing to them your own unhappiness in such a situation, has misled you, I fear. If my father is unhappy over Lady Beauclerk, his disposition is such that it will not be of long duration. He will soon tease himself out of it by recalling her account at her mantua-maker’s, and congratulating himself on escaping having to pay it.”

“Not to mention escaping having to walk her cat,” said his lordship.

A man was pacing along the riverbank ahead of them, near the spot where MacGuffin had waded out to chase the ducks. As they approached him, Catherine recognized him. “That is Mr. Shaw. Poor man! I do feel very sorry for him, and I dare say he feels his misfortune more than General Tilney.”

The man bent over and picked up some objects along the shoreline and placed them in his coat pockets. He paced some more, and then, as they approached from one side and a large family party from the other, he suddenly waded out into the river.

Understanding dawned on Catherine. “Oh! He has placed rocks in his pockets! Henry, Mr. Shaw means to drown himself! You must stop him!”

“Shaw!” cried Henry. “I say, Shaw!”

Mr. Shaw whirled around and pointed a finger accusingly at them. “Do not try to stop me! No one would help me, no one would make my angel listen to me! It is too late! My blood is on your hands!” He turned away and stumbled forward, walking with odd high steps rather than wading. “She will know!” he cried, pointing in the general direction of the Pulteney Bridge. “She will know how much I loved her when she finds me floating by her very door, and then she will regret her treatment of me! But it will be too late! I shall be gone from this earth forever!”

Catherine, frightened beyond understanding, cried, “Oh, stop him! Someone stop him!”

Henry released her arm and strode down the riverbank. “That river must be freezing at this season, Shaw, and you are frightening the ladies. Do come out now, there’s a good fellow.” MacGuffin added several barks as emphasis as he strained on his lead.

Mr. Shaw took two more thrashing steps into the river, which flowed against him and broke around his knees. “I have nothing to live for,” he said. “Nothing. My angel has forsaken me. The devil must take me for his own now!”

Henry gave a short sigh of impatience, and then bent down and took off MacGuffin’s lead. The dog immediately raced for the river and plunged in.

Mr. Shaw flailed away from MacGuffin. “Begone, hellbeast! Leave me to your dark master!” One of his feet slipped, and he went down on one knee, struggling to keep his head above water. Even in her fright, Catherine thought his behavior odd; he said he wanted to drown himself, but seemed afraid to go under water.

MacGuffin, up to his haunches in the water, seized the floating end of Mr. Shaw’s tailcoat firmly in his mouth and braced himself on the river bottom. Mr. Shaw tried to move away from him, but MacGuffin held firm.

“He has been trained in water retrieval,” Henry called to Mr. Shaw. “Trained very well, I may add. You might as well give it up now.”

Mr. Shaw attempted to unbutton his coat and slip out of it, but MacGuffin growled, the coat-tail still in his mouth, and shook his head violently from side to side, as though playing a game of keep-away. Mr. Shaw stopped struggling and began to weep with loud braying sobs; he then buried his face in his hands.

Henry watched him for a long moment. “Do you think you are the only man whose peace has been destroyed by Judith Beauclerk?” he asked, his voice full of compassion. Mr. Shaw’s turned to look at him; Henry gazed back at him steadily, and they seemed to communicate something, a shared knowledge that made Catherine suddenly uneasy.

MacGuffin tugged again, and at last Mr. Shaw came with him, stumbling out of the river, the dog herding him like a lost sheep and never letting go of the coat-tail until his captive was safely on land and wrapped in a blanket produced by the family party, which had watched the proceedings with fascinated horror. A few more spectators had collected, including several small boys who heard that someone had drowned himself and demanded, in high-pitched, strident voices, to see the corpse. Lord Whiting sent them away and consulted with the father of the family-party, and they went to fetch his carriage, which was waiting in Argyle-street.

Henry put an arm around Mr. Shaw’s shoulders, still bowed in sorrow. He looked up at Catherine consciously, and she turned and said to the fascinated onlookers, “Step away, please; leave him be.” They turned, one by one, and drifted away, as Henry spoke to Mr. Shaw in unintelligible tones.

The mother of the family-party would not be moved so easily. “What is he saying?” she asked Catherine, peering over her shoulder at Henry and Mr. Shaw huddled on the riverbank. “What is he doing?”

“My husband is a priest,” said Catherine firmly. “He will say all that is necessary.”

The woman’s face cleared. “Oh, a priest,” she said. “Aye, he’ll take care of the poor devil.” She turned to shoo her children away.

Lord Whiting and the father returned, and the three men helped Mr. Shaw to get up and moving towards the bridge. “Cat, take MacGuffin, and go to our lodgings with Eleanor,” Henry called to her. “We will meet you there.”

***

Henry and John returned to Pulteney-street a few hours later, and assured the worried ladies that they had returned Mr. Shaw to his rooms in Westgate Buildings, saw him into dry clothes and left him in front of a blazing fire.

“How could you leave him?” cried Catherine. “How do you know he will not try again to destroy himself?”

“He did not really want to destroy himself,” said his lordship, flinging himself into a chair. “He only wanted someone to share his misery. Did you not see that he feared the water? Only a man still in love with life would have such fear.”

“And pray note that he chose to make his attempt nearly on the Beauclerks’ doorstep,” said Henry. “He raved a bit in the carriage about Judith finding him floating in the river and being sorry she had cast him off, but it soon came out that he really did not wish to drown himself; he had a wild scheme of someone running for Judith so she could stop him from drowning himself and reconcile with him.”

“He also waited until he was sure he had an audience,” said Lord Whiting. “He could have jumped in before we or that nice fellow from Hampshire got there, but he waited for us to be close enough to see his act. I give him credit; ’twas as good as anything one sees on Drury Lane. Though the poor fellow has had a bad time of it.”

Henry looked at Catherine, who sat with her head down, and her hands fastened in her lap; an attitude he knew to mean that she was in some distress that she did not care to vocalize. “Do not worry, my sweet. Mr. Shaw and I had a good talk, and I made him see the foolishness of martyring himself to Miss Beauclerk. I think he might even be on the way to mending his broken heart.”

Catherine lifted her head and looked into Henry’s eyes. “You once said to me that Miss Beauclerk had not injured you; but the way you spoke to him today — the way you said he was not the first man to have his peace destroyed by her — ”

Henry and Eleanor exchanged glances, and Eleanor said, “Catherine and John are part of our family now, Henry; I believe you should tell them.”

He nodded, and said to Catherine, “I told you the truth. Judith Beauclerk did not break my heart or injure me by her flirtations. I regret I cannot say the same for my brother.”

“Captain Tilney?”

“Yes. He came home several years ago, a newly commissioned lieutenant in the Twelfth Light Dragoons, and fell for Judith with all the ardent affection of a young man fresh from a battlefield, and offered her his hand and his heart. She said that she could not marry a mere Lieutenant Tilney, and he had to put himself in the way of a battlefield commission or, better yet, a knighthood so she could be Lady Tilney. Frederick told no one of this, not even my father; and he went off to Toulon and put himself in grave danger during the siege there, in a hopeless cause, trying to cover himself with glory for her sake.”

“He won his commission?”

“Yes; he was Captain Tilney, but it was not enough for Judith; he was not Sir Frederick. He presented himself to Judith, and she laughed at him, and said she had never intended to marry him or any officer, and how could he take her so seriously? My brother changed that day, Cat; he changed from a brave, headstrong, sometimes vain and thoughtless young man into someone capable of amusing himself at the expense of another’s comfort. He learned to give what he received from Miss Beauclerk; and since then has found no woman worthy of his affection.”

Catherine considered this gravely. “That is why he acted the way he did with Isabella Thorpe, I dare say; he knew her for a vain coquette, and took his revenge on her.”

“Not so much revenge, I think, as recognizing that Miss Thorpe’s was not a heart worth winning, or worth more than a common flirtation, and perhaps taking advantage of it.”

“And now I understand why you did not wish Miss Beauclerk to live at Northanger; if Captain Tilney came to visit, I dare say it would be most uncomfortable for him.”

“Yes,” said Eleanor. “And my father promoted the match between Frederick and Judith, which really was most eligible, so Henry and I were astonished that he seemed to have forgotten the outcome of it.”

“I do not understand why Miss Beauclerk would refuse Captain Tilney and accept Sir Philip,” said Catherine. “Captain Tilney will have a much larger estate and fortune.”

“I believe she always meant to get Beauclerk, if she could,” said Henry. “She could not capture him with her own charms, but her father made it possible with the terms of his will.”

“So ambition makes fools of us all,” said his lordship. “Eleanor, love, is that tea hot? I could use a cup.”

***

The fire in their bedroom was past its first and highest blaze, and Henry and Catherine burrowed into their thick quilts, embraced by the circle of light thrown off by Henry’s candle as he read aloud the last chapter of The Mysteries of Udolpho.

O! how joyful it is to tell of happiness, such as that of Valancourt and Emily; to relate, that, after suffering under the oppression of the vicious and the disdain of the weak, they were, at length, restored to each other — to the beloved landscapes of their native country, — to the securest felicity of this life, that of aspiring to moral and labouring for intellectual improvement — to the pleasures of enlightened society, and to the exercise of the benevolence, which had always animated their hearts; while the bowers of La Vallee became, once more, the retreat of goodness, wisdom and domestic blessedness!

O! useful may it be to have shewn, that, though the vicious can sometimes pour affliction upon the good, their power is transient and their punishment certain; and that innocence, though oppressed by injustice, shall, supported by patience, finally triumph over misfortune!

Catherine made an impatient noise and thrashed a bit under her quilt.

Henry looked down at her in surprise. “You disagree with Mrs. Radcliffe, my sweet?”

“I once believed that innocence could triumph over misfortune, but now I am not so sure.”

Henry closed the book and set it aside. “Somehow, I do not think you are speaking of Udolpho.”

“No.” He waited, and she said, “Well, look at Miss Beauclerk! She has injured your brother, and poor Mr. Shaw, and now she gets what she always wanted: to be Lady Beauclerk, when she should be forced to — ”

“ — take the veil, like Laurentini?”

“Well, yes! Or something like that! It does not seem fair!”

“Consider, my sweet: to achieve her ambition, Miss Beauclerk accepted a husband who is unlikely to make her very happy. Some would say that her success will be her own punishment.”

Catherine subsided and rested her head upon his shoulder, suddenly wearied by it all. “I suppose.”

He kissed her forehead. “I fear the friends you have made in Bath have given your faith in your fellow man a severe trial. Shall we give up the lodgings, and go back to Woodston early?”

She considered his suggestion for a moment. “No, I would like to stay another week or two, if we can; the Beauclerks will be gone, and perhaps we will make new acquaintances. Although I cannot think of any friends I should like better than you, and Eleanor and John.”

“Then I must make plans for your further entertainment. We shall go to the bookseller’s tomorrow and choose something else to read together. Another by Mrs. Radcliffe? Perhaps The Italian, or The Romance of the Forest?”

“Perhaps The Midnight Bell? I like the sound of that one.”

“The Midnight Bell it is, then. And we have not been out once yet in the curricle; Matthew tells me the horses are getting fat and need exercise. One fine morning this week I will drive you out to Bristol and you shall finally see Blaise Castle.”

Henry’s words, meant to cheer Catherine, instead distressed her. “I once thought it a real castle! I was such a foolish creature. How could you ever fall in love with me?”

He looked down at her with a warm smile, his eyes all affection. “How could I not love you, Catherine? How could any man of sense not see all your good qualities? You were not foolish, just innocent of the world; and as Mrs. Radcliffe has taught us, innocence — “ he reached out and extinguished the candle — “must always triumph.”

It was not very long before Catherine found herself agreeing with that sentiment; for when he was inspired, Henry could be very convincing indeed.

FINIS.

Acknowledgments

The authoress wishes to thank Cassandra Chouinard for her illustrations, which are not only beautiful but capture the fun of the story so well; Laura Boyle for pitching the idea and featuring the story so prominently on the Jane Austen Centre at Bath online magazine; Christina Hamilton for her expert copy editing; Laura McDonald for her patience and much-needed prodding, not to mention introducing me to so many wonderful books at Girlebooks; my Janeite Posse for posseing, in particular Team Tilney and the gang at Molland's who provided such great feedback and comments during the online serial publication of this Very Nice Story; my family, as always, for their encouragement of my writing and for embracing my Janeite freakiness, although they don't always understand it; and of course the incomparable Jane Austen for giving us these wonderful characters that continue to inspire me.

About the Author

Margaret C. Sullivan is the Editrix of AustenBlog.com, a compendium of news and commentary about Jane Austen's work in popular culture. She also created the website Molland's (www.mollands.net), a resource for Jane Austen fans. She is the author of The Jane Austen Handbook: A Sensible Yet Elegant Guide to Her World (Quirk Books, 2007) and contributed to the anthology Jane Austen Made Me Do It, edited by Laurel Ann Nattress (Random House, 2011). Margaret is a life member of the Jane Austen Society of North America.

About the Illustrator

At the age of 24, Cassandra finally changed her last name but is still entrapped in her famous sister's orbit, as you can see. (We shall get nothing more serious from her now...she is not in a sober mood.) A doodler since childhood, Cassandra Chouinard abandoned her painting studies to complete a master's degree in harpsichord performance at McGill University. Meanwhile, various stints as a street portraitist, student newspaper cartoonist, and vanity press illustrator attuned her eye to various details such as line, contour, and the all-too-quick approach of a deadline.

Content

Margaret C Sullivan
There Must Be Murder

Chapter One Winter Pleasures

Chapter Two An Unexpected Meeting

Chapter Three Spoilt by Great Acquaintance

Chapter Four No Enemy to Matrimony

Chapter Five Something Very Shocking Indeed

Chapter Six Murder and Everything of the Kind

Chapter Seven Brittle and Beautiful

Chapter Eight Most Alarming Adventures

Chapter Nine The Most Unpromising Circumstance

Chapter Ten The Shades of Udolpho

Chapter Eleven Speaking Well Enough to be Intelligible

Chapter Twelve Going to One Wedding Brings on Another

Acknowledgments

About the Author

About the Illustrator