Ellery Queen

The Devil’s Cook

God may send a man good meate,

but the deuyll may send

an euyll coke to dystrue it.

— ANDREW BOORDE

Dyetary of Helth (1542)

God sends meat,

but the devil sends cooks.

— JONATHAN SWIFT

Polite Conversation (1738)

Cast of Characters

Terry Miles — She was five feet four of scenic stuff, and she wasn’t particular who explored the scenery

Farley Moran — Law student and Terry’s neighbor. He was a cool cat who lost his sang froid the night the police sent him out to meet the killer

Ben Green — Farley’s roommate. He was Terry’s type, more or less. Trouble was, he had more brains and less money than most of her playmates

Orville Reasnor — Janitor by trade, girl watcher by choice. When it came to the tenants, he never missed a trick or a torso

Fanny Moran — Farley’s half-sister. A neat little package of goodies that all the boys wanted to open, but it was marked “Don’t Touch”

Jay Miles — Professor of economics and Terry’s husband. He was the only one who didn’t seem to miss his missing wife

Otis Bowers — A brilliant physicist, but he flunked out in Adultery

Ardis Bowers — His nagging wife. To her, marriage was an institution and she intended to make Otis serve his full term, but no time off for bad behavior

Maurice Feldman — Terry’s lawyer. He knew his client’s favorite sport, but she changed partners so often he never knew who was in the game

Brian O’Hara — Small-time gambler — big-time Lothario. He only went for a sure thing, in horses or women

Capt. Bartholdi — A cop with Gallic charm. He looked like a boulevardier, but he could teach Mickey Spillane a few tricks

Freda Page — Jay Miles’ student assistant. Even thick lenses couldn’t hide the lovelight in her eyes when Jay’s name was mentioned

1

Handclasp, which is not defined in the dictionary, connotes friendliness. If your dictionary has a gazetteer, you might find Handclasp listed as a city, population 125,407, in north-central United States.

It is reasonable to assume that the founders of Handclasp named their settlement with fair visions of an inland oasis in which the habitants would live in harmony with each other, and maybe even with the Indians. Alas for visions! Although there is no record of trouble with the Indians, there has been, from time to time, a generous dollop of it among the citizenry. Some of this trouble has been trivial, some has ben serious, but most of it, as in the wider world, has been neither one nor the other. There has been a continuity of political wars, social antagonisms, personal vendettas, and marital shenanigans. Here and there, in this haphazard chronicle of standard deviations, some of which went as far as the courts, an occasional item of gaudier aspect pops up.

Like murder.

The propaganda issued by the Chamber of Commerce to entice new industry will tell you that Handclasp has, in addition to parks, libraries, and wide streets, over one hundred churches of various denominations and almost fifty elementary and secondary schools, public, parochial, and private. The inference is clear. Although dedicated to profits and progress, the Chamber is civilization-conscious. If further proof is demanded, look at Handclasp University.

Founded as a private institution in 1869, taken over by the city in 1893 and by the state in 1924, Handclasp University has grown into a flourishing association of five fully accredited colleges boasting a total enrollment of nearly seven thousand students. On or near the campus there are almost enough dormitories and fraternity and sorority houses to accommodate the enrollment. For the overflow, including tenant faculty members, there are convenient rooms in private houses carefully screened by the university lodging service, and habitable apartment buildings. Of these, although it is not mentioned by the Chamber, The Cornish Arms is one.

The grandest thing about The Cornish Arms is its name. Otherwise, it is fair to call it ordinary. It is a buff brick building set flush with the sidewalk and rising two stories. The ground floor is bisected by a hall from street to back-alley and this design is duplicated on the floor above. There is an apartment to each side of each hall — four all told — and they are, if not posh, at least comfortable. In the basement there is a fifth apartment which is occupied, or was, by Orville Reasnor, the superintendent and maintenance man.

The Cornish Arms, in brief, is not singled out for attention because it is in any way distinguished. It is described because, at this particular time, certain people lived there.

One of these was Terry Miles. Terry cannot be casually dismissed. From, metatarsus to auburn crown, she stood five feet four of scenic stuff. It was scenery, moreover, that she knew how to display to most graphic effect. Cézanne never did more with a landscape than Terry did with hers; and if he did it to more people, it was only because Terry never hung in a gallery or was constructed of materials as durable. While they lasted however, they did have the advantage of mobility. She could, for example, pick her spots and a special class of tourist. Let it be said that the lucky nature-lovers who were permitted to pause and admire Terry’s scenery in detail, while differing considerably among themselves, possessed a common denominator. They were all men.

On this afternoon, which was the afternoon of a Friday in November, Terry went calling. She had not to go very far — to be exact, seven feet, which was the width of the hall outside her door. Having crossed that distance and reached another door exactly like hers, she knocked on it, and it was opened after a delay by a young man in a deplorable gray sweatshirt, wheat jeans, and rather soiled sneakers. His dark hair was tousled, having a tendency to curl, and his eyes were a disconcerting pale gray in color, darkening near the pupils to a shade that seemed sometimes slatish and sometimes green. His mouth was small, but it was filled with good if small teeth, and so it appeared to be bigger than it was. He was, in sum, a young man of striking good looks; he might have been handsome enough to look dull if he had not, being shrewd, fought the effect off with deliberate sloppiness.

In his right hand he was clasping a can of beer that had been plugged in two places and was perspiring invitingly.

“Hello, Terry,” he leered. “Come in and join the orgy.”

“Really? A real orgy?” Terry stretched on her toes to peer over Farley’s shoulder in search of the lurid details. “I don’t see any signs of it.”

“We’ve taken cover. We thought you might be the vice squad. Damn it, Terry, come on in before the super gets suspicious.”

Terry stepped into a room that was, except for personal items and colors and an accumulated disorder, a mirror image of the one she had just left. Books were stacked on a straight chair. More books were tumbled carelessly onto one end of a well-worn sofa. At the other end of the sofa, slumped on his spine with a can of beer balanced precariously on his stomach, sat a young man who seemed to have one eye that was incapable of opening as wide as its mate. This produced the disconcerting effect of a squint; he was apparently peering malevolently when he was in fact only looking at you. Below the eyes jutted a crooked nose, surrounded by a face of engaging ugliness. Furthermore he was short, slight of build, and seemed at the moment overcome by a feeling of unshakable lassitude. He made no move to rise when Terry entered the room, compromising on a limp wave that caused the can of beer to tilt dangerously on his stomach.

“Hi, Terry,” he said, in a surprisingly baritone voice. “I’m afraid Farley was telling you a whopper. No orgy.”

“Oh, Ben, I knew he was just joking,” Terry said. “I mean, there would have been a lot of noise and everything. Orgies are by definition noisy. Everyone knows that.”

She went over and sat down on the sofa between the young man named Ben and the books. The other young man, the one called Farley, seated himself by the simple expedient of backing against the arm of an overstuffed chair and falling across it into the seat. During this maneuver, he adroitly preserved the integrity of his beer.

“Are you disappointed?” Farley said.

“I am, rather,” Terry said. “Orgies can be quite pleasant if they’re conducted properly.”

“That comment,” said the young man with the squint and the crooked nose, “requires some excogitating. It raises an arguable point. Are orgies ever proper?”

“Moreover,” said Farley, “I doubt that they are ‘conducted.’ In my experience, they just start somehow and grow.”

“That is exactly the kind of academic quibbling I’d expect from a law student and an embryo historian,” Terry said. “You’re just making excuses for not providing me with interesting entertainment.”

“You’re right.” Ben, the young man on the sofa, deftly snared his can, took a long swallow from it, and rebalanced it on his stomach. “If I had time, I’d get an orgy started. Unfortunately, I have to leave soon. I hate to walk out on any kind of entertainment, proper or otherwise.”

“That’s true,” said Farley. “Old Ben is off on a mysterious excursion for the weekend. Even I have not been admitted to his confidence, but I suspect the complicity of my sweet little sister in the apartment upstairs. Damn it, Ben, would you actually consort with the little sister of your friend and roomie?”

“Nothing of the sort.” Old Ben squinted at his friend and roomie with incredible malevolence. “Fanny has nothing to do with it.”

“Where are you going?” Terry said.

“That,” said Ben, “is for me to know and you to find out.”

“There’s no use asking him,” said Farley. “He simply won’t tell me. For my part, I’m reconciled to his lack of faith in me, shabby though it is. We were just having a couple of parting beers.”

“As I see it,” Terry said, “you are still having them, and I would have one with you, if only someone had the good manners to ask me.”

“Farley,” said Ben, “what in hell has happened to your manners? Why don’t you ask Terry to have a beer?”

“Excuse me,” Farley said. “Terry, will you have a beer?”

“Yes, I will,” Terry said.

Farley, bailed out of his chair over the arm, as he had got in, and started for the kitchen.

“While you are in the refrigerator,” said Terry, “I’d appreciate it if you would get me three fresh carrots.”

Farley came to an abrupt halt. He seemed to be having difficulty with the message.

“Did you say three fresh carrots?” he said.

“Yes, medium-sized, if you please.”

“Why in the devil, if I may ask, would you simply assume that you could borrow anything like three fresh carrots from a couple of bachelor students?”

“Why not? You and Ben cook most of your own meals, don’t you? It’s perfectly reasonable to assume that you might have carrots around the place.”

“I consider it most unlikely. Ben, do we have any carrots around the place?”

“As a matter of fact, we do,” Ben said. “I bought some yesterday at the market.”

“Well, I’ll be!” Farley turned again and got into motion. “I wouldn’t be more surprised to find the damn refrigerator stocked with opium.”

They could hear him rattling around in the refrigerator and cursing mildly because he couldn’t remember where he had left the beer opener.

“How long have you and Farley known each other?” Terry asked Ben.

“Not long. We met on campus a week or two before we decided to move in here together.”

“I’ve been wondering about that. Why did you? I mean, decide to move in here together?”

“Because it’s better than a single room. Two can pay the rent on an apartment easier than one.”

“I thought maybe it was so Farley could live near Fanny.”

“You thought wrong, honey. It’s true that Fanny put us on to the vacancy, but Farley grabbed it because there wasn’t anything else available. You didn’t take that brotherly indignation seriously, did you? Fanny’s a complicated little devil. Declaration of independence, and all that. She knows her way around.”

“Farley’s very goodlooking. I wonder why he always deliberately looks as if he bought his clothes at a rummage sale? After all, he’s going to be a lawyer in a year or so. Aren’t lawyers supposed to wear collars and ties and coats and like that?”

“He practicing to be Clarence Darrow.”

“Really? Who’s that?”

“Never mind.”

At that moment Farley returned bearing beer and carrots. He gave both to Terry, who laid the carrots on the sofa beside her and took a drink out of the can. Farley, employing the same technique as before, resumed his seat in the chair.

“As a matter of curiosity,” he said, “would you mind telling me what you’re going to do with those carrots?”

“It will be a pleasure,” Terry said. “I’m going to put them in a Student’s Ragout.”

“What the hell is a ragout?”

“A ragout,” said Ben, “is a hell of a mess cooked together.”

“Roughly speaking,” Terry said, “that’s it.”

“But what, precisely,” Ben said, “is a Student’s Ragout? As a dyspeptic bachelor, I’m always interested in recipes.”

“Student’s Ragout is the Crown Prince of all ragouts.”

“Well, you needn’t sound so damn esoteric about it. Is the recipe a jealously guarded secret or something?”

“Not in the least. Would you like me to tell it to you?”

“That’s what I was hinting at.”

“It’s quite simple. To begin with, you take a heavy pot or a deep skillet. Myself, I use my electric skillet. Then you cut strips of bacon in half and cover the bottom of the skillet with them. Next, you cut a pound or so of lean round steak into strips about one-half inch by an inch and a half. Cover the bacon with these and salt and pepper them. Take the carrots next. Slice them paper-thin and spread the slices over the steak. Then slice three good-sized onions paper-thin and spread them over the carrots. Finally add three or four potatoes, depending on the size, also sliced paper-thin and spread over the onions. Salt and pepper the potatoes and cook covered, over low heat. In my opinion, you should add a generous amount of water to be sure that the ragout stays good and moist. There’s lots of liquid in the vegetables, of course, but a little more is necessary, and quite a bit more doesn’t hurt.”

Farley and Ben, during this recital, stared at Terry with expressions of astonishment. When she was finished they were silent for a moment, then Farley turned to Ben.

“Did you hear how she rattled that off?” he said.

“By God,” said Ben, “it was absolutely incredible.”

“That’s true,” Farley said. “Somehow you don’t think of old Terry in the kitchen. You think of her in the bedroom, surrounded by silk sheets and mirrors and oceans of lotions, painting her toe-nails and plucking her brows and doing other things.”

“What do you mean by ‘other things’?” demanded Terry.

“What he had in mind,” Ben said, “was sex. You’ll have to admit, in all fairness, Terry, that you’re sexy.”

“Well,” said Terry, “what’s wrong with sex in the kitchen?”

“Now that you ask,” Ben said, “I can’t think of a thing.”

“Returning reluctantly to the ragout,” Farley said, “I must say that I was fetched by the sound of it. Ben, you’re a better cook than I am. You’ll have to try it when you get back from your weekend.”

“The proportions are just suggested, of course,” Terry said. “You can change them to suit your taste.”

“The principle, I would say,” said Ben, “is the same as that of Huck Finn’s garbage cans. The object is to get the flavors swapped around.”

“Besides being delicious,” Terry said, “it has another great advantage. You don’t have to stay around and watch it. That’s why I decided to fix it for dinner this evening. I have an appointment after a while, and I’ll just leave the ragout simmering in the skillet. When Jay gets home, screaming for his dinner, it will be ready to serve.”

“Where are you going?” Ben asked.

“None of your business. If you can be a clam about your affairs, so can I.”

“That’s right, Ben,” said Farley. “Fair’s fair. If you’ll tell us where you’re going, Terry will tell where she’s going.”

“Never mind,” Ben said.

“Neither will I,” said Terry.

Farley sighed. “Speaking of Jay, Terry, how is he?”

“Who was speaking of him?”

“You were, damn it. You said something about him screaming for his dinner.”

“That was an exaggeration, to be honest. Jay never screams. He never even yells. It wouldn’t fit in with being an assistant professor of economics. If you are an assistant professor of economics, you must be dignified and stuffy. And if you are the wife of an assistant professor of economics, you are expected to be dignified and stuffy also.”

“That’s not reasonable,” Ben protested. “How can a sexy wife be dignified and stuffy?”

“It’s very difficult,” said Terry. “If not impossible.”

“It’s worse than that — it isn’t even healthy. As between dignity and sex, I’ll take sex every time.”

“Has a tone of discontent crept into this conversation,” Farley said, “or do I imagine it?”

“It is no secret,” Terry said, “that Jay and I are not on the most amiable of terms. He disapproves of almost everything I do.”

“Is that a fact?” Ben said. “I can’t imagine why.”

“Are you being sarcastic?”

“Yes, Ben,” said Farley, “you mustn’t be sarcastic. It’s hardly appropriate for a fellow who is going on a top-secret weekend. As for me, Terry, I am on your side in the matter. If old Jay walks out on you, I’m prepared to console you.”

“If so,” said Terry, “you will have to wait your turn.”

Ben looked at his wristwatch, drained his can, and managed to stand up.

“I’m beginning to feel like a crowd,” he said. “Fortunately, it’s time for me to leave.”

He carried the empty can into the kitchen, came out again, and went into the bedroom. When he reappeared he was wearing a hat and topcoat and carrying a leather bag.

“I’m off!” he said. “See you Sunday evening.”

“I’m convinced that you have no intentions whatever of being good,” said Farley, “so just be careful.”

“Right. Old Ben Green proceeds with caution.”

He went out. Terry shook her beer can, which was empty, and rose after depositing the can on the floor.

“I suppose I should leave, too,” she said.

“Why?”

“I told you I have an appointment. And I have to fix the ragout before I go.”

“You could stay for a little while, couldn’t you?”

“It wouldn’t look right.”

“Damn the looks. Have another beer.”

“Since you ask me, I will.”

She sat down again while Farley went to the kitchen and returned with two fresh cans. He handed one to Terry and sat down beside her on the sofa.

“‘Shoulder the sky,’” he said, “‘and drink your ale.’”

“Is that original? Didn’t someone else say it first?”

“Doesn’t someone always?”

“Anyway, it isn’t ale we’re drinking. It’s beer.”

“A mere technicality,” Farley said.

2

Soon after five o’clock Fanny Moran, Farley Moran’s little sister upstairs, returned to The Cornish Arms. She did not, however, climb directly to her second-floor apartment. She spoke cheerfully to Orville Reasnor, who was on his hands and knees in the vestibule near the entrance, and paused briefly to check her mailbox, which was empty. While she was thus engaged, Orville exploited the opportunity to survey her with considerable admiration from end to end, and he concluded as usual that she was a neat little package. It was a short excursion, actually, from end to end of Fanny, for she stood only one inch over five feet, although a natural tendency of the observer to linger on the way usually prolonged the trip. Orville, who was a trained observer, took his time going from strawberry blonde hair, cut short and slightly shaggy, to a small pair of nyloned feet raised for added height on high heels.

“You ain’t got any mail,” Orville said.

“So I see,” Fanny said. “Thank you for looking for me, Orville.”

“I didn’t look. You’ll never catch Orville Reasnor prying into tenants’ affairs. I was working in the hall when the postman came, that’s all, and I saw what boxes he opened. Miles and Bowers is all.”

“Oh?” Fanny turned and looked down at Orville. “What are you doing down there on your hands and knees? Saying your prayers?”

“Not hardly. I been replacing some of this asphalt tile. A couple pieces got kicked up and cracked.”

“Is my brother at home?”

“Not knowing, I couldn’t say. He ain’t come out this way. ’Course, he might have gone out the back door.”

“Yes, Farley often goes in and out of back doors. It’s a kind of instinct with him.”

“You want to see him about something?”

“Not particularly. I wonder if Terry Miles is home. Don’t bother to answer, Orville. I’ll just go back and knock on her door and find out, if you don’t mind.”

“I don’t mind. Why should I?”

Not knowing, Fanny couldn’t say. At any rate, she lingered no longer. Orville Reasnor, still in a prayerful posture above his pot of tile cement, watched her ascend four steps to the lower hall level, and offered thanks for short skirts.

Down the hall a way, Fanny knocked, on Terry’s door. There was no answer, and she knocked again. This time there was an immediate response, but it was not the one she was waiting for. The wrong person opened the wrong door. The wrong person was Farley, and the wrong door was his.

“Hello, Fan,” Farley said. “No use banging on Terry’s door. She isn’t home. She said she was going out somewhere.”

Fanny jumped as if she had been caught with a jimmy in her hands. When her heart had snapped back into place, she turned and glared at her brother, who was, technically, only half a brother. (They had shared a father who had been accommodated in the course of his marital fiascoes by two wives who had succeeded in becoming mothers. The third wife, fortunately, had failed.)

“Damn it, Farley,” Fanny said, “I wish you would quit leaping out of doors at people. It’s very disconcerting, to say the least. Went out where?”

“She didn’t say. Just out. She said something about having an appointment.”

“Did she say when she’d be back?”

“No, she didn’t. I assume, however, that it will be before six. I’m invited at six to share the ragout with her and Jay.”

“What ragout? Please don’t be so cryptic about everything!”

“The ragout that Terry left cooking in her skillet. Don’t you smell it?”

Fanny sniffed, and did, and it smelled good. She was getting hungry herself. The good smell made her mouth water.

“How do you rate an invitation? I should think I’d be the one, if anybody. After all, I’m her friend.”

“So you are. She doesn’t have too many of them, does she? Friends, I mean.”

“Women don’t like her because she’s pretty and sexy. With me that’s no issue, because I’m pretty and sexy, too.”

“The hell you are. I hadn’t noticed.”

“Brothers don’t. Not normal ones. Do you think I could be included in the invitation?”

“I doubt it. There probably wouldn’t be enough. Besides, I was invited out of compassion. I’m a poor young bachelor with nothing to look forward to but his own cooking or a Greasy Spoon somewhere.”

“Well, you’re welcome to your old ragout. I’ll make Ben take me over to the Student Union. I’ll even pick up the check if necessary.”

“You may find that a little bit difficult, little sister. Ben’s gone.”

“Gone? What do you mean?”

“How can I be more explicit? Taken off. Deserted his nest.”

“Did he go with Terry?”

“Oh, no, nothing like that. With Jay confined by his duties at the university, why should they go off together? For the accomplishment of certain things, there’s no place like home.”

“You have a lecherous mind, Farley Moran. What makes you think I was thinking of such certain things?”

“Weren’t you?”

“To be honest, I was. Ben’s an enchanting little scoundrel. I may decide to marry him if he ever shows signs of being anything more than a perennial college student. The only thing is, I suspect him of being susceptible to seduction.”

“What makes you suspect that?”

“Never mind. Did Ben say where he was going?”

“No. In fact, he was damn secretive about it. He said he’d be back Sunday evening.”

“Well, blast his treacherous little, heart He’s simply never around when I want him. Are you sure you don’t know where he went?”

“I said I didn’t. Don’t you believe me?”

“No. And it may take you quite a while to convince me, so I guess I’d better come in while you try.”

She walked past him into the room and sat down on the sofa, crossing her knees and thereby displaying — thanks to the short skirt — a pair of legs that were extremely ornamental as well as useful. Farley followed her as far as a chair, into which he collapsed.

“There’s nothing to be gained by nagging me,” he said. “I’ve told you all I know.”

“Nevertheless, it might be interesting to speculate.”

“Well, it’s obvious enough, if you ask me. No speculation is necessary.”

“I’m not so sure. Just because he was secretive is no sign he had some kind of assignation, or something. As a matter of fact, if that were the case, the little devil would probably have bragged all over the place about it. Men have no honor in such matters.”

“Do you think so?”

“Still, one can’t discount the possibility entirely. He might do something like that just to annoy me.”

“Why should it annoy you if you don’t know?”

“He may tell me afterward. In the meantime, I’m forced to speculate, which is even worse than knowing. What time did he leave?”

“About two. Just a little while before Terry left.”

“Was Terry here?”

“I said so, didn’t I? I thought I did.”

“I’m sure you didn’t. What did she want?”

“She wanted to borrow three fresh carrots for the ragout.”

“What on earth would make her think she’d find fresh carrots in this warren?”

“Well, it just happens that we had some. Ben bought them yesterday at the market.”

“If that isn’t just like him! He’s completely unpredictable. It shows, however, that he would be useful around a house. I wonder if I shouldn’t be a little more generous and give him a fair chance.”

“It might keep him home weekends. Incidentally, speaking of generosity, how about a fiver?”

“You had your monthly allowance from our wayward daddy. What the devil did you do with it?”

“My monthly allowance is hardly adequate. By the time the old man gets through paying alimony, there’s not much left for his lawful progeny.”

“As you know, there isn’t anything at all for this lawful progeny. As an efficient secretary with a thorough command of shorthand, as well as attractive legs, I earn my own way. When are you going to get that law degree, anyhow? You’re already two years past due.”

“You know I had to lay off and work a couple of years.”

“Perhaps you’d better lay off and work a couple more. Every month, what with twenty bucks here and ten there, you’re costing me at least fifty bucks.”

“Oh, come on, Fan. A lousy fiver won’t kill you. I need some gas for my car.”

“Why don’t you sell that heap? What business has a pauper got with a car?”

“Are you going to let me have the fiver or not? Be a good sis, Fan. Some day you’ll get it all back with interest.”

“I suppose I’ll have to. Here, damn it. And make it last.”

She dug the five out of her purse and, after wadding it in her hand, tossed it to him. It fell short between them, and he eyed it for a moment, as if not quite sure that picking it up was worth the effort.

“Thanks, Fan, you’re a doll. I’d offer you a beer, but Ben and Terry and I drank them all.”

“That’s all right. I prefer a martini, which I’m going up and fix for myself this instant.”

“I don’t suppose you’d want me to come up and have one with you?”

“You’re right, I wouldn’t. You have your ragout. And wash your face and hands before you go, for God’s sake.”

Fan got up and left, stepping carefully over the crumpled five-spot. Walking to the stairs, she saw that Orville Reasnor had vacated the vestibule.

Upstairs in her apartment she peeled to the buff, showered and, after a fierce struggle, got into a sweater and a pair of adhesive pants. This done, she went to the kitchen and mixed two martinis, one of which she poured and began to drink. Since she had been practically deserted by Ben, the devious little devil, she supposed she might as well eat out of the refrigerator and spend the evening at home. There was a small steak to broil, a potato to bake, and some head-lettuce for a salad. There was also this martini to finish drinking, another to follow, and more where they came from if it began to seem like a good thing. Later, for amusement, there was Joseph Andrews in the bedroom.

Not so amusing as Ben, Fan thought.

Where had he gone? Fan wondered.

And with whom?

If anybody?

3

At the precise time that Fanny was placing her potato in the oven, her brother Farley was crossing the hall. It was one minute to six, and Farley, following Fanny’s departure from his apartment, had not only washed his hands and face, he had also put on a reputable shirt, and a pair, of pants with a crease in them. His hair was brushed; his shoes, which had replaced the soiled sneakers, were shined. He had not gone so far as a coat and tie; but he had at least transformed himself into a presentable dinner guest, however casual. As such, with an air of anticipation, he knocked on Terry’s door.

The door was opened by a tall young man with that particular kind of thinness which forecasts, instead of increasing corpulence, a gaunt and cadaverous middle age. His hair, still thick, was light brown and limp, brushed laterally across a long skull from a low part on the left side. He looked out upon the world, including Farley, through thick lenses set in enormous black frames. Although he was still on the nether side of thirty, he already gave a harried effect, as though he had hunted too long in economic cyles in search of a way out.

“Oh,” he said, “it’s you, Farley. What can I do for you?”

“Hello, Jay,” Farley said. “I’ve been invited to dinner. Didn’t Terry tell you?”

“Terry isn’t home yet. Do you happen to know where she went?”

“She mentioned an appointment, but she didn’t say with whom or where. I’m sure she expected to be back by six, though. No doubt she’s been delayed.”

“No doubt. Terry’s always being delayed for one reason or another. Well, you may as well come in and wait.”

“Thanks.” Farley stepped into the room and waited while Jay, after peering down the hall, closed the door behind him. “I hope I’m not imposing.”

“Not at all. Sit down, Farley, and I’ll fix you a drink. Gin or Scotch?”

“Scotch.”

“Soda?”

“Plain water.”

“That’s good. I’m not sure I’ve any soda left, now that I think about it.”

Jay went into the kitchen and took a bottle and glasses out of a cabinet. Farley, at ease in a chair, could hear him excavating ice in the refrigerator. The simmering ragout filled the room with the most delectable odor, of bacon and steak and carrots and onions and potatoes. A happy combination, thought Farley. He regretted that he wasn’t very hungry. What he wanted most was the Scotch and water that Jay was now conveying. He accepted the glass Jay offered, raised it in salute, and took a large swallow.

Jay, holding a glass of his own, sprawled in another chair. His long thin legs gave an effect of disorganization.

“I’d better warn you,” Jay said, “that we may have a long wait. Promptness is not one of Terry’s virtues.”

“She specifically said six. She’ll probably be along in a few minutes.”

“I wouldn’t count on it. No affront intended, old man, but she’s probably forgotten all about inviting you.”

“In that case, perhaps I’d better not stay.”

“Oh, no. I wouldn’t hear of your leaving. If she doesn’t show up soon, we’ll eat the damn ragout ourselves. That’s what we’re having, you know.”

“I know, I can smell it. Besides, Terry came over earlier to borrow some carrots for it.”

“Terry never has everything she needs for anything. What time was she over?”

“It must have been shortly after one. Ben hadn’t left yet. He’s gone for the weekend now. I think that’s why Terry took pity on me and invited me to share your ragout. She and Ben and I had a beer together.”

“You said she mentioned an appointment. Did she mention what time it was for?”

“I think she said three, but I’m not sure.”

“Well, she’ll be here when she gets here. That’s about all you can say. It’s an ulcerous job keeping up on Terry’s whereabouts. I learned long ago not to try. Would you care to hear some music while we’re waiting?”

“That would be fine.”

“Any preference?”

“Anything you like.”

Jay gathered up his scattered legs and went over to the player in a kind of slow-motion lope. Adjusting his glasses on his nose, he peered down into the machine.

“There’s a Beethoven quartet already on. How about that?”

“Beethoven? Ah.”

Farley would have been just as agreeable to an offering by the Beatles; he had no taste for music of any kind. But the pretense of listening would relieve him of the necessity for making conversation, which would be a relief to Jay as well. So they sat silently in the shimmer of sound and the odor of ragout, and their glasses were empty when the recording was finished. Jay got up again and refilled glasses and turned the recording over.

“We’ll hear one more,” he said, “then we’ll eat. And to hell with it”

His voice was edged with a kind of resigned bitterness. However empty Jay’s belly was of food, Farley thought, it was full to capacity of Terry. Small wonder, really. Even after maximum concessions to Terry’s obvious allure, a man had to resent eventually the ease with which she kept slipping the ties that bind.

Not being able to think of anything appropriate to say, Farley said nothing. They sat and listened, or pretended to listen, and there was still, one string quartet and a Scotch highball later, no Terry.

“That’s it,” said Jay. “I won’t bother to apologize, Farley. Let’s eat the damn ragout before it dries out.”

Farley looked at his watch. “Terry’s an hour late, Jay. Aren’t you concerned?”

“Why should I be? This is an old story.”

“Just the same, I’d feel better if we at least made some effort to find out where she went. Honestly, Jay, she was so definite about the invitation and the time that I just can’t believe she forgot or ignored it.”

“It’s decent of you to be concerned, but I assure you it’s uncalled for. Anyhow, what can we do? She doesn’t seem to have told anyone about her plans, whatever they were.”

“Are Ardis and Otis Bowers home from the university yet? Perhaps they’d know.”

“No chance. Ardis loathes Terry, quite justifiably, and poor Otis isn’t allowed within speaking distance if Ardis can prevent it.”

“It wouldn’t do any harm, Jay, to ask them.”

“All right. Let me turn down the heat under the ragout first.”

He went into the kitchen with the empty glasses, and returned in a moment without them.

“That should hold it all right,” he said. “Talking with Ardis and Otis will get us nowhere, Farley, but I suppose you’re right about making some sort of effort. Let’s go.”

In the hall, at the foot of the staircase to the second floor, Farley, with one foot lifted to the first tread, stopped suddenly. He had been struck by an idea, apparently, and he stood pinching his lower lip while he considered it.

“I was just thinking,” he said. “Orville Reasnor may have seen Terry leave. If so, he could probably tell us about when it was. It seems to me Terry mentioned an appointment at three, but if she was a lot later than that getting away it might explain why she’s so long getting back.”

“I doubt it.” Jay was clearly impatient. “Anyway, I’m skeptical of Orville Reasnor’s ability to contribute anything enlightening to anything.”

Farley, with Jay abreast, took a turn and descended a short flight to the basement. He knocked on the door of Orville Reasnor’s bachelor quarters. In a few seconds the door swung open to reveal Orville. His lack of shirt or shoes, his attire of long Johns and heavy socks, indicated that Orville had been roused from a well-earned nap, and the indication was supported by his belligerent expression. Clearly, he was anticipating a gripe.

“Evening, Doctor,” he said to Jay, ignoring Farley. “What’s the trouble?”

Orville invariably conferred the doctorate when speaking to a member of the University faculty. Sometimes, as in Jay’s case, it was appropriate. One always had an uneasy feeling, however, that Orville used it not so much as an expression of respect as, on the other hand, of some esoteric personal insult.

“No trouble, Orville,” Jay said. “Mr. Moran and I were expecting my wife home for dinner about six, and she hasn’t got back yet. We thought, if you happened to see her leave, that you might remember what time if was.”

“I never saw her. If she’d have left between a little before two and a little after five, I’d have seen her.”

“Oh? Why so?”

“Because I was working all that time in the vestibule. She’d have had to go right past me.”

“Well, she’s gone. Maybe you just forgot.”

“Not Orville Reasnor. I don’t forget so easy. That’s not to say she couldn’t have gone out the back door into the alley. The hall’s a lot higher than the vestibule, and I couldn’t have seen nothing in the hall when I was down on my knees, which most of the time I was.”

“I guess that’s the way she went. Thanks, Orville.”

“I wouldn’t worry none if I was you, Doctor.” Orville’s little eyes had acquired a sly expression; his lips, surrounded by the day’s growth of gray stubble, twitched on the verge of a grin. “She’ll be back in her own good time, I expect.”

Jay’s lean face was wooden as he turned away; Farley, having caught the innuendo, understood Jay’s reluctance to pursue the matter. Further inquiries about Terry were an open invitation to ribaldry, and no man enjoys the cuckold’s role.

On the way upstairs Farley asked, “Does Terry often use the back door?”

“She does when our car’s parked out on the apron. Today it wasn’t. I had it on campus.”

“Well, she must have gone out that way. Maybe it was a shortcut. In the same direction she was going, I mean.”

“Of course. There’s nothing odd about using the back door. All of us do on occasion.”

Having reached the first floor, they ascended the longer flight of stairs to the second. Beyond the Bowers’s door, someone moved in response to Jay’s knock. It was Otis Bowers himself who opened. Behind Otis, wearing an apron and holding a dish towel, and watching curiously from the kitchen, was his wife Ardis.

Otis was approximately the same age and height at Jay. He had a weight problem, as Jay did, but in reverse. Where Jay was lean, with the prospect of growing leaner, Otis was fat, with the prospect of growing fatter. He was an assistant professor of physics. Ardis was a graduate student and instructor in the Department of English. Her claim to prettiness, which had some basis, was disputed by a hint around eyes and mouth of chronic acrimony; even her speech had a sour flavor.

“Hello, Jay,” Otis said. “Farley. Come in. We’ve just finished our dinner.”

“Sorry to intrude, Otis,” Jay said, stepping into the room with Farley at his shoulder. “We won’t be a minute.”

“No intrusion at all. Sit down and stay a while. We have nothing planned for the evening.”

“Thanks, Otis, but we just came up to ask if you’ve seen Terry. She invited Farley to dinner, and she seems to have gone off and forgotten all about it.”

Ardis had retreated into the kitchen. She now reappeared, as if on cue, without her towel and apron.

“Otis hasn’t seen her,” she said. “Have you, Otis?”

“No, no, I haven’t seen her. Sorry, Jay.”

Otis’s chubby pink face, normally benign, was a picture of misery. As they all knew, Ardis’s abrupt interception of Jay’s question was an oblique allusion to a painful episode involving Otis and Terry. The affair, if it could be so exaggerated, had been incited by Terry, not Otis, and he nursed no ill feelings. Ardis, however, would neither forgive nor let Otis forget.

“I meant the question to include you, Ardis.” Jay’s face was again wooden. “She might have been on campus. If so, you might have seen her.”

“Well, we didn’t. Neither Otis nor I.”

“That’s right, Jay,” said Otis. “We haven’t seen her today at all. She’s probably been delayed by something or other.”

“Yes,” said Ardis. “Something or other.”

Jay turned to the door. Otis hurried forward and held it open in a gesture of courtesy. His embarrassment was still pinkly evident.

“I’m sorry, Jay. I wish I could help you.”

“Forget it, Otis,” Jay said.

He and Farley went out into the hall, and the door closed behind them. Ardis’s voice immediately began beyond the door.

“What a bitch!” Farley said.

4

Farley’s remark, as it developed, was a cue. The door across the hall swung open and Fanny Moran popped out.

“Did someone mention me?” she said.

Farley stared at his half-sister in amazement, as if he had witnessed a minor miracle when it was least expected.

“Would you mind telling me,” he said, “how in hell you managed to hear me through that closed door? By God, you must have rabbit ears!”

“No such thing. The door was cracked open, as a matter of fact. I was listening.”

“Spying, you mean. Has anyone ever told you that you have acquired some deplorable habits?”

“There was no spying to it. I was curious, that’s all. I heard you two when you knocked on the Bowers’s door, and I was waiting for you to come out. What did you want to see Ardis and Otis about?”

“I won’t tell you. It would only be rewarding your eavesdropping.”

“Jay will tell me. Won’t you, Jay?”

But Jay and Farley had moved off down the hall. Fanny trailed after them. They paused again at the head of the stairs.

“We were inquiring about Terry,” Jay told her. “We thought they might have seen her, or might know where she went.”

“Hasn’t she come home yet?”

“No.”

“How odd. I wonder where she could be.”

“It’s not so odd, really. It isn’t even particularly unusual. I keep telling everyone.”

“Well, in my opinion, it is odd. I consider it most unlikely that Terry, after inviting Farley to dinner, would deliberately stay away.”

“We’ve been over that point, too. There’s nothing to be gained by discussing it again. Farley, you must be starving. Let’s go down and eat the damn ragout, if it’s still edible.”

“Haven’t you eaten it yet?” asked Fanny.

“No. We kept thinking Terry would be along any minute.”

“There you are, Farley,” Fanny turned to big brother with a frown. “You said I couldn’t share the ragout because there wouldn’t be enough. As it happens, there would have been plenty for all.”

“How the hell was I to know Terry wouldn’t show up? I’m no fortune-teller.”

“There would probably have been enough in any event. You were determined to exclude me, that’s all.”

“Anyhow,” said Jay, “there will be plenty now. Will you join us, Fanny?”

“It’s too late,” Fanny said. “I’ve already gone to the trouble of cooking and eating a steak and a baked potato. However, I’ll come along to keep you company. Perhaps you can give me a drink or something.”

“Agreed,” said Jay.

“She’s incorrigible,” said Farley. “She has absolutely no sense of propriety whatever.”

In the downstairs hall, outside Jay’s apartment, Farley paused and looked down the hall toward the alley exit. Like the vestibule, it was at the bottom of a shallow flight of stairs.

“I don’t suppose there is anything to be learned from checking the back door,” he said.

“I don’t see what,” Jay said, pushing his own door open. “It has a nightlatch. Anyone can go out that way. Besides, it’s left unlocked most of the time, so that anyone who parks on the apron can get in. I think Orville locks it for the night at eleven. After that, anyone who wants in has to come around to the front entrance. Damn it, don’t try to make a police case out of this, Farley. You know and I know that Terry’s simply on the loose. Let’s leave it like that.”

They went inside; the ragout, keeping warm, still smelled good. Fanny and Farley stopped in the living room, and Jay went into the kitchen. China and silverware, being removed from the places where they were kept, made identifiable noises.

“Are you wearing pants,” Farley said, “or has your skin turned blue?”

“Don’t be absurd,” Fanny said. “All girls wear tight pants these days. It’s the style.”

“It’s a wonder to me how they get in and out of them.”

“You mustn’t be prudish, big brother. It doesn’t suit you. If I am any judge of male character, you know perfectly well how they do.”

Jay appeared in the kitchen doorway holding a large serving spoon, with which he gestured like a cop directing traffic.

“Come and get it, Farley,” he said. “There’s no use making a production out of this. Serve yourself from the skillet and eat here in the living room if you like.”

“I’ll serve,” said Fanny. “I can be useful as well as ornamental.”

She went into the kitchen, relieving Jay of the serving spoon as she passed, and began to fill a plate from the skillet. She passed the plate to Farley, who had followed, and began to fill another.

“Just a little for me,” Jay said. “I’m not very hungry.”

“Neither am I,” said Farley.

“The ragout looks wonderful,” Fanny said, “in spite of cooking so long. I must learn how to make it.”

“Won’t you have some?” Jay said. “There’s more than enough.”

“I couldn’t possibly. I’ll put some coffee on to perc.”

“Thanks, Fanny. As long as you’re being useful, would you mind fixing your own drink? The stuff’s there in the cabinet,”

Fan put the coffee on and got a bottle of gin out of the cabinet. She couldn’t locate any vermouth for a martini, but she found a bottle of quinine water and made a minimum gin and tonic, not bothering with lemon or lime. She carried it into the living room, where Farley and Jay were eating the good ragout with less enthusiasm than it deserved. Sipping her gin and tonic, she looked at a Picasso print on the wall; she went over and stared for a moment at the record player; she examined carefully, one by one, all the items on the telephone table; finally she drifted into the bedroom. When she returned her glass was empty, and so was Farley’s plate. Jay’s plate, however, still held some of the ragout, pushed to one side as if it had been emphatically scorned and rejected.

“Shall I serve you some more ragout?” Fanny asked.

“No more for me,” said Farley.

“No, thank you,” said Jay.

“How was it?”

“Delicious,” Farley said.

“Too damn many onions,” Jay said. “Terry knows very well that I like her to use fewer onions than the recipe calls for. They don’t agree with me — a soupçon is plenty. She did it deliberately. We haven’t been exactly congenial lately.”

“Oh, nonsense!” Fanny’s derision was palpable. “If you ask me, Jay, you are simply being petty. There was nothing to compel her to fix your dinner at all.”

Jay said something impolite. “See if the coffee’s ready, will you, Fanny?”

Carrying the two plates, she went to see. The coffee was.

“Sugar or cream?” she called.

“Black,” they both said.

She delivered the coffee and returned to the kitchen. She found a plastic refrigerator dish and put the leftover ragout in it. Then she washed and dried the two plates, the silverware, and the electric skillet. She considered another gin and tonic, decided against it, and went back into the living room. She sat down on a sofa, raising her knees and hugging them to her chest, thereby creating a perilous tautness over a choice section of her anatomy.

“While you guys were eating,” she said, “I looked for clues.”

“Clues to what?” Jay said.

“Clues to wherever Terry might have gone.”

“Of all the colossal nerve!” Farley said. “I wondered what the devil you thought you were doing, prowling around and prying into everything.”

“Looking for clues is not prowling or prying. Obviously, Farley, you’re determined to put everything I do or say in the worst possible light. If Terry had an appointment, it’s reasonable to assume that she might have made a note of it somewhere.”

“Now that you mention it, it is,” Farley conceded.

“I couldn’t find it, however. Not on the table by the telephone or on her dressing table in the bedroom. Can you think of any place else likely to look?”

Jay’s voice was quietly desperate. “Terry’s appointments are rarely the kind she’d make written notes of to leave lying about. I don’t want to appear ungrateful, but I’d appreciate your just cutting it out. I have a notion where Terry went, if you must know, but I have no intention of proving myself right by going after her. I’ve become weary of painful scenes.”

“Well,” said Fanny, “I have no wish to intrude where I’m not wanted. But I’m compelled to point out that a lot of people seem to be jumping to a certain conclusion. It’s being assumed Terry is out having a time. That is not, as I see it, necessarily so.”

Jay shrugged angrily. “What do you expect me to do?”

“If I were her husband, I would at least call the hospitals and see if there have been any accidents or anything like that.”

“She was carrying a purse with identification in it. If she’d been in an accident, I’d have been notified.”

“Perhaps she was mugged and robbed. If so, the mugger would have run off with the purse and thrown it away somewhere.”

“All right, damn it! If she isn’t back by ten, I’ll call the hospitals. Nothing will come of it, but I suppose I’m expected to act like a husband.”

“If you ask me, you aren’t even acting like a husband whose wife may be out having a good time.”

“I used to act like one,” said Jay, “but I got tired of it.”

Farley had been pinching his lower lip, thinking hard. Now he said suddenly to Fanny, “Was there a memo pad on the table by the telephone?”

“I didn’t see any. Why?”

“I was just thinking. When there isn’t anything else handy, don’t women often make notes of appointments on old envelopes, the margins of magazines, things like that?”

“Farley, sometimes you show faint signs of intelligence,” Fanny said. “There are some magazines in that bucket at the end of the sofa. I believe I’ll look at them, Jay, if you don’t mind.”

“Help yourself,” said Jay.

The bucket was just that. Fanny removed its contents, half a dozen magazines and a newspaper. Kneeling, she began to examine the magazines, looking at the covers, riffling rapidly through the pages to check the margins. Jay leaned back in his chair and closed his eyes, bearing the futility of it all with a pretense of patience; Farley, after a moment, went over and sat down on the end of the sofa, by the bucket He reached for the newspaper and began to examine it, holding it folded over in his hands just as he had picked it up. It was folded twice at a page of classified ads, including a column of personals.

“Wait a minute!” Farley’s voice had acquired all at once an excitement qualified by incredulity. “What’s this?”

“What’s what?” said Fanny, looking up.

“It’s damn funny, that’s all I can say. Here, Jay, you’d better read this.”

Jay Miles opened his eyes. Farley, rising again, walked over and handed him the newspaper, indicating with his index finger an item. Jay stared at the item for a long time. Then he sighed, twisted the paper into a tight roll, and slapped a bony knee with it. Leaning back, he closed his eyes again.

“Damn it, what is it?” Fanny said. “Am I allowed to know, or not?”

Farley took the paper from Jay’s hand and read aloud: “‘T. M. Friday at three. Stacks. Level C. O.’”

Fanny jumped up, snatched the paper, and read it for herself. Then, as if to dispose of it once and for all, she dropped the paper back into the wooden bucket.

“That’s that,” she said. “T. M. is Terry Miles. Today is Friday. Three is when she said she had an appointment. Stacks and level clearly refer to a library, probably the one at the university. But who in hell is O?”

“That,” Farley said, “is none of your goddam business.”

Jay stirred. His face was strangely untroubled. The Personal, rather than increasing his anxiety, seemed actually to have relieved it.

“It’s just a coincidence,” he said.

“Are you serious?” Fanny stared at him. “Some coincidence, if you ask me!”

“No.” Jay rose and jammed his hands into his pockets, shaking his head with a kind of dogged stubbornness. “Think. Terry is devious and inclined to do weird things, but why not a note in the mail? Why not a telephone call? For that matter, why not direct contact at the apartment? Terry’s alone here almost every day, and there wouldn’t have been any problems. Then why a Personal? There’s simply no sense to it.”

“There may be no sense on the face of it,” said Fanny, “but there may be more to it than the face.”

“I don’t think so.” Jay removed his glasses, polished the lenses on his handkerchief, and replaced them. “Believe me, I know Terry. Anyway, no one has anything to worry about except me, and I’ve developed a kind of immunity. Thanks for your concern, but I’m rather tired. Do you mind?”

“He means,” said Farley, “will we get the hell out.”

“I know what he means,” Fanny said. “I must say, however, that he is kicking, us out like a perfect gentleman.”

5

Farley veered off toward his own door.

“Farley,” said Fanny, “get your topcoat on. I’ll be down in a minute.”

“Topcoat?” Judging by the astonishment in Farley’s voice, he might have been ordered to remove his pants. “Why in hell should I put on my topcoat?”

“Because it’s cold outside, that’s why.”

“It may be cold outside, little sister, but I’m inside. And inside is where I’m going to stay.”

“Please don’t drag your heels, Farley. You and Jay may feel inclined to leave things as they are, but I feel differently.”

“Oh, butt out, Fan. Can’t you see the poor guy just doesn’t want to make a display of his embarrassment?”

“Yes, but it has also occurred to me that Jay’s embarrassment may not be the only consideration in this matter. Or even the primary one.”

“Nuts. I admit I was worried at first, but now I’m not. At this moment Terry is loitering at the first corner of the current triangle. Jay’s occupying the second corner; and if you ask me, he knows the occupant of the third corner, if he cared to go there and make a fool of himself.”

They had been talking in low voices outside Farley’s door. Farley, after making this statement, which he meant to be conclusive, opened his door with the obvious intention of shutting it again between him and Fanny. But Fanny, with other intentions, slipped quickly past him into the room and turned to face him as he shut it in defeat on the space she had been occupying.

“The first corner is what’s bothering me,” Fanny said. “There are some very suspicious circumstances here, if you ask me.”

“You mean the Personal?”

“Partly that. Mostly, however, I’m thinking how Ben, the ugly little devil, just happened to go off somewhere a little while before Terry went. They could have met outside. It wouldn’t surprise me a bit if they did.”

“Ben and Terry? Little sister, you’re getting brain-fag, or you’ve had too much gin.”

“I’m not, and I haven’t. It’s easy to underestimate Ben. As I know from experience, he can be extremely fascinating when he wants to be. He appeals to the mother instinct.”

“In that case, you have nothing to worry about. Terry doesn’t have a mother instinct. Look, Terry and Ben were here with me this afternoon. If they had anything cooked up between them, they were the best actors that ever lived.”

“I’m hardly convinced by that. To be honest, brother, you’re not as smart about such things as a lawyer ought to be. Almost anyone could deceive you.”

“Do you agree that the Personal was directed to Terry?”

“In spite of Jay’s pretense that it was a coincidence, I agree that it probably was.”

“There you are, then. Why the hell should old Ben resort to such a stratagem when all he had to do was step across the hall almost any time he chose?”

“Did I say the Personal was put in the paper by Ben? I don’t recall that I did.”

“You implied it. Surely the Personal was Terry’s reason for going wherever she went.”

“I implied no such thing. I merely said it was suspicious that Ben and Terry went off so close together. Perhaps he waited somewhere nearby and took her to keep the appointment. Perhaps he met her somewhere after the appointment.”

“Well, if you don’t have a mind like a scatter gun! It’s impossible to tell what you’ll think of next. As Jay pointed out, why should anyone publish the Personal? Why not write or phone? Do you have an answer to that, little sister?”

“It could have been placed by someone who didn’t know Terry’s address or phone number. She must have talked to this person, whoever he is — she wouldn’t have known otherwise to look out for the Personal. But she refused to tell him how to write or call her.”

“That narrows it down a lot. We now know that we are looking for an illiterate. Someone, for example, who can’t read names in a telephone directory.”

“No such thing. It so happens that the Miles telephone is unlisted.”

“The hell you say! How do you know?”

“Because I wanted to call Terry from the office one day, and I couldn’t find the number in the telephone book. Later she told me it was unlisted and gave me the number in case I ever wanted to call again.”

“I must say you have a way of finding out things.”

“I am merely observant and intelligent.”

“As well as sexy.”

“That’s true. And a little curious. My curiosity has been aroused, and I intend to satisfy it. There is something ominous, if you ask me, about that Personal. It is not at all the way to conduct a love affair. In my opinion, it involves something else entirely. And whatever it involves, I suspect that Ben is in it somehow, on Terry’s side or the other.”

“You’re getting worse and worse. First you suspect old Ben of simple fornication, and then of mysterious involvements. Maybe he’s a kind of poor man’s James Bond or something. He just likes to combine business with pleasure.”

“Don’t be silly. I’ve already told you what he is. He’s an idiot. I confess that I’ve become too damn fond of him, however, and I wouldn’t want him to get into trouble.”

“If you want to keep him out of trouble, why don’t you keep him home? Apparently you haven’t been making things interesting enough for him.”

“I’m afraid you’re right. Perhaps I should allow him more privileges. Anyhow, we have deduced that Terry went off to meet someone at the university library, and I’m going right over there to see if I can learn anything. Are you coming with me or not?”

“Not. And you’re not going without me. Damn it, you can’t be wandering around alone at this hour of the night!”

“Can’t I? Try and stop me.”

“Be reasonable, Fan. It’s almost ten o’clock; the library will close in another hour. It’s been seven hours since Terry was there, if she ever was. What can you hope to learn now?”

“That remains to be seen. It’s better to be doing something than nothing, especially if circumstances have made it impossible to sleep or anything trivial like that.”

“Since when has sleeping become trivial?”

“Oh, go to sleep, then! I don’t care. I might have known you’d fail me the first time I asked you to help.”

“All right, all right.” Farley slapped his thigh in a gesture of disgusted concession. “I suppose I’ll have to go along. If you want my opinion, though, I think it’s no better than invasion of privacy.”

“That’s just like you, Farley. You ask if I want your opinion, which I don’t, and then go right ahead and give it to me anyhow. I’ll run up and get my coat.”

She hurried upstairs. In her bedroom she donned a lined trench coat, which seemed appropriate to detection. Since she did not like to return to a dark apartment at night, she turned on the bed lamp before switching off the ceiling light. Then she went into the kitchen and turned on a small light above the range. While there she briefly considered the advisability of having a quick nip against the cold, but rejected it. Back in the living room she switched off the ceiling light, pausing only long enough to note with relief how light splashed into the darkness from the bedroom on one side and the kitchen on the other. Downstairs she found Farley, in his topcoat, sulkily waiting in the hall.

They went out the alley door to Farley’s old Ford on the apron. It was cold outside, near freezing, but the sky was clear, with lofty stars and a slice of moon. Farley was sullen at having to go, and they drove in stiff silence to the Handclasp campus, which was not far away, and across to the library, the only building on the campus left with a blaze of lights.

Parking was no problem at this hour. They parked at the curb and went up a long walk to the building, passing reference rooms to right and left, and upstairs to the charging desk. The girl at the desk was trying to sustain the illusion of efficiency, but her eyes were heavy behind her thick glasses. She answered Fan’s questions dully. She had not been on duty at three o’clock, so she could not tell if Mrs. Miles had been in the library or not. She did not know Mrs. Miles, moreover, and could not have told in any event, unless Mrs. Miles had presented her stack permit.

“Say!” said Fanny, “I didn’t think of that. How could Terry have met someone in the stacks if she didn’t have a permit? Farley, do you happen to know if she has one?”

“I’m sure she has,” Farley said, “as the wife of a faculty member. It’s a courtesy.”

“That’s so,” said the heavy-eyed girl.

“Well,” Fanny said, “Farley is only a student, and I am only a sister, which is not so grand as being a wife, but I’d like to be admitted to the stacks, anyway.”

“Do you have a permit?” the girl said to Farley.

“Certainly.”

“Go ahead,” she said.

“I guess I’ll have to,” Farley said. “Although I can’t see any sense to it.”

They passed through into the stacks, which were erected on low-ceilinged levels from basement up. Level C was below them, and so they descended narrow steel steps and turned down an aisle between shelves of books. At the far end, beyond a cross-aisle, ranged a row of carrels, each furnished with a desk and chair. All the carrels were dark, except one in which a late bookworm toiled over a tome.

“I am thinking,” said Fanny, “that one of these alcoves would make a dandy place to meet somebody.”

“That depends,” Farley said, “on the purpose of the meeting. For private conversation, yes. For private frolic, no.”

“What other purpose can you think of, where Terry is concerned?”

“None at the moment. Incidentally, whoever she met had to be someone with a permit.”

“Logical. It also narrows the suspects down to about ten thousand people.”

“Fewer than that, I think. I’m sure we can eliminate the freshmen.”

“With Terry how can you be sure of anything? But I’ll concede on other grounds. Freshmen are not admitted to the stacks.”

“In any event, it is clearly impossible now to tell if Terry was here at three o’clock or not. We had better leave.”

“We had much better,” said Farley, “never have come at all.”

They left the library. At the curb beside the Ford, Fanny stopped and stared for a moment at a cast-iron VIP posed on a marble pedestal across the street.

“You’re thinking again,” Farley groaned. “What now?”

“I’m thinking that a library is not, after all, an ideal place for a tryst. Especially if something more than conversation is contemplated.”

“If there was a tryst, remember? If Terry was ever here at all.”

“That’s understood. It isn’t necessary to qualify every statement, Farley.”

“It isn’t necessary to prolong this foolishness, either. Let’s go home.”

“Well, I can’t think of any place else to go, except the Student Union. We could ask there if anyone saw Terry with anyone.”

“The Student Union! I’ve got news for you, sister. The Student Union is not an ideal place for a tryst, either, if something more than conversation is contemplated. All you can contemplate there is billiards or watching television or something like that.”

“It wouldn’t do any harm to ask.”

“It wouldn’t do any good, either. Chances are a hundred to one against finding anyone who even knows Terry, let alone who saw her there this afternoon and remembers it. I’m going home, Fan, and that’s that.”

“I dare say you’re right.” Fanny, for a wonder, was submissive. “We may as well. Perhaps Terry will return before morning, if she hasn’t already.”

Arriving shortly thereafter at The Cornish Arms, they drove up the alley and onto the apron, below the rear window of Farley’s apartment. Moments later, at the door Fanny cursed softly.

“Damn!” she said. “Orville has locked the back door for the night. Well have to walk around.”

They walked around to the front entrance and up the steps from the vestibule into the hall.

“Come have a nightcap,” Farley said.

“Beer? No, thanks.”

“I’m out of beer. I told you that this afternoon. I’ve got a little gin.”

“In that case, I accept.”

They had the nightcap, which Farley fixed in the kitchen while Fanny waited in the living room, and then Fanny went upstairs and struggled out of her tight pants and climbed into the loose ones of her pajamas. It was going on midnight, and in spite of the worrisome, puzzling developments of the night she was very sleepy.

She slept through the night like a log, as the saying goes. Although as Fan often pointed out, it has never been established that a log sleeps.

6

Fan slept so soundly that she woke the next morning with a hangover. On her stomach, her face buried in her pillow, she raised her head heavily and squinted at her alarm clock. If she were seeing right, and if the clock were not telling a lie, she had exactly fifteen minutes to bathe and dress and get to work — clearly an impossibility, even if she skipped breakfast.

Her own alarm system began ringing dire warnings of an irate employer and immediate dismissal. Fan bounced out of bed and sprang wildly for the bathroom. She was standing there with her pajama pants in a limp little heap around her feet before she remembered that this was Saturday morning, no work today, and to hell with alarm clocks and employers.

Weak with relief, she hoisted her pants and retied the string and strolled back to her bed and sat down on the edge of it. She had been shocked so widely awake that it was now hopeless to try to go back to sleep.

She began to think in terms of a leisurely shower and breakfast. The soft and silken feeling of having two whole days with nothing to do was nicely developing when all at once the events of the previous evening returned to her clearing head.

Had Terry come home in the night?

And where the devil was Ben?

Fan put coffee on in the kitchen and returned to the bathroom for her shower. Dressed and brushed, she boiled an egg, toasted a slice of bread, and ate the egg and toast with two cups of black coffee and strawberry jam. She washed her breakfast things and put them away, and then she was ready to apply herself to the problems at hand. A minute later she was rapping briskly on Farley’s door downstairs.

No answer — clearly, Farley was still asleep or had gone out. Of these alternatives, the former was more likely. This conclusion called for repeated and louder knocking, which Fanny was prepared to administer; but then it occurred to her that the best policy, when you wanted information, was to go to the horse’s mouth. So she moved across the hall to Jay Miles’s door and, stooping to plant an ear close to the panel, listened shamelessly. She was rewarded by the faint sound of movement within, and Fan knocked. After a moment the door was opened by Jay, who had been interrupted in the act of tying a knot in a black string tie.

“How do you do that without a mirror?” Fanny said. “It looks hard.”

“It’s easy,” Jay said. “What do you want, Fanny? I’m in a hurry.”

“Are you going somewhere?”

“I have a Saturday morning class.”

“Oh, then Terry got home all right last night.”

“Your concern is commendable, but your assumption is wrong. Terry didn’t get home last night, or this morning either.”

“Well, are you just going off calmly to meet a ridiculous class when your wife is missing and unaccounted for?”

“Exactly. What alternative would you suggest?”

“Did you call the hospitals last night?”

“I did. As I predicted, quite needlessly.”

“If she were my wife, I’d call the police this instant.”

“If you were and did, Terry would have your scalp. Believe me, the last thing Terry would want is the police messing around in this. How can I make you understand, Fanny? I don’t want to appear churlish, but I’d appreciate it if you would stay out of my personal affairs.”

“Oh, all right. I know when I’m not wanted.”

“I’m sorry. Now, if you will excuse me, I have to finish dressing.”

He shut the door quietly in Fanny’s face; and Fanny, ignored at one door and rejected at the other, climbed upstairs to her own apartment and had a third cup of the coffee. She felt by no means deflated. If Terry was Jay’s business, Ben was hers, and she was not prepared to relinquish her rights in the old devil so long as there was even a suggestion of his involvement. Or the least hope of rescuing him from his delinquency. On second thought, it was probably just as well, everything considered, to delay notifying the police.

The Personal was what made things so confused. If Ben was involved, the Personal made no sense. Besides being too devious for Ben’s tastes, it was susceptible to detection and correct interpretation, and thereby risky. And why the ‘O.’ instead of ‘B.’, inasmuch as ‘T.M.’ was used instead of something deceptive? It made no sense whatever. Could it be, as Jay insisted, that the Personal was just a coincidence? It would surely be enlightening, Fanny thought, to know who had placed it in the paper.

The thought became instantly a resolution to find out. It would give her something to do while Farley snored and Jay taught his class. Something constructive might come of it, although Fan had reservations. It did not do to expect too much, she had learned, because it only increased your disappointment when you got too little — or nothing.

She was not sure that newspapers divulged the identity of users of their Personal columns. They might consider it confidential information like doctors and lawyers and the clergy. There was no point in speculating about it, however. She could learn by trying, and that was what she was going to do.

The Personal had appeared in The Journal, the only paper in town with considerable circulation. Fanny happened to know where its offices and plant were located, for she passed the building every day going to work on the bus. She put on hat and coat and gloves and went down to the bus stop on the corner and caught a bus going downtown.

At the Journal building, Fan was directed to Classified Ads. She found it without difficulty. Behind a high counter, a breasty woman asked her crisply, in a voice that defied her to do so, if she wished to place an ad.

“I don’t wish to place one,” said Fanny, “but I’d like to find out the name of someone who did.”

“Wasn’t the name published with the ad? Can you tell me the kind of ad it was?”

“It appeared in the Personal column of the Thursday evening edition.”

The woman’s expression immediately said that she had just been asked to commit treason.

“I’m sorry. The identity of Personal placers is not revealed.”

“It’s important.”

“No, no. It’s quite impossible.”

“Well,” said Fanny, stretching the facts to fit the occasion, “it is probable that whoever inserted that ad is some kind of criminal. Well, I suppose you’re honor bound to protect him.”

“There is no certainty that we know the identity of the party. We often don’t in Personals, you know.” It was now evident in the woman’s face that rules and curiosity were at odds. “Do you have a copy of the newspaper with you?”

“No, I don’t, but I can quote the ad.”

Fanny quoted it verbatim, having a retentive memory. It was apparent at once that the woman remembered it. It was equally apparent, from the way honor rose above curiosity, that honor had won a cheap victory.

“I remember the item very well,” the woman said. “It came in the mail with cash payment enclosed. I know because it came to my desk, and I arranged myself for its publication. I haven’t, of course, the least idea who sent it. Sorry I can’t help you.”

When Fan left the Journal building, it was approaching noon and seemed a long time from her boiled egg. She decided to lunch downtown. But first she spent half an hour in, a department store resisting the temptation to buy several items she did not need. Then she went to the café in a hotel where the blue-plate special was corned beef and cabbage and little boiled potatoes sprinkled with parsley. After lunching on this, with just one martini beforehand to whet her appetite, she caught another bus and returned to The Cornish Arms.

From the vestibule she walked directly back to Farley’s door and began to knock on it loudly, convinced that it was high time Farley was getting up if he hadn’t already done so. As it turned out he had, but only recently, for he was, although dressed, still disheveled and surly. He glared at Fanny with animosity.

“Stop that damn banging!” he said. “What the hell do you think you’re doing?”

The order to stop banging was ex post facto, since it had necessarily stopped when he pulled the door away from her fist. So Fanny, ignoring it, slipped past into the room and turned to face him with disapproval.

“I think I’m doing things that need doing, that’s what I think. While you have been sleeping and Jay has been off doing inconsequential things, I have been busy trying to discover what’s become of Terry. How do you expect to accomplish anything by lying in bed?”

Farley fell into a chair and finger-combed his tousled hair with a temperate despair. His glare had diminished in animosity.

“Which means,” he said, “that you have been making a pest of yourself again. Fan, why don’t you have the common decency to mind your own business? What, precisely, have you been up to now?”

“I’ve been downtown to the newspaper office to see if I could find out who placed the Personal, but I couldn’t They have some kind of rule against telling. They didn’t know, anyhow, because the Personal was sent in the mail. My efforts went for nothing.”

“Serves you right. Maybe now you will butt out and stay out. Did you inquire before you left if Terry had come back or not?”

“I’m not as addle-headed as you seem to think, Farley. I asked Jay.”

“What did Jay say?”

“He said Terry hadn’t returned.”

“Did he also suggest that you quit meddling?”

“Well, yes, he did, as a matter of fact.”

“Good! I recommend that you comply.”

“You’re as bad as Jay, Farley, and that’s the truth. Neither of you is willing to take any action whatever in this matter. If you ask me, it’s not natural for a husband to be so indifferent to the unexplained absence of his wife.”

“Jay’s not indifferent. He’s stoic. He has become inured by constant repetition.”

“I don’t care a hang what you call it, it’s not natural. And, as I recall, you were kind of disturbed yourself in the beginning. What suddenly happened to make you change, I’d like to know?”

“Nothing happened. I merely decided to observe a period of quiet out of respect for the dead.”

“Dead!” Fanny gave a startled little leap. “Are you implying that Terry is dead?”

“Hell, no. I was referring to the Terry-Jay marriage. Surely you’re perceptive enough to see that it is, as the saying goes, as dead as last year’s bird nest.”

“Is that all?” Fanny relaxed. “I know you and Jay are convinced that nothing is indicated but a peccadillo, but I have been making an effort to learn the truth, and it’s my opinion that it’s time you did a little something to help.”

“Not I. I’ve withdrawn from the fray.”

“We’ll see about that. There is something helpful you can do without setting foot from this apartment.”

“Such as?”

“Such as calling the taxi companies. They must keep a record of calls, and one of them may be able to tell you if someone was picked up here, or near here, about three o’clock yesterday.”

“Like hell! I don’t intend to waste my time calling taxi companies.”

“Why not? Your time is largely wasted, anyhow. We could find out where Terry was taken, if she was taken.”

“If there’s anything to this Personal that’s got you so hot and bothered, she only went to the university library. The distance is easily walkable.”

“Because she went there is no sign she stayed there. She could have gone on in the taxi to some place else with whomever she met.”

“I simply won’t call any taxi companies. There’s no use asking me.”

“Very well. And next time you want five, or ten or twenty dollars, I simply won’t give it to you. There’ll be no use asking me.”

“So that’s the way it is!” Farley glared at her with a resurgence of his early animosity. “Blackmail!”

“I prefer to call it fair pay for services rendered. No services, no pay.”

“All right, damn it! If you’re going to be so nasty about it, I’ll have to humor you. Now get out of here, Fan. Go think of something else useless to do.”

He got up and, taking her firmly by an elbow, ushered Fanny to the door.

“Wait a minute,” said Fanny. “Not so fast, brother. I’m sorry to say that you can’t always be trusted to keep your word. When will you make the calls?”

“Just as soon as I’ve had some breakfast.”

“Breakfast! It’s past lunch time.”

“Breakfast, lunch, shmunch. As soon as I’ve eaten. Not before.”

“All right, then. But see that you do. If you don’t, I’ll make you sorry.”

Fanny permitted herself to be pushed into the hall. And at that moment, as luck would have it, there was Jay Miles, returning from the university.

7

“Hello, Fanny,” said Jay. “I was hoping to see you.”

“Were you?” said Fanny skeptically. “Why?”

“Well, I was pretty rude to you this morning. I want to apologize.”

“However rude you were,” Farley said, “it probably wasn’t rude enough. When you learn what this femme has been up to, you may want to insult her some more.”

“What have you been up to, Fanny?”

“Go on, Fanny,” Farley said. “Tell him what you’ve been up to.”

“I went down to the Journal office and inquired about the Personal. I wanted, if possible, to know who placed it.”

“Oh? Did you learn anything?”

“Nothing. The Personal was mailed in with the fee — in cash — enclosed.”

“Too bad you went to so much trouble for nothing.” Jay seemed surprisingly docile about the episode. “I told you last night the Personal was a coincidence, not directed to Terry at all. Didn’t you remember?”

“I remembered, but I didn’t believe it. And nothing’s developed, so far as I can see, to make me believe it now.”

“You see?” said Farley. “She simply will not mind her own business.”

“To be fair, I can’t say I blame her for being concerned. I’m really not so indifferent as I seem.” Jay, although he spoke without urgency, was clearly appealing for Fanny’s understanding. “As a matter of fact, I’ve been cudgeling my brain over this ever since last night, and I think I’ve finally come up with the answer. I owe you an explanation for all your worry and trouble. If you’d care to come in—”

“I accept both your apology and your invitation,” said Fanny. “Farley, go get your breakfast, or whatever you want to call it.”

“Not much,” Farley said. “If Jay’s going to explain something, I want to hear it, too.”

Jay unlocked his door and they all went in. He was carrying a briefcase, which he took into the bedroom while Fanny and Farley helped themselves to chairs.

“May I get you a drink?” Jay said, returning.

“Not for me,” Farley said. “My stomach’s empty.”

“Nor me,” said Fanny. “I had a martini with my lunch, and I can’t have any more until five o’clock. Where do you think Terry has gone? I’m dying to know.”

“I think she’s gone back to Los Angeles.”

“Back to Los Angeles?” said Fanny. “Is that where, she came from?”

“Yes. Didn’t you know? Actually, we were married in San Francisco. I had a job at the university there, and Terry had moved up from L.A. and was living alone in an apartment. Not attending the university, you understand. She just wanted to try living in San Francisco for a while. New experience. Terry was always keen for a new experience. Anyhow, we met at a party and got married. I don’t quite understand why. I went head over heels for her, of course, but somehow I never felt that I was the type to make Terry reciprocate. Perhaps she just had an urge to try the academic life.”

“But why would she run off to Los Angeles without a word to you or anyone else? If you ask me, it makes no sense.”

“It makes Terry’s kind of sense. If you knew her better, you’d understand that. She is perfectly capable of doing on impulse something that someone else would plan carefully.”

“Even after inviting Farley to dinner?”

“That would be no deterrent to Terry. She was probably halfway to L.A. before she even remembered it.”

“What about luggage?” Fanny pounced on the thought triumphantly. “Did she take any?”

“Apparently not. But it’s no more than two hours from here to L.A. by jet, and after she was there, she could easily prevail on Feldman to supply anything she needed.”

“Feldman?” Farley said. “Who’s Feldman?”

“Yes, Jay,” said Fanny, “please don’t just throw in new characters. It’s very confusing.”

“Maurice Feldman, an attorney. To be exact, he’s the executor of an estate left to Terry by her father, who was a minor movie executive.”

“You mean Terry is an heiress? I didn’t dream of such a thing!”

“Well, we didn’t talk about it much. It’s a pretty large estate, I think, but Terry won’t get control of it until she’s twenty-six, which will be about a year from now. Meanwhile Feldman doles out a limited allowance from the interest on the principal.”

“Why would Terry’s father want to tie things up that way?”

“Need you ask?” Jay shrugged. He fished in a pocket for cigarette and matches and, having found them, did nothing further about them. “Surely it’s evident by this time that a sense of responsibility is not one of Terry’s attributes. Her father didn’t want to cut her off, but he hoped a delay would bring a little more maturity. Wishful thinking, I’m afraid.”

Fanny rose, took the cigarette and matches from Jay’s hands, lit the former with one of the latter, and sat down again.

“Since you are not going to smoke this,” she said, “I may as well. I must say, Jay, I’m not completely convinced. Is there any particular reason why Terry should suddenly have decided to go back to Los Angeles?”

“She was always threatening to. She didn’t want to come to Handclasp in the first place. She was never happy here. If the offer by the university hadn’t been so attractive, I’d probably have stayed in Frisco.”

“If she’s gone back to Los Angeles, it should be easy to check. As you say, she’d certainly get in touch with this Mr. Feldman, because of the allowance and all. Why don’t you call him and ask?”

“I intend to, this evening.”

“Why don’t you call him now?”

“No. I’ve decided to wait a little longer.”

“There you are, Fanny,” Farley said. “I hope you’re satisfied and will stop making a nuisance of yourself.”

Fanny’s retort, which was on the tip of her tongue, was stymied by a knock on the door. Her first thought was that here was Terry, home from the wars. But, on second thought, it would be ridiculous for Terry to knock on her own door. On the other hand, she might consider it wise, under the circumstances, to throw in her hat before entering.

It was not Terry at all, of course, but Otis Bowers.

“Hello, Otis,” Jay said. “What can I do for you?”

“I wonder,” said Otis, “if I could borrow some matches. I seem to be out.”

“Sure.” Jay stepped back, giving Otis a clear view of Fanny and Farley, whom Otis had been trying to see around Jay’s shoulder. “Come on in.”

Otis came in. Jay headed for the kitchen, where the matches were.

“Hello, Fanny, Farley,” Otis said. “I just knocked on your door, Fanny, but I couldn’t raise you.”

“Obviously,” said Fanny, “since I am here and not there. What are you looking for, Otis?”

Otis’s head, which had been turning this way and that, suddenly assumed a fixity, eyes front, as if he were afraid of the consequences of turning it at all.

“Nothing,” he said. “Nothing at all. I just came to borrow some matches.”

“I thought maybe you were looking for Terry. If you were, you can quit. She isn’t here.”

“Little sister,” Farley said, “why don’t you shut up? If Jay wants a mouthpiece, I’m sure he’ll ask for one.”

“Well, what’s the matter with you, Farley?” Fanny said indignantly. “What’s the harm, I’d like to know, in telling Otis that Terry isn’t here when he can plainly see for himself that she isn’t? I don’t understand your attitude at all.”

“Oh, I give up!” said Farley. “By God, I do!”

“What’s all the fuss about?” Otis said. “Didn’t Terry get home last night?”

“No,” Farley said, “she didn’t.”

“Jay thinks she went to Los Angeles,” Fanny said. “Isn’t that so, Jay?”

“Yes.” Jay, having completed his round trip to the kitchen, handed Otis half a dozen matchbooks.

“But why Los Angeles?” Otis said.

“We’ve been all over that,” said Fanny. “If you want to know things, Otis, why don’t you get in at the beginning?”

“Never mind,” Jay said. “There’s no point in dwelling on the matter. Otis, I believe there’s enough matches there to last until you can get more.”

“Yes. Yes, this is plenty, Jay. Thanks very much.”

Jay, when he had come away from the door after admitting Otis, had left it open, possibly as a hint to his guests, but the effect, unfortunately, was only to gather another. Otis, on his way out, was suddenly face to face with his wife. Ardis had appeared on the threshold and was nosing into the room.

“Otis,” she said, “what are you doing down here? I thought you were just going across the hall to borrow some matches from Fanny.”

“Fanny isn’t home,” Otis said.

“As you see,” said Fanny.

“Did you get some matches?”

“Yes. Jay loaned me some.”

“Then we had better go back upstairs.” Ardis leaned forward into the room and craned, like her husband before her, this way and that. “Where’s Terry? Didn’t she come back last night?”

It was evident from her tone that she considered it Jay’s good luck if Terry hadn’t. Jay obliged woodenly by confirming her hopes.

“Jay thinks she’s in Los Angeles,” said Fanny.

“Los Angeles! Whatever for?”

“There are good reasons,” said Fanny, “that are too involved to relate.”

“Is that so?” Ardis shifted a sweetly venomous stare from Fanny to Jay. “Even if there are, I’d look closer to home before leaping all the way to Los Angeles. As I have good reason to know. Even, next door or upstairs is not too close for Terry’s operations. Jay, have you asked Brian O’Hara if he knows where she is?”

Otis was pink and Jay was white and Farley was red, but Fanny was mostly interested.

“What the hell do you mean by ‘next door’?” Farley said.

“What I would like to know,” said Fanny, “is what she means by ‘Brian O’Hara.’ Jay, what does she mean?”

“Shut up, Fan!” Farley said. “For God’s sake, shut up!”

“Brian O’Hara,” Jay said stiffly, “is a local and lesser version of Arnold Rothstein. He is a gambler who specializes in collegiate athletic contests. He owns a couple of night spots geared for college students. He is reputed to be honest by his own liberal standards. I wouldn’t know.”

“Oh, I know who he is, of course,” Fanny said. “What I mean is, what does he have to do with Terry?”

“Ardis is trying to tell me,” Jay said, “that Terry and O’Hara have been seen together under suggestive circumstances. Thanks, Ardis, but I already knew.”

“Well, you may have known, but I didn’t,” said Fanny. “Did you know, Farley? Why didn’t you tell me?”

“I’m no damn scandal-monger, that’s why,” Farley said. “Besides, it’s incredible that you hadn’t found out. It’s a miracle.”

“It’s evident that I’ve said too much,” Ardis sniffed. “I was only trying to be helpful. Come along, Otis!”

She marched away, Otis trailing. Passing through the doorway, he cast a glance backward.

“Jay, thanks for the matches,” Otis said miserably.

“You’re welcome,” Jay said.

When they were gone, Farley rose and turned immediately to Fanny with grim decision, as if he were prepared to do violence if necessary.

“You, too, Fan. Stand up. Let’s leave Jay alone.”

“Surely.” Fanny stood up as ordered. “You are quite right for a change, Farley. I must say, too, that you were quite right in the hall upstairs last night. I am always inclined to see the good in a person instead of the bad, but that Ardis is a bitch.”

8

It has been said of patients in mental hospitals that one of the therapists’ most difficult problems is to get them to do anything. Although some kind of work is thought to be as important to the cure of mental disorders as aspirin to the alleviation of a headache, the patient displays a remarkably obdurate insistence on submitting to the tricks of his nervous system. Jay Miles was not a mental patient, but in this respect, at least, he felt and acted like one.

Left to his own devices, with many things to do that might have been done, he did nothing.

He merely thought about doing them.

He thought about getting his lectures in order for Monday’s classes; but economics, ordinarily a stimulant, seemed at the moment abysmally dull. He thought about preparing himself lunch, but he couldn’t think of anything available in the larder that appealed to his feeble appetite. He thought about having a drink; but drinking, if started, was something he might be tempted under the circumstances to continue, and he needed to keep a clear head with which to think of all the things to be done that he wasn’t doing. He thought about listening to music, which would really have required no effort; and he would have done this, if only it hadn’t been so far from his chair to the player.

It was even farther to the telephone.

What he ought to do, if anything, was to call Maurice Feldman in Los Angeles and inquire about Terry. Appearances demanded it. He was expected by his neighbors, especially that bothersome little Fanny, to make a display of anxiety he by no means felt; indeed, that he was no longer capable of feeling.

In the beginning he had been ardently in love with Terry. But ardor diminishes, and love dies, from chronic neglect and frequent betrayal. (Sometimes the love becomes hate, and then the ardor grows strong again.) It was too bad that things had developed with him and Terry as they had. But there it was, bad gone to worse, and it was far too late to do anything about it. It had been, in fact, too late from the first.

Jay consulted his watch and found that it lacked two minutes of being three o’clock. Allowing for the time difference, it was almost one in Los Angeles. It was, moreover, almost one of a Saturday afternoon. Barring urgent business Feldman would not be in his office; barring inclement weather, if Jay knew his man, Feldman would not be at home. A golf bug, he would almost certainly be on some course trying to break a hundred. The thing to do, Jay decided, was to place a call to Feldman’s home and leave word for the attorney to call him back when he got in. But what was Feldman’s home number? Jay remembered the area code, 213, but the number had slipped his mind. He thought, however, that Terry had written it in the back of the directory on the page provided for listing out-of-town numbers, and he got up with great effort to see, and there it was. He dialed the number and was given the information he expected. Feldman was not at home, but he was expected at five o’clock L.A time. The woman who answered the phone, a maid, assured Jay that she would relay his request that Mr. Feldman return the call. Jay cradled the phone with an exorbitant sense of accomplishment. There! The tiling was done, the gesture made. Now it was possible to resume doing nothing, or next to nothing, until seven o’clock.

Doing nothing, or next to nothing, for four hours is in itself a difficult job. One must, paradoxically, do something in order to accomplish it. Sleeping is as close to doing nothing as a man can get; and Jay, who had slept very little the previous night, went into the bedroom and took off his shoes and lay down on his back on the bed.

It was a precarious position, for it is peculiarly conducive to unpleasant reflections while awake, and to bad dreams when asleep. The trick, of course, was to think of something or someone besides Terry, but this was impossible because she was immediately everywhere at once in the room, even creeping beneath his eyelids when he closed them. He did not resist her presence, which would have been a mistake, and so he achieved a kind of passivity that in the end induced unconsciousness. He slept fitfully until he was awakened by the strident ringing of the telephone in the living room.

The apartment had grown dark while he slept, and he groped his way toward the ringing. As he expected, his greeting brought on the gravelly voice of Maurice Feldman.

“Jay? Feldman here. What’s on your mind?”

“Well, it seems that Terry has wandered off; and I was wondering if she’s shown up in L.A. Have you heard from her?”

“If she’s here, she hasn’t got in touch with me. How long has she been gone?”

“Since yesterday afternoon. When I got home from the university, she was gone.”

“Didn’t she tell anyone where she was going?”

“Apparently not. No one seems to know.”

“What makes you think she came out here? Did she take any clothes with her?”

“Just what she was wearing, so far as I can tell. That’s why I. thought she’d be in touch with you right away.”

“Well, if I hear from her, I’ll let you know immediately.”

“I’d appreciate it.”

“I rather suspect, however, that you’ll be hearing from her soon, if she doesn’t return. God knows what makes Terry so erratic. Keep me informed, will you, Jay?”

“Right. Sorry to have bothered you.”

“No bother. I’m glad you called. It’s probably too early to get excited, though, where Terry’s concerned. I suppose you’re accustomed to her habits by this time.”

“Thoroughly. How was your golf game today?”

“Golf? I didn’t play golf. I was tied up at the office.”

“Oh? If I’d known that, I’d have called you there.”

“I’m involved in a rather important court action at the moment. Demands my personal attention. If there’s nothing else on your mind, Jay, I’ve got to dress for dinner. We’re having guests.”

“Right, Maury. Thanks for calling back.”

He hung up and returned to the bedroom. After turning on the ceiling light, he sat on the edge of the bed and put on his shoes. He still wasn’t hungry, but it was a long time since his last meal, and he decided that he had better eat something. On the other hand, he didn’t feel like going to the trouble of preparing anything; besides, he had an urgent need to get out of the apartment. Wearing a topcoat but no hat, he left the building and walked over to a small restaurant near the campus that catered largely to students.

Consuming a bowl of soup and a cold roast-beef sandwich, Jay Miles began at last to face the issue he had heretofore avoided. He considered Brian O’Hara and what, if anything, should be done about him. He would have preferred to do nothing at all, but appearances clearly dictated a gesture in O’Hara’s direction. Terry’s relationship with O’Hara, however much or little it amounted to, incited no anger in Jay, only a soiled sense of shame that he could feel none. This had the effect of augmenting his bitterness toward Terry for stirring in him an emotion that was, at most, no more than incidental to the one he should have felt. Be he did not blame O’Hara for Terry’s initiative. Once he would have blamed O’Hara, but no longer. There had been too many O’Haras.

His attitude was hardly understandable by those who expected him to react “normally.” Ever since Ardis Bowers had made her point about Terry and O’Hara, Jay had realized that, if he wanted to keep the respect of those who were aware of the. circumstances, he would have to go through certain motions. To say nothing, perhaps, of allaying dangerous speculation. At any rate, he was faced with the disagreeable necessity, of seeing O’Hara, and of letting it be known afterward that he had done so.

This being so — acting on Macbeth’s principle in the killing of Duncan — he decided that now was better than later; and he paid his check and left the restaurant.

It was a long walk to the residential hotel in which O’Hara kept a suite. But it was a good night for walking, which also had the effect of delaying the disagreeable encounter. Jay went all the way afoot. It was almost nine o’clock when he reached the hotel, an impressive stack, of stone and steel whose marquee advertised The Rinaldo.

He had to ask at the desk for O’Hara’s suite number, and he was forced to wait while the clerk rang up to see if O’Hara was there in the first place, and if he would receive a caller in the second. Jay rather hoped that he wasn’t, or wouldn’t. But the hope was wasted both ways. O’Hara was and would. Suite 1502, top floor.

Jay went up in the elevator, which rose too fast.

He was admitted by O’Hara himself, alone in the living room of his suite. It was anyone’s guess, of course; as to who might have been in other rooms.

O’Hara, who was sometimes a ruffian in behavior, was far from one in appearance. As tall as Jay, he was wider and thicker in the shoulders, and even narrower in the waist. He held himself erect, but with an effect of being at ease, and he moved with grace. His eyes were cold pale blue. His hair, which was blond, was cropped. His voice, amiably modulated, was a lie.

“Come in, Miles,” he said. “It’s Doctor, isn’t it?”

“I don’t make a point of it. Mister’s good enough.”

“Let me take your coat.”

“No, thanks.”

“You could use a drink, couldn’t you?”

Jay could have, but he said he couldn’t.

“I can’t stay,” he said. “I’m looking for my wife.”

O’Hara permitted the slightest flicker of surprise to disturb his expression, but he had the good judgment not to put his reaction into words. Clearly he had no intention of either confirming or denying a relationship of which Jay apparently was aware. He had, in fact, a genuine aversion to the kind of angry attention, both public and private, that his activities naturally invited.

“Am I to understand that she’s missing?”

“That’s right.”

“What made you think you’d find her here?”

“Why not? If I’m not mistaken, she’s been here before.”

“Sorry. This is not my night for confessional. She’s your wife, for the present, and you can think what you like about her.”

“Thanks. That’s liberal of you, but why the time qualification?”

“We needn’t pretend with each other. Terry is a dissatisfied wife. You know as well as I that it’s only a matter of time till she leaves you. If you say she’s missing, maybe she already has.”

“Maybe. How do you know so much about it? Did she tell you?”

“All I’ll tell you is that she isn’t here. I haven’t seen her for a week.”

“I’d hardly expect you to say otherwise.”

O’Hara’s only physical reaction was a. narrowing of the lids over his eyes, but Jay was suddenly aware of cold menace.

“You’re wrong. If she were here, you could expect me to say so, and to hell with you. Would you like to look through the place?”

“No,” said Jay Miles.

“I’ll tell you this, too. We had a date for cocktails at one of my places yesterday afternoon. She didn’t show up. I assumed that something had developed to prevent her coming. For her sake, I hoped so. I don’t like being stood up.”

“Don’t you? Somehow, the idea doesn’t disturb me. You’ll understand my indifference, I’m sure.”

“I don’t give a damn how you feel about it.” O’Hara occupied himself for a few seconds with finding and lighting a cigarette. “I’ll tell you what I do give a damn about, though, since you’ve brought it to my attention. I give a damn about what’s become of Terry. How long has she been missing?”

“Since yesterday afternoon.”

“That long? And you have no idea where she can be?”

“I’ve had a couple of ideas. Both seem to have been wrong.”

“Maybe you know more about it than you’re admitting.”

“What the devil do you mean by that?”

“You have plenty of reason to work up a hate for Terry. It would be smart of you to kick up a fuss as a cover-up.”

“Don’t be a fool. It’s been all over between Terry and me for some time now”

“Then what’s the uproar about?”

“She’s still my wife, O’Hara.”

O’Hara smiled. “Are you getting tough with me?”

“Let’s not underestimate each other. A mistake either way could be costly.”

“Fair enough. And now, if you won’t have that drink, I have an appointment at one of my clubs. I’m already late.”

He went to the door and held it open. “I’ll make a point of looking into this,” he said. “Let’s hope we hear from Terry soon.”

Jay said nothing more.

He descended to the lobby in the fast elevator, from the lobby into the street. A cold wind had come up. He felt that he had survived an ordeal with as much dignity as the circumstances permitted.

Turning up his collar and lowering his head, Jay walked home against the wind.

9

Otis Bowers awoke with a sensation of rising slowly through brackish water to the surface of a stagnant pool. His teeth felt smeary and his face, with its growth of meager beard, dirty. It took him a moment, dreading the day, to remember that it was Sunday, a fact which by no means diminished his dread. He did not plan the traditional pause for worship and rest, having no conviction in the one and little hope of the other. Ardis, stirred by current events to an old animus, was hardly a restful mate. He could feel her beside him, hear her breathing. He knew without looking that her back was turned against him, a position she seemed able to maintain even in the tossing and turning of sleep.

Carefully Otis eased his legs over the side of the bed. This slight effort exhausted him, and he sat slumped for a few minutes, braced by his arms. Then he struggled to his feet and padded into the bathroom. Now, with a kind of sustained rush, he brushed his teeth, washed his face, lathered, and shaved. Returning to the bedroom, he saw with despair that Ardis was sitting up against the headboard of the bed.

“Good morning,” Otis said.

“Is the coffee making?” Ardis said.

“Not yet. I just woke up.”

“What time is it?”

He looked at the alarm clock, which she could have seen for herself by simply turning her head.

“Twenty minutes past nine.”

“I want my coffee.”

“I was just going to make it.”

He went out to the kitchen and put cold water into a Pyrex pot and leaned against the table until the water boiled. He removed the pot from the burner, measured in the instant coffee, and watched it while it steeped. This done, he poured two cupfuls and carried the cups to the bedroom. Thus far, he had been reasonably successful in not thinking about things he didn’t want to think about.

“Here you are,” he said.

She carried the cup immediately to her mouth, afterward closing her eyes and letting her head fall back against the headboard. Her face looked grayer and older than it was.

“I wonder if Terry’s back,” she said.

“I don’t know. I haven’t seen Jay since yesterday.”

“Aren’t you terribly concerned?”

“Don’t start that again. Please don’t.”

“Oh, excuse me.” Ardis raised her head and opened her eyes, disclosing the malice behind her lids. “I’d forgotten how sensitive you are on the subject of Terry. She made a fool of you with so little effort, didn’t she?”

“I suppose she did. You are welcome to think so, if you like. Can’t you forget it, Ardis? Can’t you let me forget it?”

“That would be nice for you, wouldn’t it? It’s not as easy as all that for me.”

“Can’t I make you understand that there never really was anything between Terry and me? Nothing ever happened. She was only playing a game with me. Terry’s got a cruel streak in her. She enjoys things like that. I’m not the type Terry would take seriously.”

“Why not? Aside from being a fool in your personal affairs, you’re a brilliant physicist. You have a wonderful career ahead of you. All you have to do is use common sense.”

“Terry doesn’t give a damn about physicists, brilliant or otherwise, and she didn’t give a damn about me.”

“Are you saying that what’s good enough for me isn’t good enough for your precious Terry?”

Fool or not, Otis could see the folly of going any further in that direction. It was futile, in fact, to go anywhere in any direction. His offense had not been infidelity, but a fatuous gullibility that in her view reflected on his legal bedmate. He would have been in less trouble, actually, if he had done as well in adultery as in physics. He had not, however. He had been involved in a fiasco, not a conquest; and he admitted that he deserved Ardis’s scorn, although he yearned for surcease.

“Nothing of the sort,” Otis said. “I’m just saying that Terry has a beastly set of values. Look at the way she treats Jay. She really has no regard for him, although he’s a very competent economist. It’s a mystery to me why she ever married him. She’s much more taken with animals like Brian O’Hara.”

Ardis sipped her coffee, staring at him slyly over the run of the cup.

“‘O.’ for O’Hara?” she said.

“Must you be so devious, Ardis?” He sat down on the side of the bed, clutching his cup and saucer in his left hand. “I simply don’t know what you’re talking about.”

“I’m talking about the Personal ad that appeared in Thursday evening’s Journal.”

“What Personal ad?”

“It was addressed to ‘T.M.’, and it was signed ‘O.’ It arranged a meeting for a certain time and place.”

“What time and place?”

“Three o’clock Friday afternoon. Apparently at the university library.”

Otis stared into his cup. Then he shrugged and looked up.

“It’s absurd. In Terry’s case, what’s more, completely unnecessary. In spite of the initials, I don’t believe it was meant for her at all.”

“That settles the matter very neatly, doesn’t it? Case closed, eh?”

“Didn’t you expect me to deny that it was ‘O.’ for Otis? Very well, I deny it. All right, I’ve been a fool, but not so big a fool as to engage in any damn foolishness like this. Why should I? I could have spoken directly to Terry whenever I chose.”

“So, for that matter, could O’Hara.”

“That’s the point. The Personal wasn’t meant for Terry at all.”

“You can dismiss such coincidence if you care to. I’m not prepared to do so.”

He stared at her with a thoughtful expression, as if his mind, having dismissed one consideration, had gone off on another tangent.

“How do you happen to know about the Personal? I can’t recall anyone’s mentioning it.”

“I read it when it appeared.”

“I didn’t know you read the Personal columns.”

“This time I did.”

“Interesting. And you thought of me the first thing, didn’t you?”

“Not without cause.”

“There’s nothing quite so exhilarating as a wifely faith. I’m wondering what, suspecting me of a clandestine meeting in advance, you would be capable of doing to prevent it.”

“Nothing. I doubt that you’re worth it.”

“Wouldn’t you even spy a little? Just out of curiosity?”

“Not when I had a migraine headache. Friday afternoon, you’ll remember, I had one.”

“I know you said so.”

“And so I had. I came home early and took a sleeping pill. I was here in the apartment all afternoon.”

“At the scene, so to speak.” He laughed without humor and rose abruptly. “Are you actually offering explanations, Ardis? It’s not like you.”

They looked at each other with the closest thing to understanding that they had achieved for a long time.

“More coffee?” he said.

“Yes.” She held out her cup. “Please.”

10

Later that same Sunday morning — the second day after the disappearance of Terry Miles — two boys were discussing seriously a problem of importance. They were in a sparsely settled neighborhood on the eastern edge of a city that was growing westward. No new construction had gone on there for a long time. The houses, all of aging vintage, were for the most part separated by one or more vacant lots; there was plenty of open space for the antics of boys. A short distance eastward the plumbing ended and the open country began. There were no suburbs here. The planners, speculators, and builders of the city of Handclasp concentrated their interests and investments on the other side of town.

The two boys, crossing a vacant lot, had stopped to settle their problem between them, the problem being what to do. They had lately escaped the horror of Sunday school; now, after changing into appropriate clothes, they were determined to salvage what was left of the day. Being of the age that both remembers toys and has premonitions of girls, they earnestly sought an adventure that would include the excitement of the one and the apprehension of the other. As they examined and discarded a number of possibilities, their breath escaped between them in frosty clouds. They were bundled against the cold morning in heavy jackets. Whatever they were called by their peers, they were soon to enter certain official records as Charles and Vernon — names which do not have, among small boys, a greatly used sound.

“I’ll tell you what,” said Charles.

“What?” said Vernon.

“Let’s go explore the old Skully place.”

“We can’t do that. People live in it.”

“Not now, they don’t. Nobody’s lived in it for over a month.”

“Somebody will, though. Some real estate company downtown rents it.”

“What difference does that make? Nobody’s living in it right now. That’s what counts.”

“What do you want to explore the old Skully place for?”

“Wait’ll I tell you what I saw there the other night.”

“What?”

“I saw a light in an upstairs window.”

“You’re just making that up.”

“I am not. It was a little light, like a flashlight. It kept moving around.”

“What night was it? What time did you see it? Come on, make it good.”

“It was Friday night. Real late. It must’ve been one o’clock, maybe more.”

“What were you doing at the old Skully place that late?”

“I was coming home in the car with Mother and Dad. We’d been downtown to a late movie. I just happened to look up and saw the light in the window as we went past. I told Dad about it, but he said I was imagining things.”

“You were.”

“I wasn’t. I bet you I wasn’t.”

Faced with such conviction Vernon, the skeptic, began to waver.

“Who do you think it was?” he asked in an awed tone.

“How should I know? I’ll bet he didn’t have any business being there, though. Are you game to have a look?”

His courage challenged, Vernon agreed, beginning to share Charles’s excitement. Even if they didn’t actually come across anything, the old and empty house would inflame the imagination to any boy’s satisfaction. As they traveled the long two blocks to the house, they convinced each other that they were performing a necessary — and dangerous — service to the community.

The Skully house, named for its orignal owner — a widower who had died there harassed by the unfounded suspicions of other imaginative youngsters like the pair now approaching through unkempt grass from the rear — was two stories tall, but so narrow in construction that it seemed taller. It had a high screened back porch; small windows in the foundation indicated the presence of a basement. Although old and ugly, it was kept in repair by the real estate agency that owned and rented it.

The two young trespassers, after crossing the back porch and finding the rear door locked, retreated and found a basement window that wasn’t. Charles first and Vernon behind him, they scrambled through and dropped.

The basement reeked of mustiness and junk and dust and rats and spiders. There was a coal bin, and a storage room for home-canned fruits and vegetables, its shelves still holding a supply of dusty Mason jars and a litter of rusted lids. Near the ancient furnace stood a workbench with a vise attached; a flight of ladder-like steps ascended to the kitchen door. Charles and Vernon, still in that order, climbed the steps and tried the door. It was unlocked, and they entered and crossed the kitchen, unconsciously walking — for no reason except the cold menace of the silent house — on tiptoes.

The first floor revealed no ghastly secrets; nor did their intrusion invoke old Skully’s ghost, which was said to loiter about the place. Relieved and disappointed, they went up a narrow stairway to the upper floor, now side by side for company. There were two doors on each side of a hall, and a fifth at the end. They walked straight back to the end door and found that it opened into a bathroom; the high old-fashioned tub had feet shaped like eagle claws clutching round balls. Reversing themselves, they began to open the other doors on empty rooms. Not speaking for fear of affronting the silence, they communicated with each other through a system of gestures and grimaces.

Now Charles conveyed to Vernon the information that the last room, deliberately withheld for the purpose of climax, was the one in which he had seen the mysterious moving light.

Crossing to this door, he pushed it inward....

11

“Sundays,” said Farley, “last forever.”

“They only seem that way to you,” said his sister Fanny, “because they give you an uneasy conscience.”

“Are you speaking from experience?”

“My conscience never bothers me.”

“Maybe that’s because you don’t have one. Let it go, however. It so happens that I am living quite comfortably with my conscience at the moment. Why shouldn’t I be?”

“That’s for you to say.”

“Tell me, little sister, why should my conscience kick up on Sundays in particular? Rather, that is, than on Mondays or Tuesdays or any other day of the week?”

“It seems to me difficult to rest easy on a day of rest when one never does anything else, whatever the day is. As for me, I work hard earning my living, and therefore I have nothing to reproach myself with.”

“Well, what the hell would you call studying law? I’d call it work, that’s what I’d call it! And damn hard work, too, between you and me.”

“It all depends on who’s doing it, and how much is being done. You want me to be honest, don’t you? I haven’t seen you crack a book all weekend.”

“Thanks to you, I’ve been compelled to do other things.”

Sprawled on the sofa in Fanny’s apartment, Farley eyed her sourly. If it had not been contrary to his best interests, he would have said something insulting and stalked out. His best interests could best be served, however, by hanging on, even if it mean submitting to harassment. In short, he had eaten very little for almost two days, and he was badly in need of nourishment. He had realized this about four o’clock, ten minutes ago, and he had simultaneously remembered that Fanny, if she had Sunday dinner in, usually had it around five. So Farley had come up to see if anything edible was under way, and luckily something was — a piece of beef tenderloin in the oven that was adequate for two. But Fanny had as yet extended no invitation to stay. Worse, she was looking at him in a manner that did nothing to feed his hopes.

“That reminds me,” she said. “I’ve been wanting to ask if you called the taxi companies, as I told you to.”

“I considered not doing it, but I knew you’d devil the devil out of me if I didn’t. So I did.”

“What did you find out?”

“Just what I expected. Nothing. There’s no record of anyone’s picking up a passenger here, or near here, any time close to the time Terry left.”

“Are you sure you inquired, or are you just saying so?”

“Of course I’m sure. Do you think I’d lie about it?”

“Yes, I do.”

“Well, I’m not going to take an oath on it. Believe me or not as you please.”

She was distracted from whatever response was on her tongue by a knocking on the door, and she went over and opened it to reveal Jay Miles. He was wearing his topcoat and was obviously either just going out or just coming back from having been out. The two wedges of flesh below his eyes, behind the thick glasses, were dark smudges.

“Hello, Fanny.” He peered over her shoulder at Farley. “Oh, there you are, Farley. I thought you might be up here.”

“I came up to have dinner with Fanny,” Farley said, “but she hasn’t asked me yet.”

“Fat chance,” said Fanny. “Come in, Jay. Whither away, or where from?”

“I’m just going.” Jay stepped inside far enough to allow Fanny to close the door. “As a matter of fact, that’s why I was looking for you, Farley. I thought maybe you might go with me.”

“That’s a good idea!” Fanny said. “Farley, get yourself cleaned up and go with Jay. While you’re out you can have dinner together somewhere.”

“Not I,” Farley said. “I don’t want to go.”

“How do you know you don’t? You don’t even know yet where he’s going.”

“Wherever it is, I don’t want to go.”

“Don’t be contrary. Where are you going, Jay?”

“To the police. I’ve finally made up my mind.”

Farley sat up at Jay’s quiet declaration. Fanny backed her eat little stern onto the arm of a chair and studied Jay as if she were trying to make up her own mind about something. Oddly, although she had been urging action, she did not seem enthusiastic about Jay’s proposed visit to the police.

“I don’t know about that,” she said. “Have you made certain that she didn’t run off to Los Angeles?”

“Yes. I called Feldman yesterday afternoon. He hasn’t seen or heard from her.”

“I hate to be bitchy, but another suggestion was made.”

“Brian O’Hara? I went to see O’Hara after talking with Feldman. Last night. Terry wasn’t at his place and hadn’t been there.”

“Do you think for an instant he’d admit it if she had been?”

“I’m convinced O’Hara was telling the truth.”

“Perhaps so, but it doesn’t do to be impetuous in, an affair of this sort. There’s such a thing as going off halfcocked, you know.”

“Well, I’ll be damned!” Farley was staring at Fanny in amazement. “You have been running all over the place doing things and forcing others to do things, and now all of a sudden you start dragging your heels. What’s the matter with you?”

“Nothing’s the matter. We have delayed going to the police this long, and it will do no great harm to delay a little longer, that’s all. Ben can be expected back soon, if his word can be relied upon, and he may know something that will be helpful.”

“Ben?” Jay sounded confused. “Oh, I don’t think so. What in the world could Ben know about it?”

“You never know,” Fanny snapped. “He’s a deceptive little bugger.”

“She persists in suspecting Ben of dark, doleful deeds,” Farley said. “She’s absolutely irrational about it.”

“That’s not true! I am only trying to keep an open mind.”

“It doesn’t make any difference one way or the other,” Jay said. “I’ve made up my mind, and I’m going. I’m a great deal more worried than I was at first.”

“Oh, all right. I can see there’s no use trying to stop you. However, I see no advantage in going immediately. You might just as well wait until tomorrow.”

“I don’t see why.”

“Because today’s Sunday, that’s why.”

“What does its being Sunday have to do with it?”

“Things are closed on Sunday. Everyone knows that.”

“Police headquarters? Don’t be absurd, Fanny.”

“At least they’ll be operating with a skeleton crew. It will probably be impossible—”

“Fanny,” said Farley, “you’ve gone too far. Even you have better sense than to believe that. You’re up to something, and I want to know what it is.”

“What you want is of no consequence. I am the only one who has been attaching proper importance to all this, and I don’t propose to be criticized now for a difference of opinion.” Fanny, having disposed of Farley, turned her attention to Jay. “Jay, are you actually determined to go?”

“Yes.”

“In that case, Farley will go with you.”

“Who says so?” Farley said.

“I say so. I can tell you right now that you’ll gain nothing by hanging around here, for you aren’t getting any of my dinner. Not a bite.”

“Come along with me, Farley,” Jay said. “I’d appreciate it if you would.”

“What for?”

“Call it moral support. We probably won’t be there long. When we’re through, I’ll buy you dinner.”

“Since you put it that way,” Farley said, rising with a show of interest, “I’ll come.”

He went out in Jay’s wake; and Fanny, still hooked on the arm of the chair, began to consider the new development. She was not opposed in principle to bringing in the police, for she had been convinced for some time that it was the only sensible thing to do. But her uneasiness about Ben and his possible connection with Terry Miles’s disappearance had increased with speculation; she was not, where Ben was concerned, nearly so sensible as in the case of others. It would be a great relief if only he would get back and explain things, damn him. In the meanwhile, time would pass more quickly if it were filled with events.

Fan went into the kitchen and looked into the oven. The tenderloin had acquired a nice crust and would soon be done. She mixed batter for potato pancakes, using a prepared mix and letting the batter stand for ten minutes, according to the directions on the box. This interval Fan utilized in stirring up a couple of martinis. One she drank in what was left of the ten minutes, the other she saved to drink just before eating.

Having eaten, she cleaned up and went back into the living room and turned on the table lamp. Night had come early, as nights did in November; it seemed much later than it probably was. It was actually six-thirty; and it was unlikely that Jay and Farley, who had left approximately two hours ago, had had time to go to police headquarters, stop somewhere for dinner, and return. It was even less likely, when they did return, that they would come up and report to her as, in all decency, they should. They would go to Jay’s apartment, or to Farley’s or each to his own; and she, Fanny, would be left in exasperating ignorance for the whole night. This was not to be borne, of course. She decided to wait in Farley’s apartment, assuming that Farley had left the door unlocked. (She could hardly take the liberty of waiting in Jay’s without his permission, but Farley’s was something else.)

Taking cigarettes and matches with her, she went downstairs, tried Farley’s door, and found it unlocked. Farley was notoriously careless about doors, one of his few habits that could sometimes be useful. His living room was dark, but the darkness was cut by a swath of light from the bedroom, Fanny crossed the room, peeped cautiously in — and there, lying on the bed, on his back, his shoes off and his arms folded under his head, was Ben Green.

Fan stepped into full view.

“Hello, Fan,” Ben Green said in his melodious baritone. “Come in and lie down.”

“Like hell,” Fanny said.

His grin expanded. “I naturally assumed that you had slipped in for a bit of sport.”

“Your error.”

“Which brings us to the point. What are you doing here?”

“More to the point, where have you been?”

“That’s no secret. I’ve been away.”

“Where away?”

“Out of town.”

“With whom?”

“Do you think I’d tell you? However, I was lone-wolfing it.”

“Where’s Terry?”

“Terry? Is she gone?”

“Yes. So have you been. Doesn’t that seem a coincidence?”

“You’re on the wrong track, honeyball. I’m saving myself for you.”

“Well, you can be as clever and secretive as you choose. But you had better think up a convincing lie if you don’t care to tell the truth.”

Impressed by her gravity, Ben sat up on the edge of the bed, prepared as a tentative measure to take her seriously. Now that he had assumed a position less conducive to the free exercise of his libido, Fan ventured to come closer. She even sat down beside him. He helped himself to her near hand, examined it, patted it, and continued to hold it.

“Something’s up,” he said. “Tell old Ben.”

“I told you. Terry’s gone. No one knows where she is.”

“So what? Terry has always been given to a moderate amount of moonlighting. She’ll be back after a while, breathing sighs and telling lies.”

“If she’s coming back, she’s taking her own sweet time about it. She disappeared shortly after you left on Friday afternoon.”

“So that’s it. Old Ben wanders away, and Terry goes up in smoke. Natural conclusion: assignation. Sweet nitwit, it won’t wash. I don’t even come close to fitting Terry’s prescription. Wrong ingredients entirely. I’m too poor, too runty, too ugly. And incidentally, if I may say so, too smart.”

“How about Otis? What kind of prescription did he fit?”

“Otis was a joke. Otis was a comedian. All he gave was laughs, and what he got was nothing. Everybody knew the score except Otis. That’s the trouble with these scientific types. They leave their brains in the laboratory. They’d be better off if they were born without glands.”

“Well, you mustn’t call yourself unpleasant names. I won’t have it. No one can deny that you are poor, but you are not runty and ugly.”

“As another runt, you’re prejudiced. Not that you’re ugly, I hasten to add. On the contrary, you’re lovely and sexy. Would you like to recline?”

“What I would like and what I would do are two different things. Behave yourself, Ben. In my opinion, you are just as brainy and glandular as Otis ever was.”

“True. My brains, however, are Machiavellian.”

“Damn it, Ben, you have a positive talent for leading me off the point. The point is, Terry’s been gone since Friday, everyone’s worried, and what are you going to do about it?”

“I?” His eyes widened, then narrowed. “Me? Nothing. Why should I? What could I?”

“You could explain where you’ve been, to start with. Besides, what do you mean by running off without a word to me about it? You know very well I’ve decided to marry you as soon as you get your doctorate and show signs of amounting to something. I won’t have you running all over the place without restraint. Tell me at once where you have been.”

“I respectfully decline to answer on the grounds that anything I say you’ll use to incriminate me.”

“You mean you won’t tell me?”

“That’s it.”

“Very well. It’s plain that I can’t help you if you won’t let me. You can explain to the police.”

“The police!” His voice had sharpened, and his grip tightened on her hand. “What do the police have to do with it?”

“Jay and Farley have gone down to headquarters to report Terry missing, and some sort of investigation is bound to be made.”

“Why did they want to do such an idiotic thing? Well, I have nothing to say to the police. They can damn well let me alone.”

“They can, but it is doubtful that they will. We will all have to answer their questions.”

“Don’t worry, Fan. I can take care of myself.”

They sat side by side on the bed. Ben’s grip had relaxed, and her hand was comfortably, in his, at home. She felt alarmingly warm and susceptible, and she had a strong notion that it would be wiser and safer, if less interesting, to devise a distraction. After all, if she was beginning to think along certain lines, it was more than likely that he was already ahead of her.

“Have you had dinner?” she said. “I have some tenderloin left. Would you like some?”

“No, thanks. I’m not hungry.”

They continued to sit, undistracted.

Damn it, she thought, what has become of Jay and Farley? What could be keeping them?

12

Trouble was keeping them.

Jay had had little or no experience with police stations, and he was not sure of the protocol in the present case. There was, however, a man in uniform on duty behind a high counter, and it was apparent that he was expected to appeal here if he hoped to proceed at all. He had an idea that there must be a Bureau of Missing Persons somewhere that specialized in finding folk who were lost, strayed, or stolen; the most that would be done at present, he suspected, was the recording of a few statistics, vital and otherwise, and the phony reassurance of some cynical bureaucrat who would assume at once that Terry, of the three alternatives, was a stray of the voluntary type.

“Good evening,” said the uniformed man across the high counter. “May I help you?”

This was certainly a favorable beginning, courteous if not deferential, and Jay was, sure enough, reassured.

“I want to report a missing person,” he said.

“Name?”

“Jay Miles. This is Farley Moran, a neighbor.”

“Where do you live?”

“I live at The Cornish Arms — I’m a professor at Handclasp University. You must have misunderstood me, though. I’m not missing. It’s my wife.”

The policeman permitted himself a slight smile. “And what is your wife’s name?”

“Terry. Miles, of course.”

“How long has she been missing?”

“About forty-eight hours. Since Friday afternoon.”

The policeman had been making notes on a pad. Now he threw the pencil aside and tore the top page from the pad. “Wait here a minute....”

He left the door open behind him, and Jay and Farley could see him retreating down a hall. A few minutes later he reappeared and beckoned.

“In here. Captain Bartholdi will talk to you.”

Jay was surprised; he had hardly expected, on the strength of a mere report, to draw the attention of a captain. He was no less surprised by the appearance of the man who had risen from behind the desk. Captain Bartholdi was slim, gray, handsome, urbane, and Gallic. He looked as if he would have been far more at home with an épée than a police positive.

“Sit down, gentlemen.” Captain Bartholdi indicated chairs. “Which one is Mr. Miles?”

“Jay Miles,” said Jay.

“Farley Moran,” said Farley.

Bartholdi nodded to Farley, but he directed his attention to Jay. That is, he looked at Jay, and spoke to him. But he seemed abstracted. His gray eyes had a distant expression, as if he were hearing a faint snatch of music or listening to a faraway voice.

“I understand your wife has disappeared, Professor Miles?”

“That’s right.”

“She has been gone for two days?”

“Yes. Since Friday afternoon.”

“Have you any reason to believe that the police should be interested?”

“I don’t know. That’s what I want the police to find out.”

“May I ask you why you’ve waited two days before coming to us?”

“This isn’t the first time my wife has gone off unexpectedly. I kept thinking that she would be back.”

Captain Bartholdi said, “I see,” as if he really did. “But now you’ve become anxious. Is that it?”

“Yes.”

“Do you have any knowledge at all of where your wife might have gone? Did she leave home with a specific destination? Did she have an appointment with someone, for example?”

“She said something about an appointment, but I don’t believe she said whom it was with. Mr. Moran can tell you about that.”

Farley, thus cued, opened his mouth to speak. He was prevented by an arresting gesture from Bartholdi. The captain pushed his swivel chair back.

“Later, Mr. Moran. Right now, would you mind coming with me?”

“Where?” Jay, rising, had a paradoxical sensation of sinking. “Why?”

“Just follow me, please.”

He came around the desk and went out of the room. Following, followed in turn by Farley, Jay was aware of the grace of Bartholdi’s movements. (His feet, like his hands, were small and slender.) They went down the hall to the elevator. Captain Bartholdi punched a button with a delicate thumb, and the car descended. They came out in a basement corridor. It was chilly here; lights burned with a tinted pallor, as if the naked electric bulbs had been blued by the chill. Jay knew with dreadful certainty where they were bound, and what, when they got there, he would have to see. Bartholdi had paused in the corridor and was watching him.

“Professor Miles,” he began.

“It’s Terry, isn’t it? She’s dead, isn’t she?”

Jay’s voice was washed of life and luster. Bartholdi answered as if he were dictating mortuary statistics for the record.

“It’s a body. There was no identification on it. You can tell me if it’s your wife.”

They went into the morgue, and saw, and it was. It was Terry, or what was left of her. In spite of the anguish and terror of violent death, she seemed at peace in this bleak depository. Perhaps it was only that she was empty. Her throat was clawed by her own nails, where she had dug futilely at whatever had strangled her; it was a miracle that any loveliness had survived. She had clearly been dead for some time. Jay’s mind caught and clung to an ugly thought.

Thank God, the weather has been cold.

“Yes,” he said. “That’s Terry.”

He spoke with a brittle brusqueness, as if impatient with the unpleasant task that fate had imposed upon him and wishing to be done with it. Bartholdi, watching him closely, recognized the last thin defense against hysteria. He took Jay by the arm and steered him away, jerking his head toward the door as his glance slid across the white mask of Farley’s face beyond Jay’s shoulder. In the hall, the three men stopped. A long sigh, like an escape valve, came from Jay.

“Are you all right, Professor Miles?” Captain Bartholdi asked.

“Where did you find her?”

“We’d better go back to my office.”

“Poor Terry. Poor Terry.”

“I’m sorry this was necessary.”

They took the elevator back to Bartholdi’s office. Jay had a peculiar gassy sensation, as though he were in danger of violating the law of gravity with every step; he kept lifting his feet, one after the other, with exorbitant care. He felt a great relief at reaching the security of a chair. He suddenly became aware that in the chair beside him sat Farley. He had forgotten Farley. He had no such positive feeling about Bartholdi, across the desk. Although the captain seemed kind and sympathetic, he was an unpleasant factor, brimming with painful questions demanding answers.

“Would you like a glass of water?” Bartholdi asked.

“No, thanks.”

“A cigarette?”

Bartholdi passed them, and Jay and Farley accepted. The business of supplying lights accomplished, Bartholdi leaned back-behind a stratum of smoke. “Late this morning, shortly before noon, we received a call from a man who lives on the east edge of town, on Wildwood Road. This man has a son, a kid named Charles. It seems that Charles and a friend named Vernon decided on Sunday to investigate an empty old house in the neighborhood. Known as the Skully place. It seems this kid Charles was curious because he claims he saw a mysterious light moving in an upstairs window last Friday night. Or early Saturday morning, to be exact. The two boys got into the house through a basement window. Upstairs, in the same room where Charles claims to have seen the light, they found the body of your wife, Professor Miles. It. scared the daylights out of them, of course, and they ran home to spill everything to Charles’s father, who called us in, as I said. A couple of patrolmen were sent out to investigate, and there was the body, just as the kids reported.”

Bartholdi’s eyes had gone dreamy again. Again he seemed to be listening for something, hearing something, a distant accompaniment to his own voice.

“That’s where I came in,” he went on after a moment. “I was out there within half an hour. Here, subject to revision, are the conclusions I’ve drawn: The victim was killed some time ago. In the light of what you’ve told me, I’d say it was probably Friday night, not too long after she disappeared. She had not been attacked, and so rape would appear to be out. She was, moreover, fully clothed. She was strangled either with a stout cord or a length of some kind of strong material, possibly a stocking or a necktie.”

“But why there?” Jay’s voice had a harsh, breathless sound, as if he himself were being strangled by invisible hands. “What was she doing in an unoccupied house? Surely she didn’t go to such a place to meet someone.”

“Not likely.” Bartholdi paused, looking beyond Jay at a point on the far wall. “She was taken there either before or after she was killed. I think it’s possible this was a kidnapping that got fouled up.”

“Kidnapping!”

“It’s still just a theory. Kidnapping victims must be rich to be profitable. Are you a wealthy man, Mr. Miles?”

Jay shook his head. “I live on my salary. But my wife’s father left her a small fortune.”

“Oh?” Bartholdi leaned forward. “Did you get a ransom note?”

“No.”

“It might still come in...” Bartholdi mused. “Yes,” he said slowly, “this might be a kidnap case, at that. It’s suggestive that the body was left in a place where, except for the nosiness of a couple of kids, it might have remained undiscovered for months. That would give a kidnapper plenty of time to negotiate for ransom.

“It might interest you to learn,” he went on, “that just on the chance I’ve taken certain precautions to keep a kidnapper, if there is one, from finding out that we know his victim is dead. I’ve threatened the two boys and their parents into silence, and I’ve given orders to every officer associated with the case. The news of this murder will be suppressed, if at all possible, for at least twenty-four hours. Not that I’m very hopeful. It’s likely that a kidnapper would have had the Skully house under observation. If so, he knows we’ve found the body.”

Jay was shaking his head. “I’m not sure about this kidnapping thing. My wife wasn’t in control of her money. She wouldn’t have been for another year. She’s been drawing a modest allowance from the interest on the estate.”

“Who administers the estate?”

“A lawyer in Los Angeles. His name is Maurice Feldman.”

“Wouldn’t he have paid a ransom from the estate if it meant saving your wife’s life?”

“Of course. There’s no question about that. But the kidnapper would have had to be aware of the circumstances, which I find questionable. Terry and I never mentioned her inheritance. I’m sure that not a soul in Handclasp knew a thing about it.”

“How can you be so sure? Women are not very good at keeping secrets. Did you, for instance, Mr. Moran, ever hear Mrs. Miles mention her inheritance?”

“Never,” said Farley.

“You’re positive?”

“Certainly. Jay told me about it yesterday, after Terry had gone. That’s the first I heard of it.”

“By the way, Mr. Moran, I believe you were going to tell me about an appointment Mrs. Miles may have had.”

“There isn’t much to tell, really. Terry dropped in to our apartment Friday afternoon, and while she was there she said she had an appointment at three o’clock. That’s all.”

“She didn’t mention a name? A destination?”

“No. As I recall, she made quite a point of not mentioning any.”

“So? That’s interesting. You said ‘our’ apartment, Mr. Moran?”

“Ben’s and mine. Ben Green. He’s working on a doctorate at the university. I’m in law school.”

“Why did Terry come to your apartment? Any particular reason?”

“She wanted to borrow three carrots.”

“Carrots?” Bartholdi’s eyebrows shot up. “Did you say carrots?”

“That’s right. For a ragout. She was going to put the ragout on to cook while she was out. That way, it would be ready when Jay got home in the evening.”

Bartholdi’s eyes slanted toward Jay. “And was it ready, Mr. Miles?”

“Yes. It was simmering in the electric skillet.”

“A man must find it satisfying to come home to a hot meal. I’m a bachelor who doesn’t, and I know.” After this irrelevant remark, Bartholdi returned his attention to Farley. “How long did Mrs. Miles stay in your apartment?”

“Not long. She left shortly after Ben did.”

“Where did Ben — Green, did you say? — go?”

“I wouldn’t know. Old Ben was mysterious about it. Not the first time, either. I have a notion he goes off for a little extra-curricular fun, if you know what I mean.”

“I think I do. When did he get back?”

“He didn’t. At least, he hadn’t when Jay and I left to come here. He said he’d be back some time this evening.”

“Interesting.”

“Oh, if you think there was any connection between Ben and Terry, you’re way off base. I’m sure there wasn’t.”

“Chances are, of course, that you’re right,” said Bartholdi easily. “A lively imagination is one of my worst faults. Just the same, we’ll have to prevail upon Mr. Green to let us in on his activities this weekend.”

“It would be more helpful to know who placed the Personal.”

“Personal? What Personal?”

“There was one in Thursday evening’s Journal. It was addressed to ‘T.M.’ and was signed ‘O.’ It arranged a meeting for three o’clock Friday afternoon. From certain terms used, we deduced that the place of meeting was the University library.”

If Bartholdi’s imagination was at work again, there was no evidence of it in his eyes. They were more dream-filled than ever as he turned them slowly upon Jay.

“When did you first know about this Personal?” he asked Jay.

“Friday night,” Jay said. “Farley and I had just finished eating the ragout, as I recall, and Farley and Fanny were looking around to see if they could find a note of the appointment Terry had presumably gone to keep. It was you who actually found the Personal, wasn’t it, Farley?”

“It was, come to think of it,” said Farley. “Fanny was looking through some magazines for a marginal note or something. I just happened to pick up the Journal, and there was the Personal.”

“Who,” said Bartholdi, still watching Jay, “is Fanny?”

“Fanny Moran,” Jay said. “Farley’s half-sister.”

“She lives upstairs,” Farley said.

“And how did it happen, Mr. Moran, just for the record,” said Bartholdi, “that you were with Professor Miles in his apartment at the time?”

“I had been invited by Terry to come over at six and share the ragout. Fanny just got into it somehow. Fanny’s always getting into things.”

“Well, the Personal is something to start with, anyhow.” Bartholdi sighed and rose. “This has been an ordeal for you, I know,” he said to Jay. “I wish I could send you home, but first I want to take you out where the body was found.”

“Why? So you can watch my reactions?”

“Sarcasm, Professor Miles? It’s not necessary.”

Jay got to his feet with an effort, feeling all the while as if he could not possibly make another. “Isn’t the husband always the prime suspect? I’m beginning to have the feeling that we’ll be seeing a lot of each other, Captain. Why don’t you start calling me Jay?”

13

The old house seemed to have withdrawn into depth and darkness to guard half a century of secrets. The long walk leading from the street was rough underfoot, the cracks between its broken bricks still sprouting the dead moss and grass left over from the summer. Captain Bartholdi, who had preceded Jay and Farley through the thin traffic from downtown, now preceded them from street to house. He went up across the high front porch and knocked on the front door, which seemed an absurdity to Jay until he realized that the place was now, of course, occupied by the police. The door swung open with a classic creak, and the three passed in, Bartholdi still in front.

“Well, Brady,” he said, “how’s everything?”

“Cold,” said Brady, a bulky shadow barely discernible. “I’d give a leg for a quart of hot coffee.”

“You’ll be relieved at midnight. No one’s been around, I suppose?”

“Not a soul, dead or alive. I won’t say I haven’t thought about ghosts.”

“These gentlemen are. Professor Miles and Mr. Moran. We’ll just have a quick look upstairs.”

“Right. Watch your step on the stairs. The carpet’s worn through in a couple of places.”

Bartholdi switched on a flashlight. He held it pointed at the floor. Jay followed, Farley followed Jay, and the three men climbed single file to the second floor, where Bartholdi opened the first door on his right. Jay, beside him, could have sworn that a breath of colder air issued from the room but he knew this was only the trickery of an inflamed imagination in an exhausted mind.

“This is the room,” Bartholdi said, “where the kids found her.”

He played the light on floor and walls. On the floor lay nothing but a thin layer of dust, tracked now and disturbed in a far corner — where Bartholdi held the light steady for a minute — by a once-recumbent body. On the walls, only paper with a-design of faded roses, just slightly brighter in one small rectangular place where a picture had hung.

Bartholdi shut the door. The trio huddled in the hall, standing in the puddle of Bartholdi’s light.

“You see, Jay?” Bartholdi assumed the familiarity, to which he had been invited, without effort. “No tricks. No psychology.”

“Can you tell me, then, what has been gained by bringing me here?”

“Have you ever seen this house before?”

“I have no recollection of it.”

“Had your wife?”

“I wouldn’t know, but I should think it very unlikely.”

“She never mentioned any place that might seem, now that you are here, to have been a reference to this house?”

“No, not to me.”

They stood in silence, their feet unmoving in the bright puddle, a frail and tiny circumference established against the darkness. The cold numbed their flesh. Jay’s voice, when he spoke at last, was intense and harsh, almost guttural.

“Who could have done it? Who?”

“That remains to be seen. But we’ll find out.”

“But why kill her? If she was kidnapped, wouldn’t it have been better to let her live, at least until the ransom was collected?”

“It depends on the point of view. A dead victim can’t identify anybody.”

“Whoever did it, you’ve got to find him!”

“We will. The Personal is something to go on. I have another lead, too, and I’m hoping both may get us to the same person. This house has been rented.”

“Who rented it?”

“It was rented two weeks ago by a man who gave the name of Ivan Harper. He paid a month’s advance rent in cash. He hasn’t, so far as I can learn, been seen since. Not by the people at the agency or any of the neighbors. The gas and electricity have not been turned on, no telephone has been installed. It’s a safe bet that Harper, whatever his name really is, is our man. He rented this house solely for the purpose for which he used it. I haven’t been able to see the agent who personally rented the house, but I’ll get him in the morning at the agency.”

“He should be able to give a description. He can surely recognize this man if he sees him again.”

“Oh, he’ll give a description, all right, probably inaccurate. He saw the man only once, two weeks ago, and you have to assume that anyone who risked this caper would have taken the elementary precaution of disguise.”

Farley suddenly made a noise that was half sigh, half groan. His feet backed out of the puddle, and his arms made slapping sounds against his sides.

“It’s cold,” he said. “Do we have to stand talking in this house all night?”

“Sorry.” Bartholdi’s feet also began to move, taking the puddle along.

They went downstairs and out to their cars. Bartholdi stopped outside his car and spoke to Jay, who had veered off with Farley toward his own.

“I’m not sure of the location of The Cornish Arms. I’ll follow you.”

“Oh?” Jay stopped and turned, colliding with Farley, who was at his shoulder. “Are you coming along?”

“Yes.”

“I’m very tired. I don’t think I can keep going much longer. Couldn’t we put it off until tomorrow?”

“I want that newspaper, the one with the Personal in it. And maybe Green has got back from wherever he went — I want to talk to him. There are other things, too.”

“Well, all right.”

14

“Hush!” said Fanny.

She said it softly and fiercely, leaning forward in a listening attitude. Ben, who had not been making a sound, followed directions simply by continuing to do what he had been doing, which was nothing. Fanny got up and, having removed her shoes some time before for greater comfort, padded swiftly through the darkened living room to the hall door, where she laid an ear against the panel. Then, straightening with a ladylike curse, she returned to the bedroom as silently as she had come.

“Just as I suspected!” Fan said. “They have sneaked into Jay’s apartment without making the least effort to let me know.”

“Perhaps, on the contrary,” said Ben, “they made an effort to keep you from knowing.”

“I shouldn’t be surprised. In any event, it’s a dirty trick. They know very well that I have been waiting and waiting to hear what happened at police headquarters.”

“What surprises me is that you even heard them come in. I was just as alert as you were, arid I didn’t hear a sound.”

“Have you had your ears examined recently?”

“There’s nothing wrong with my ears. There’s nothing wrong with my nose, either. That’s because I keep it out of other folks’ business.”

“Well, whatever the condition of your various organs, there certainly seems to be something wrong with your head. Are you incapable of understanding anything? I tried to tell you that this is now police business, thanks to Jay. And the police are quite likely, in my opinion, to make it the business of everyone.”

“I doubt it. A mere wandering wife? Husbands who can’t keep their wives at home are not taken very seriously by the fuzz.”

“Maybe so, maybe not. It all depends on what happens to the wives when they are not at home.”

“True. I must admit, Fan, that you have a happy knack of going straight to the heart of a matter. I’m prepared to bet, however, that what is, happening to Terry is rarely prosecuted these days as a criminal offense.”

“That remains to be seen. Just because you’ve been off wallowing in the fleshpots, you needn’t suspect it of everyone else.”

“Who’s been wallowing in fleshpots?”

“Do you deny it?”

“I neither deny nor affirm. I maintain a gentlemanly silence.”

“Just wait until the police get to you. We’ll see then how long you maintain silence, gentlemanly or otherwise.”

“I’ll wait, and I advise you to do the same. No doubt Farley will be over soon, and you can pump him dry.”

“If you think I’m going to stay here and wait for Farley to come when he gets good and ready, you can think again.”

“What are you going to do?”

“I’m going over there immediately, and you’re coming with me.”

“Like hell!” Ben, who had been in a prone position, came quickly erect and planted his stockinged feet on the floor. “Not on your life!”

“Oh, come on, Ben. You deserted me for the entire weekend. The least you can do now is be accommodating.”

“Damn it, I didn’t desert you. I only went off for a couple of days on my own business.”

“Are you sure it was strictly your business? For your sake, let us hope so.”

“At any rate, I’m quite comfortable where I am, and I refuse to budge.”

“Will you come if I kiss you?”

“Don’t tempt me. You know I have no character.”

“I’m prepared to be especially liberal on this occasion.”

“I’m wavering. As a matter of fact, I’m seduced.”

“Good. You will find that I am as good as my word.”

Indeed, she was a great deal better. She was by all odds, Ben thought, the most talented kisser this side of heaven. Or, he amended, his pulses pounding, it would be more appropriate to look for comparisons in the opposite direction. It was neither hurried nor scrimped, and it delayed their departure for longer than Fanny had intended or Ben had hoped.

“You know,” said Fanny finally, “I’m inclined to believe you after all.”

“Regarding what?”

“Regarding what you haven’t been doing this weekend.”

“I haven’t said what I haven’t been doing.”

“Just the same, your reactions are not those of a man who has been satiated, or even appeased.”

“I’d be happy to offer further evidence.”

“No. I have kept my word, Ben, now you keep yours.”

“All right. But we’re choosing the duller of two alternatives.”

He found his shoes on the floor and put them on, while she put on her own and inspected her lips for damage in the mirror above the chest. Minor repairs having been made, they crossed the hall and knocked on Jay’s door; and Fanny, after knocking, opened it without waiting for a response. Jay was seated with his head in his hands, and Farley was sprawled on the sofa, supported on one elbow. Aside from looking up, neither moved when Fanny and Ben entered.

“Hello, you. two,” Fanny said briskly. “Jay, you look absolutely like the wrath. You must go to bed immediately after telling me what happened at police headquarters.”

Jay groaned and put his head back in his hands. Farley opened his mouth to answer, and then said nothing; but he neglected to close his mouth. Captain Bartholdi appeared suddenly in the kitchen doorway.

“Who are you?” Fanny demanded.

“I was about,” said Bartholdi, “to ask you the same question.”

“Captain Bartholdi, Miss Moran,” Jay said.

“She’s my half-sister,” said Farley. “I don’t remember if we warned you about her or not. If we didn’t, we should have.”

“How do you do, Miss Moran,” Bartholdi said.

“Quite well, thank you. Why don’t you just call me Fanny?”

“Am I correct in thinking that this is Mr. Green?”

“Just call me Ben,” said Ben. “I can see that we’re intruding, so we’ll excuse ourselves. Come on, Fan.”

“Don’t be absurd,” Fanny said. “Are we intruding, Captain Bartholdi?”

“Not at all,” Bartholdi said. “As a matter of fact, I want to talk to you both.”

“I was afraid of that,” Ben said. He went over to seat himself gloomily on the sofa beside Farley, who had, by sitting up, made room. There was still space left for Fanny, and she took possession of it. Bartholdi remained standing, perhaps because standing reinforced his air of command. He already had the feeling, relative to Fanny, that maintaining command would present certain difficulties.

“Are you a police captain?” Fanny said.

“Yes.”

“Then it’s your job to look for missing people?”

“Sometimes.”

“Are you going to look for Terry?”

“I intend to do whatever is indicated.”

This answer struck Fanny as evasive. She studied Bartholdi’s bland Gallic face for a moment, trying to decide if he was reliable and efficient. She had a strong notion that he was both, and a great deal more when more was called for.

“You must be good at your job. You have to be good, don’t you, to get to be a captain?”

“Usually. Sometimes it’s politics.”

“I don’t believe it was politics in your case. I must say I’m relieved.”

“I’ll try to justify your confidence.”

Bartholdi had a feeling about Fanny also, and the feeling was that the interview was going the wrong way. The wrong person, that is, was asking the questions. Not that he was excessively disturbed by this. He was prepared to maneuver from any position.

“Why a captain?” said Ben suddenly.

“What?”

Bartholdi turned his eyes on Ben, startled. He was aware of having been pricked by a shrewd thrust.

“Isn’t it unusual far a captain to be assigned to a case like this?”

“Why so?”

“Well, for one thing, we don’t even know if it amounts to anything yet, and neither do you. In my opinion it doesn’t. For another thing, Terry isn’t what you’d call a VIP. It seems odd that she’d draw so much rank the first thing.”

“All people are important, aren’t they?” This was an interesting young fellow, Bartholdi thought. Have to keep parrying him for a while.

“There you are, Ben,” said Fanny. “I hope you’re ashamed of yourself. How do you think it makes Jay feel when you talk like that?”

Jay was in fact feeling very little except exhaustion and a queer sense of loss that was growing worse. Hearing his name dropped in a conversation that he hadn’t followed, he looked up from his hands, and he focused on the right hand of Bartholdi, which held a newspaper narrowly folded. The newspaper was slapping softly against Bartholdi’s thigh.

“What’s that?” Jay asked.

“This?” Bartholdi lifted the newspaper and stared at it as if he had forgotten it. “Oh, a copy of Thursday evening’s Journal. I found it in the kitchen in a stack of papers.”

“We let them accumulate for a week or so before we put them out in the hall.” Behind their thick lenses, Jay’s dull eyes sharpened and turned toward the telephone. “But Thursday evening’s Journal is on the desk there, where you left it.”

“This is another copy.”

“We only take one. Why would we have two?”

“A good question. There’s a reasonable answer to it, however. Since it’s the copy in which the Personal appeared, it’s reasonable to assume that your wife was expecting and anticipating it. She would have been anxious to see it as soon as possible, Therefore, if she was out when the papers hit the streets, she probably bought an extra copy and carried it home afterward. Do you happen to remember if she was away from home Thursday afternoon?”

“I haven’t the least idea.” Jay seemed to have lost all interest in the matter immediately Bartholdi offered his explanation. “She was here when I arrived shortly before six. Where she may have been earlier, I couldn’t say.”

“Well, never mind.” Bartholdi’s interest also seemed to be gone. He diverted his attention to Fanny and Ben. “Can either of you two, thinking back, recall anything Mrs. Miles said that might have been a clue to where she was going on Friday afternoon?”

“Not I,” said Fanny. “I’ve tried and tried, but I can’t remember a thing.”

“I haven’t tried at all,” Ben said, “and there’s no use trying now. She said she had an appointment, as Farley can verify, but she didn’t say where or with whom, and that’s all there is to it.”

“All right. Now I want to ask you a question that calls for an opinion. Do you think,” said Bartholdi, “that kidnapping is a likely explanation?”

It was immediately apparent from their expression that, of all possible questions, this was the least expected.

“Kidnapping!” Fanny said. “Are you serious?”

“Why shouldn’t I be?”

“On the contrary, why should you be?” Ben said. “Terry isn’t famous, and she doesn’t have any money to speak of. What could be gained by kidnapping her?”

“She does have money.”

“What do you mean?”

“She is the heiress to a considerable estate. She isn’t in control of it yet, but there’s no doubt that it could be tapped by a kidnapper.”

“It’s news to me. Is it true, Jay?”

“It’s true, Ben,” Jay said.

“Well, why was no one ever told? I, for one, knew absolutely nothing about it. Did you know anything about it, Fanny?”

“Not before Terry disappeared. Jay mentioned it for the first time yesterday. And that, as I see it, is the point. I didn’t know it, and Ben and Farley didn’t know it, and according to Jay it’s unlikely that anyone around here knew it. Don’t you see? If you’re going to kidnap someone for money, you have to know that the person has it, or that someone else will pay it.”

“I understand that,” Bartholdi said gently. “Miss Moran, I wasn’t accusing anyone here of kidnapping—”

“I should hope not!”

“—but I can’t simply discard the possibility. That’s why I asked your opinion.”

“I suppose it’s possible,” Ben said. “But I don’t think it’s probable.”

“As for me,” said Fanny, “my opinion is even less favorable.”

“Well.” Bartholdi’s shrug was noncommittal. “If there is any substance to the theory, we should soon be hearing from the kidnapper. In the meanwhile, we mustn’t let it blind us to other considerations. The Personal, for instance, suggests a closer relationship than kidnapper-victim, though there’s a definite chance the same individual is involved in both. And I would like to know, incidentally, how Mrs. Miles left this building and vanished without, apparently, being seen by anyone.”

“I can’t see that there is any great problem there,” Fanny said. “She just walked out when no one happened to be looking.”

“But the building superintendent was working, I’ve been told, in the front lobby at the time she must have left. He’s positive she didn’t go out that way.”

“Then she must have gone out the back way. Why do you insist on making a mystery of something that can be easily explained, Captain? I should think you’d be trying to find out where she went and where she is, instead of which door she walked out of to get there.”

Bartholdi smiled. He was already beginning to feel an affinity for Fanny, whom he had first categorized as a charming little nut. “We’ll just accept the fact that she’s gone and proceed from there. And speaking of being gone, it’s time, I think, that we were. Mr. Miles is exhausted, and I’m sure your brother has nothing more to tell me at the moment. Do you Jive in the building, Miss Moran?”

“I live upstairs over Farley. Why?”

“I thought we might go there to finish our discussion, if you don’t mind.”

“Can Ben come with us?”

“By all means.”

“That’s not necessary,” Ben said. “I’m like Farley. I have nothing more to tell you.”

“What do you mean, nothing more?” said Fanny. “You haven’t told him anything yet.”

“That’s what I have to tell,” Ben said. “Not anything.”

“That remains to be seen,” said Bartholdi amiably. “If we talk long enough under the right conditions, you may think of something.”

The third degree may or may not have been implied, Ben thought glumly, but the polite official tone was unmistakable. Fanny had him by the hand, damn her, and was leading him toward the door while Bartholdi said good night to Jay and Farley.

15

“I have a little gin,” said Fanny, “if anyone would care for a martini or something.”

“I’d care for one,” Ben said. “But I imagine there is a regulation against it so far as Captain Bartholdi is concerned.”

“So far as I’m concerned,” Captain Bartholdi said, “regulations are flexible.”

“In that case,” Fanny said, “we will all have one. Please make yourselves comfortable.”

Bartholdi, in an easy chair, had no apparent difficulty in doing so, but for Ben it was harder. After all, when it came to feeling comfortable in the company of a police captain on official business, it was much easier said than done. Fanny was creating small musical sounds in the kitchen with glasses and ice and a long spoon. Ben stared at his extended legs, wondering if the wiser course would be to lie or simply clam up.

“You’re a graduate student at the university, Mr. Green?” Bartholdi asked.

“That’s right.”

“Your roommate, I understand, is studying law. Is that your field?”

“No. History.”

“Oh? Do you plan to teach?”

“I’ve had some such notion.”

“I was told that you’ve been away over the weekend.”

“Yes,” Ben said.

“When did you leave?”

“Friday afternoon. Two o’clock or thereabouts. I don’t know exactly.”

“And you got back this afternoon?”

“Yes. Late. After Farley and Jay had left to see you.”

“Do you mind telling me where you’ve been?”

“Yes.”

“You mind?”

“Yes.”

“Why?”

“I just like to keep my business to myself.”

“So do I, when possible. Sometimes, unfortunately, it’s not. I congratulate you, at any rate, on reaching the better of two bad decisions.”

“What decision?”

“To tell me nothing instead of lies. If you had lied, it would have been the worse for you in the end. As it is, it may be bad enough.”

“Cool it, man! You don’t even know there’s anything wrong. Or do you?”

“A woman’s missing. Isn’t that enough?”

“Not to rate a captain.”

“One thing about captains, we’re discreet, if that’s any reassurance to you.”

“It isn’t,” Ben said.

“We’ll find out anyhow. You’d be better off telling me voluntarily.”

“That,” said Fanny, returning with a tray of martinis, “remains uncertain. He might be better off with the police, Captain, but it is by no means established that he would be better off with me.”

“Oh?” Bartholdi glanced curiously from Fanny to Ben, who was looking sourly at Fanny. “Perhaps, Miss Moran, I’d better talk to Ben alone.”

Ben was not deceived, by the use of his given name, into any false sense of security.

“Don’t pay any attention to Fan, Captain,” he said. “She wants to deprive other girls of the entertainment she persistently rejects for herself.”

“Could it be that you’re admitting something?” Fanny cried.

“Damn it, you can badger me all night, and that’s all it will get you! You may as well let me alone.”

“That’s true.” Fanny addressed Bartholdi, who was tasting his martini and finding it cold and dry and as good as cheap gin could make it. “I can testify that he’s a hopelessly obdurate little devil when he gets his back up.”

“In that event, we will save time and effort by doing as he says. We will let him alone. Temporarily, anyway.” Bartholdi settled back and looked at Ben without animosity. “I can understand your reluctance to talk about your activities since leaving here Friday, but I’m sure you won’t have the same reluctance concerning events prior to your leaving.”

“What events? What’s to tell that’s worth telling?”

“Let me be the judge. I understand Terry Miles dropped in on you and Farley Moran shortly before you left — before she disappeared. I want you to tell me, as nearly as you can remember, what happened and what was said while the three of you were together.”

“Nothing of any consequence. She wanted to borrow three carrots for some damn ragout. She said she had an appointment at three o’clock, and she wanted to make the ragout before she left so it would be ready for dinner when she and Jay got back in the evening. I gave her the carrots, and we had a beer together and talked nonsense. That’s all there was to it.”

“This appointment. Did she say what it was, or where, or with whom?”

“No. In fact, she made a point of not saying.”

“Did this strike you as odd?”

“With Terry? Not much!”

“If I wanted to,” said Fanny, “I could say something apropos the pot and the kettle.”

“She did fix the ragout and leave it cooking,” Bartholdi said. “Did you know that?”

“She said she was going to, so why wouldn’t she? I’m going to fix one myself soon. It sounded damn good.”

“Did she give you the recipe?”

“Yes.”

“Do you remember it?”

“Sure. There’s nothing complicated about it.”

“I wonder if you’d pass it on to me? I’m a bachelor, and I rather fancy myself as an amateur chef.”

“Happy to oblige. You start with bacon...”

He stopped in response to Bartholdi’s gesture. The captain dug into a pocket and produced a mechanical pencil and a small notebook.

“Here, Ben, write it down.”

Ben took the notebook and pencil and began to write, pausing briefly once in a while to remember the proportions. Fanny, meanwhile, divided her attention between Ben and Bartholdi with an expression of comic incredulity.

“Well,” she said, “if this doesn’t beat anything I’ve ever seen or heard! I was under the impression that we were discussing something important, and all of a sudden, without warning, you two are off on a ragout. Can’t you stick to the subject?”

Bartholdi took the pencil and notebook from Ben and studied what Ben had written. “Are you sure these are the right ingredients?”

“Positive.”

“And the exact proportions? Proportions are very important in good cooking.”

“That’s just the way Terry told it to Farley and me.”

“It’s quite a lot of onions,” said Fanny, who had taken the liberty of reading over Bartholdi’s shoulder. “No wonder Jay complained.”

“Complained?” Bartholdi looked up. “Complained when?”

“Why, Friday evening, when he and Farley were eating the ragout. He said there were too many onions. You know, Captain, that could be a clue? To Terry’s state of mind Friday — her three o’clock appointment and all, I mean. Or maybe she put too many onions in it purposely to annoy him. The way I’ll make Ben’s martini with too much vermouth. It’s a woman’s way sometimes.”

Bartholdi shrugged. “We had better get back to the point. From remarks that have been dropped, I gather that Terry Miles was inclined to stray a bit.”

“Oh well, it’s an open secret,” Ben said. “It’s true.”

“If so,” said Fanny, glaring at Ben, “it is a habit she shares with certain others I could name, not necessarily females.”

“What particular man or men was she involved with? It may be important.”

“There was something once about Otis Bowers, but it didn’t amount to anything,” Ben said. “The only reason Terry gave old Otis a little exercise was for the pleasure of seeing Ardis in the saucepan. Terry is malicious as well as glandular.”

“Who,” demanded Bartholdi, “is Otis Bowers?”

“He teaches physics at the university. Lives across the hall.”

“And Ardis,” said Fanny, “is his bitch of a wife.”

“Oh? Why do you call her that, Miss Moran?”

“A bitch? Because that’s what Ardis is. Why else would you call someone a bitch?”

“Is that your considered opinion?”

“Very little consideration was called for. It’s perfectly evident.”

“You seem to be a young woman of decided views.”

“She’s a nut is what she is,” Ben said. “She thinks it makes her look taller when she talks dirty.”

Fanny greeted this commentary with all the hauteur it deserved. She took a scornful sip of her martini just to show that she was otherwise unaffected, and scratched for a moment in Her strawberry patch with fingers that weren’t engaged by the glass.

“If you are looking for a lover,” she said, “you are absolutely wasting your time with Otis. He is not only fat, but also home. At least, he was home all weekend. What would be the point in going somewhere to meet a lover who stayed home? It’s stupid on the face of it.”

“I agree,” Bartholdi said.

“As well as frustrating,” said Ben.

“On the other hand,” said Fanny, “Brian O’Hara could be considered a favorable prospect.”

Bartholdi sat up. Ben drained his glass, olive and all. It was difficult to tell if his voice was impaired by amazement or if it was merely the effect of talking around the olive.

“How in hell do you come up with these things, Fan? What does Brian O’Hara have to do with it?”

“I have it on good authority, confirmed by Jay himself, that Terry and Brian O’Hara have been seen together frequently. This, of course, does not mean a great deal in itself. What means a great deal is when they were together and not seen.”

“That,” said Ben, “is neatly put.”

“Do you know Brian O’Hara, Captain?” Fanny asked.

“Very well, both officially and unofficially. Officially, I’m compelled to take a dim view of O’Hara’s activities. Unofficially, I have to concede him certain qualities.”

“So does Terry, apparently,” said Fanny, “although I doubt that they are the same qualities.”

Bartholdi finished his martini. He set his glass aside and rose. “I’ll run along. In some respects, you’ve been quite helpful. In others—” with a look at Ben “—you haven’t.”

When Captain Bartholdi was gone, Ben said excitedly, “He slipped! He slipped! Did you notice it?”

“Slipped how? Notice what?” asked Fanny.

“In his tense. Once or twice he used the past tense in referring to Terry!”

“Whatever do you mean? Damn it, Ben, can’t you ever say right out what’s in your devious little mind?”

“Never mind.” Ben was still staring at the door. “Now I know why there’s a captain on this case.”

16

Bartholdi was abroad early. Presenting himself at the Chubitz Real Estate Agency, he asked to see the top man. It got him into a paneled office with framed photographs of houses on the walls and a pink and white man behind a desk. The desk was an unconvincing imitation of polished walnut, and the man who rose from behind it might have done so, Bartholdi thought, behind a similar desk in a similar office forty years ago in mythical Zenith. The pink and white man with the peculiarly ancient look of an infant was Chubitz himself, with whom Bartholdi had spoken by telephone at his suburban home.

“Good morning, Captain Bartholdi,” Chubitz said. “Sit down, sit down! How can I help you?”

His voice had the rather desperate heartiness of a man who had just been refreshed by two days of frantic leisure. Bartholdi eased himself into a chair and hung his hat on his knee.

“As I told you yesterday,” he said, “I’m interested in one of your properties. It’s known as the old Skully Place.”

“It’s rented,” said the real estate man.

“It’s the renter I’m interested in. You promised to check on the agent involved and have him available this morning. I’d like to talk with him.”

“It appears that the house was rented by Mr. Jenkins, one of our most reliable men. The house was rented to a—” Chubitz consulted a note — “a Mr. Harper. Ivan Harper.”

“You told me all that. Is Jenkins in the office?”

“Yes,” said Chubitz anxiously. “Is anything wrong?”

“We’re interested in this man Harper. Where can I find Jenkins?”

“You’re welcome to see him here in my office. Shall I call him in, Captain?”

It was evident that Chubitz preferred being present to getting a secondhand report from his reliable man later. Bartholdi shrugged, and Chubitz pressed a button that summoned a secretary, who was sent to summon Jenkins. Jenkins, arriving promptly, proved to be an evil-eyed young man with the deadly earnestness of one who lives by commissions.

“Jenkins,” said Chubitz, “this is Captain Bartholdi of the police. He wants to ask you some questions about the Skully property.”

“Right,” said Jenkins. “Right-o.”

“To begin with,” said Bartholdi, “when was the house rented?”

“On a Monday. Two weeks ago today, to be exact.”

The cherubic face of Mr. Chubitz beamed at this evidence of exactness on the part of his Mr. Jenkins. The beam contrived to remain anxious.

“It was rented, I understand,” Bartholdi said, “to a man who gave the name of Ivan Harper.”

“Right. Right-o.”

“Did you take him out to see the house before he rented it?”

“No. He said he’d been by earlier, and he was sure it was the place he wanted.” Jenkins grinned like a shark. “You meet all kinds of kooks in the realty game.”

“He paid a month’s rent in advance?”

“Right you are.”

“Did he pay by check or by cash?”

“Cash.”

“Did he ask you to see to having the gas and electricity turned on?”

“I offered to do it as part of our agency service, but he said he would attend to it himself.”

“Are you aware that he didn’t?”

“He didn’t?”

“As a matter of fact, Harper hasn’t occupied the house at all. It’s still empty.”

“Well, now,” said Mr. Chubitz nervously. “Well, now.”

“Why would a man rent a house he doesn’t intend to occupy?”

“A good question, Mr. Jenkins.”

“I thought at the time there was something queer about the guy. I’ll bet Harper wasn’t even his real name!”

“What made you think the transaction was queer?”

“A kind of feeling he gave me. The cash, for one thing. People usually pay by check—”

“Tell me what he looked like. As accurate and complete a description as possible.”

“Jenkins has a retentive memory,” Chubitz said unhappily. “I’m sure he’ll be most helpful. You mustn’t disappoint us, Jenkins.” There was steel in this last admonition.

Bartholdi, watching Jenkins quail, would have enjoyed planting a shoe on the generous Chubitz bottom. Nothing worse, under the circumstances, could have been said. It was unlikely after two weeks that Jenkins would ordinarily be able to supply more than a vague description. Now, with his employer’s displeasure threatening, he would be worthlessly explicit, adding superfluous gewgaws to what might have been an authentic detail or two.

Bartholdi listened sourly. Tall. Shoulders slightly stooped. Age in the upper middle bracket. Hair graying, parted in the middle and slicked down. Horn-rimmed glasses. Teeth stained badly, as from incessant smoking or chewing tobacco. Going fat about the gut. Neatly dressed in brown suit showing signs of wear. Ditto brown topcoat and brown hat. Walked with a slight limp. And, oh, yes — hands were ingrained with grime that soap no longer removed — the hands, Jenkins had thought, of a mechanic or machinist, at any rate of someone who worked in oil and grease. Jenkins clearly felt that this was his prize item. Like an expectant dog, he waited for commendation.

Bartholdi didn’t give it to him. Instead: could Jenkins identify Harper if he saw him again? Oh, positively! No question about it! Bartholdi secretly doubted it. Jenkins’s description was far too detailed, and there was now no way to separate the truth from the figments of the Jenkins enthusiasm. One thing, at least, could be assumed. If Harper was a kidnapper and murderer, he had not nakedly exposed himself to Jenkins’s observation, however unreliable that might be.

“All right.” Bartholdi shifted in his chair. “We’ll call on you, Mr. Jenkins, if you’re needed further.”

“Right. Right-o.” Jenkins turned to Chubitz. “I believe I’d better have the utility people turn on the gas at the Skully house and start the furnace. If the temperature drops any lower the pipes may freeze.”

“Good thinking, Jenkins. See to it right away.”

“Right-o!”

Back at headquarters, Captain Bartholdi had the switchboard operator give him an outside line. He dialed a number he had been given by Jay Miles, and after a preliminary skirmish with a secretary was talking with Maurice Feldman in Los Angeles. Feldman’s voice sounded husky and hurried, as if he had to rush words through a diseased larynx before the organ wore out.

“I’m calling in reference to a woman named Terry Miles,” Bartholdi said. “I understand you’re the executor of an estate left to her by her father.”

“That’s correct. She was formerly Terry Kinkaid. What kind of scrape is Terry in now?”

“I’m afraid I have bad news, Mr. Feldman. She’s dead.”

There was a long silence. Then the husky, hurried voice came back with a note of genuine regret.

“Poor Terry. I was always afraid she’d come to a bad end. Was it an accident of some kind?”

“It’s murder. It may also have been kidnapping.”

“Murder!” The husk in the attorney’s voice was harsher. “Murder? Are you sure?”

“She was strangled to death.”

“When did it happen, for God’s sake?”

“By the most reliable calculation, some time late last Friday or early Saturday. Her body was not found, however, until yesterday.”

“Why hasn’t there been any news of it?”

“We’ve been sitting on it for the time being. I told you kidnapping is suspected.”

“This means that you don’t know who the murderer is.”

“We’re working on it.”

“How’s Jay bearing up? Terry’s husband.”

“As well as can be expected. Mr. Feldman, I’d like to consult you about a number of things. Can you fly here?”

“I’m tied up in a court action. I can’t possibly leave right how.”

“When can you get away?”

“Possibly in two days. Three, more likely.”

“That’ll have to do. In the meantime, I’d appreciate it if you would keep your mouth shut about this.”

“You have my word on it. Poor Terry. Poor Jay. I’ll be there just as soon as I can make it.”

“Let me know your flight, and I’ll meet you at the airport.”

“I’ll do that.”

Feldman hung up. Bartholdi put on his hat and coat again and went out.

17

The building was constructed of old gray stone, held in the intricate embrace of vines turned brown in the November cold. Inside, at the end of a long hall, was a large central room, with four smaller rooms adjoining. These were accessible, a pair on each of opposite sides, by means of high and narrow doors. A desk stood near the door to each of the four smaller rooms, each desk littered with books and papers. Above each door, fastened with thumb tacks to the jamb, was a small sign identifying the occupant of the room. One of the signs, with a contempt for academic rank, read MR. MILES. The desk outside this door was occupied by a young woman who wore a pair of harlequin glasses. She was diligently attacking a stack of papers with a blue pencil. There was no one else in the room, and Bartholdi was forced to clear his throat in order to attract her attention.

“I beg your pardon,” he said, “but is Professor Miles in his office?”

As Bartholdi had anticipated, she shook her head. She had dark brown hair severely arranged, but Bartholdi’s Gallic perception, in spite of the hairdo and the glasses, gave her due credit for hidden goodies.

“I’m sorry,” she said. “Professor Miles called to say that he won’t be in today. I’m Freda Page, his student assistant. Can I help you?”

Bartholdi considered. He said suddenly, “Maybe you can, Miss Page. My name is Captain Bartholdi. I’m a police officer.”

Was there, for an instant, a flicker behind the lenses?

“Yes?” she said.

“I’m going to be frank with you, Miss Page. I’ve got to rely on your discretion—”

“I don’t carry tales, if that’s what you mean.”

“Good. Professor Miles’s wife is missing. She’s been gone since Friday afternoon.”

“I know.” Freda Page studied her blue pencil for a moment, then laid it carefully between the stacks of marked and unmarked papers. “He told me when he phoned this morning.”

“Oh? What else did he tell you?”

“Nothing. Just that Terry left home Friday and hasn’t been seen since.”

“Did he say that he’d been to the police?”

“He did.”

“Then you must have been expecting a police officer.”

“Not necessarily. I can’t see what you hope to learn by coming here.”

“I noticed that you called Mrs. Miles Terry. Do you know her well?”

“Well enough.”

This terse remark, Bartholdi thought, although uttered without emphasis, was susceptible to analysis. Did it imply that even a little of Terry was enough? And was the color a little higher in Freda Page’s cheeks? It was an interesting speculation. Loyalty was not always a virtue. Nor was love, for that matter, at least in a police investigation.

“Can you suggest any reason why she left home?” he asked.

“None whatever. No, that isn’t so. I could suggest one, but it would be slanderous if not true, and I can’t prove that it is.”

“I asked for a suggestion, not proof. Do you mean that she’s probably off with some man?”

“I mean that she’s wanton and faithless.” Freda Page’s cheeks were now hot.

“How do you know? Hearsay?”

“More directly than that. Professor Miles seems to respect my judgment and discretion. He sometimes confides in me.”

“Why don’t you call him Jay? That’s what you call him privately, isn’t it?”

If he had hoped for confusion, he was disappointed. She smiled defiantly, adjusting her glasses on her nose.

“Very well, then. Jay.”

“That’s better. More comfortable for both of us. I take it you think a lot of Professor Miles.”

“I do. Personally and professionally. He deserves a better wife.”

Like Freda Page? Bartholdi wondered. Or was theirs the kind of student-teacher relationship that breeds on every campus, not to be taken seriously? Freda Page, however, must surely be a graduate student of some standing. She was not, at any rate, a child.

“Does he think so?”

“I wouldn’t presume to say. Why don’t you ask him?”

“Mrs. Miles apparently had an appointment Friday afternoon. Did you know that?”

“Of course not. Why should I?”

“I thought she might have come here.”

“To the office? I don’t think so. Not to my knowledge, anyhow.”

“Not here necessarily. To the university. Did you see her on campus?”

“I didn’t see her at all, on campus or anywhere else.”

“Was Professor Miles in the office here that afternoon?”

“Yes, for a few minutes after lunch. He also came back for fifteen or twenty minutes after his last class of the day.”

“What time was that?”

“Two-thirty.”

“Does the class meet in this building?”

“Yes, on the second floor.”

“Then he must have left the office before three.”

“I suppose he did. Why? I don’t see how Jay’s time schedule will help you find his wife.”

“One more question, Miss Page. Did he say where he was going when he left here?”

“No.”

“He says he didn’t get home until about six.”

“He may have worked in the library. He often does that. I’m sorry I can’t be of more help.”

Bartholdi wondered if she was. He had a notion that Freda Page considered the disappearance of Terry Miles to be, at the worst, good riddance. He thanked the girl, and as he turned away she was already picking up the blue pencil to resume her work on the pile of unmarked papers.

Two hundred yards further along a curving concrete walk, swarming at the moment with between-class students, he found the administration building. At the foot of the wide shallow steps leading up to the entrance, he paused and looked back along the way he had come. The swarm of hurrying students was thinning rapidly in the final moments of intermission. He wondered if there was a perpetual competition among undergraduates nowadays to see which could devise the sloppiest costume. But then his student days were thirty-odd years in the past, and his recollections were probably distorted by nostalgia.

Inside, he sought out the registrar’s office. He identified himself to a female clerk behind a high counter and asked if he might see the registrar. He was invited behind the counter and into a private office, where he was greeted by a dehydrated little gray man who reminded him, for some reason, of a hungry sparrow. The registrar’s name was Wister, and he offered a dry gray hand.

“Sit down, Captain Bartholdi,” he said. “How can I serve you?”

“It’s a routine matter,” Bartholdi said, holding on to his hat and keeping his topcoat on, “which I would prefer not to explain just now.”

Registrar Wister made a tent of his fingers. “If you will just tell me what you wish to know...”

Bartholdi extended a page, torn from his notebook, on which he had written a list of names. “I’d appreciate it if I could see the records of these people.”

Wister read the names, listed one to a line in a vertical column:

Jay Miles.

Otis Bowers.

Ardis Bowers.

Farley Moran.

Benjamin Green.

Fanny Moran.

“Doctor Miles and “Doctor Bowers are, of course, members of our faculty,” Wister said. “So is Mrs. Bowers, in a lesser capacity. She is, I believe, a graduate instructor.”

“I know that.”

“You must realize that our records are limited in this office, Captain, especially with respect to the faculty. More detailed information would be available from the heads of the various departments.”

“That can come later, if necessary. I’m interested at the moment only in general background information.”

“Well, let’s see what we have.”

Wister disappeared in the outside office, taking Bartholdi’s list with him. He was back shortly with five manila folders. He placed them on the desk before Bartholdi.

“There is nothing on Fanny Moran,” the registrar said. “She is not a student in this institution.”

“I know. I just thought she once might have been.”

“There’s no record of her. If you’ll excuse me, there’s something I must see to.”

Wister went out, and Bartholdi hunched over the desk. He culled the five folders one by one. When he was finished he had acquired, besides the knowledge that Ben Green was a brilliant student and Farley Moran no better than fair, some information that, in effect, enlarged his prospects. Otis Bowers had been a student, before coming to Handclasp, at the California Institute of Technology in Pasadena. Ardis Bowers had been at C.I.T. with him, not then a student but already his wife. Ben Green, although he had done all his college work at Handclasp, was a legal resident of Glendale. Farley Moran was a transfer student from U.C.L.A. (Fanny Moran, who had no record, could be assumed tentatively to have come, before or after or with Farley, from the same area.) In brief, there seemed to be a California colony in Handclasp. More significantly, perhaps, at The Cornish Arms.

Wister returned after a while to find Bartholdi leaning back in his chair with eyes closed. He appeared to be sleeping: he was, in fact, far from it. The manila folders were stacked neatly in alphabetical order and pushed back on the registrar’s desk.

“Are you finished, Captain?” Wister asked.

“Yes, thank you.” Bartholdi opened his eyes and pushed his chair back.

“I’m sure you will respect the rights of these individuals—” Wister indicated the manila stack “—to all possible privacy.”

“Of course.”

Bartholdi took the registrar’s dry hand, gave it up, and left. Outside he walked slowly along the curving concrete walk in the direction of the library, his topcoat flapping about his legs.

18

There is in American legend a kind of hero. The legend has variations, as has the hero. He is not so much an individual of heroic proportions as a prototype who effuses a certain character. He begins humbly; and he is compelled, by early environment and example, to take a predatory posture. He recognizes the necessity of being hard and the advantage of being merciless. He uses his wealth to acquire charm and polish, which he exploits to consolidate his position. Perhaps he climbs through precinct and ward to political power, often behind the scenes. Or he becomes mighty in business, or in organized labor. Sometimes he flouts the law directly, rather than obliquely, and rises in the rackets.

Condemned in public, he is often admired in private. His ultimate strength is not in what he has but in what he lacks, which is conscience. He is always dangerous.

Young Brian O’Hara could hardly be expected to have achieved the dimensions of such a legend. But he was on the way.

O’Hara’s history did not quite conform to the specifications. His beginning was not humble; his middle-class father, although far from wealthy, was comfortably enough situated to provide his only son with a college education, for example. At college the younger O’Hara had played football and basketball. In football he was competent; in basketball he excelled; in both, by drive and luck, he prospered. For as a sophomore he began placing bets (progressively larger) on the contests in which he was engaged, never permitting a foolish loyalty to prevent his betting on his alma mater’s opponents when it seemed judicious to do so. On the gridiron his successes were largely the result of chance, but on the court his skill furthered his cause. It is surprising what a good thing a clever operator can make of this sort of thing. By the time Brian O’Hara graduated, he had a secret bank account of $20,000.

Cast loose on the world, he saw no reason for spoiling a good thing. His instinct functioned, his luck held, and his interests spread. He now had valuable contacts of a certain kind across the country; and he became a post-graduate specialist in collegiate athletic competitions, digressing only now and then, for variety, into the realms of the pros. The bank accounts grew rapidly in spite of taxes, which he was smart enough to pay in full, and spilled over into investments that proved financially lucrative. Among these were two night spots in Handclasp where college tastes were pandered to. They were expensive, as such spots go; they made no attempt to attract patronage of those who could not afford them, and so were largely patronized by those who could. Collegians were not the only patrons. They merely set the tone; and many of them were sources of profitable information.

As Captain Bartholdi had said, Brian O’Hara was not unknown to the police. His activities did not come under Bartholdi’s surveillance, but the captain knew O’Hara’s reputation for running a smooth operation. If he was a habitual violator of the law, he chose with care the laws he violated. He never strayed into transgressions where the chance of failure was multiplied by unnecessary risks, and the consequences were too high for the game. At least, Bartholdi reflected on his way to O’Hara’s, he never had before. But then, in the precarious dodges O’Hara engaged in, there were always unpredictable forces at work. Such as the violent potential of love, or passion, or whatever it was that a particular woman generated to make the disciplined sanity of a lifetime go up in smoke.

That was the point as Bartholdi saw it. If O’Hara was involved in the death of Terry Miles, kidnapping was no factor. Passion and violence were conceivable but not, coldly calculated, the long odds against abduction and murder. And if not, what was the significance of all the folderol about the renting of an isolated house?

Well, thought Bartholdi, pushing the button beside O’Hara’s door, that remained to be seen. In the meantime, one neglected no possibility and remained always open to the long chance.

Bartholdi’s having rung at O’Hara’s door, the door was opened by O’Hara himself. It was nearly three o’clock in the afternoon, and the fixer was shaved and brushed and impeccably dressed in a gray suit, white shirt and maroon tie, apparently open for business. If his reaction to the sight of Bartholdi was less than enthusiastic, it was at least congenial; and his time, within limits, was at Bartholdi’s disposal.

“Hello, Captain,” he said. “Come on in. What brings you to the camp of the enemy?”

“Enemy?” Bartholdi stepped in and even allowed himself to be divested of his hat and topcoat. “I’m here to see if you might be willing to give me a little help.”

“You selling tickets? I’ll take fifty.”

“No tickets. Just a little information off the record.”

“Sure. Anything for good relations with the fuzz. How about a drink?”

“No, thanks.” Bartholdi helped himself to a chair. “I’m looking for a stray. A woman by the name of Terry Miles. I believe you know her.”

“Wait a minute.” O’Hara’s voice had suddenly withdrawn. It reached Bartholdi, clear and cold and no longer offering to buy tickets. “Since when do you concern yourself with tray wives?”

“Captains don’t come so high. And this looks as if it might lead to something interesting.”

“You’ll have to do better than that, Captain. If you want me to play, deal from the top of the deck.”

“All right, I’ll play it straight. A man’s wife is missing. She’s been missing for about three days, since Friday afternoon. Apparently no one saw her leave, no one knows where she went or where she is. The husband asked for police help, and he’s getting it; he’s a college professor who could raise a stink through channels if he chose. We also have reason to suspect that this isn’t simply a case of a woman on the prowl. That’s all you’re going to get. Are you playing?”

“A hand or two, at least till I see how the game’s going. I know Terry well. I intend to know her better. She’s hot stuff.”

“Would you care to amplify that?”

“Isn’t it plain enough?”

“There would be complications, of course. She already has a husband. Or are you shooting for something less legal?”

“Her husband doesn’t seem to bother her. Why should he bother me?”

“It’s a good point, and I get the feeling it’s particularly valid in this case. It’s my impression that her husband is on the point of leaving her.”

“Really?” O’Hara’s laugh was hard and flat. “Don’t you think he’s kind of late? It seems she’s already left him.”

“It may not be so simple. Or do you happen to know where she is?”

“I don’t. I told Jay Miles that when he was here Saturday night. I’ve tried to find her since, without any luck. I’ll tell you this, though. If anything has happened to her, somebody’s going to pay for it. I’m no gutless husband. I know what Terry is, and she suits me just right. I have a notion that a woman like her quits looking when she has what she needs. And as far as Terry’s concerned, I’ve got it. For your information, Captain, she was planning to get a divorce.”

“Thanks for the information. You haven’t seen her since Friday? Haven’t heard from her?”

“No.”

“You say you’ve been looking for her. Where have you looked?”

“Various places. She wasn’t there, so it doesn’t matter.”

“You have no idea where she may have gone?”

“If I had an idea where, I’d look there. She had a date with me for cocktails Friday afternoon. She didn’t show. I assumed that something had come up, and I didn’t try to find out the reason.”

“Why not?”

“Climb off it, Captain. We didn’t give a damn about her husband, but why rub it in his face?”

Bartholdi smiled. “I get the impression you don’t like Jay Miles.”

“I don’t feel anything about him, one way or another. At least, I didn’t. Now, I don’t know. There was something phony about his coming here.”

“It seems to me, since he knows or suspects about your affair with his wife, that it was logical.”

“It could have been a cover.”

Bartholdi extended his legs. His eyes seemed cloudy. “Oh? How do you mean?”

“What would you do if you’d knocked off your wife, for instance, and wanted to hide it?”

“Are you making an accusation?” Bartholdi said, blinking. He was almost yawning.

“I’m making nothing. I’m speculating.”

“Speculate some more.”

“It’s simple enough. You’d run crying to the police, and you’d try to throw suspicion wherever it might stick.”

“It would be a dangerous game.”

“Murder is a dangerous game, they tell me:” O’Hara’s voice was mocking.

“Why would Miles kill his wife?”

“Because she was the kind of wife that a certain kind of husband might think needed killing. I’ll bet it’s never occurred to our professor friend that his problems with Terry are his own fault. He’s deficient. He hasn’t got what it takes to keep her home. Compared to Terry he’s a damn dull tool. I told you I’m under no illusions about Terry. To me, she’s an exciting challenge I can handle. Our professor can’t and never could. She’s given him one hell of a bad time. A weak man who’s been made a monkey of often goes off the deep end.”

“You’re quite a psychologist.” Bartholdi tacked suddenly. “Do you know that Terry Miles is heiress to a small fortune?”

O’Hara’s expression of surprise was, Bartholdi thought, genuine.

“No kidding. She never mentioned it to me.”

“She’ll get it next year.”

O’Hara shrugged. He said shortly, “It makes no difference to me. I’m pretty well fixed.”

“The estate was left by Terry’s father, a minor movie executive, I understand. It’s administered by a lawyer in Los Angeles.”

“I know that Terry comes from there. I go there myself two, three times a year. She’s mentioned it. But nothing about coming into a bundle.”

“Maybe you know the lawyer. His name is Feldman.”

O’Hara shook his head. “I don’t know him.”

“Well, I won’t keep you any longer.” Bartholdi rose and picked up his hat and coat. “I appreciate your giving me the time.”

“Think nothing of it.”

Bartholdi looked at his watch. “I’ve got to check in at headquarters, then I’m going home and make my dinner.”

O’Hara was astonished. “You cook?”

“I’m a bug on home cooking. Matter of fact, got a new recipe I’m eager to try. It’s a ragout — Student’s Ragout, it’s called. Ever heard of it?”

“I wouldn’t know a ragout from a soufflé.”

Captain Bartholdi shook his head in almost genuine dismay at O’Hara’s culinary ignorance. Then he put his hat and coat on and went out.

19

Fanny got back to The Cornish Arms between five and six. Outside the entrance, she met Ben Green coming from the opposite direction. Ben was cradling a brown paper sack like a baby in his right arm.

“Hello, Ben,” Fanny said. “What have you got in the sack?”

“Groceries,” said Ben.

“Have you been to the market?”

“No, I bought them from my banker. Where in hell would you expect me to buy groceries?”

“Well, you needn’t be so nasty about it. I was only asking to be agreeable. What kind of groceries have you bought?”

“Carrots and potatoes and onions. If you must know, I’m going to make a ragout like the one Terry told me about.”

“Are you sure you still remember how to do it?”

“Certainly I’m sure. It’s easy enough to remember.”

“I should think you’d be reluctant to cook it, what with what’s happened and everything.”

Ben said a four-letter word. “Do you think the damn ragout is some kind of witch’s brew that makes people disappear into thin air?”

“It’s just the principle of the thing.”

“I see no principle involved,” said Ben stiffly.

They had moved into the building while they talked, Fanny reversing the amenities in deference to his load of groceries by holding the door open for him. In the hall she did not veer off toward the stairs, but continued at Ben’s side in the direction of his apartment.

“Where do you think you’re going?” he said.

Fanny said, “I thought it might be nice to share the ragout with you.”

“Think again. I’m going to share it with Farley.”

“No problem. We can cook enough for three.”

“Does it ever occur to you that you might not be welcome?”

“That is seldom the case. Please don’t be difficult, Ben. I can help you prepare it and make myself useful in all sorts of ways. Besides, if I decide to marry you, we will be eating together all the time. The practice will do you good.”

“There you go again! Who the hell asked you to marry me?”

“It’s a natural inference. You certainly display enough interest in what goes with marriage.”

“That,” said Ben sourly, “is not the same thing.”

Having reached his door, he shifted the brown paper sack from his right arm to his left and started to dig in his pants pocket for the key. Then he remembered that he had neglected to lock the door, as usual, and he pushed it open and entered impolitely ahead of Fanny. She cheerfully followed him in.

“Where’s Farley?” she asked brightly.

“How would I know? Still at the university, I suppose. He’ll be here pretty soon.”

He went into the kitchen, put the sack containing the onions and potatoes and carrots on the cabinet, took off his hat and coat and, returning to the living room, threw them into a chair. Fanny dropped her own on top of his.

“What do you want me to do?” she said. “Shall I prepare the vegetables?”

“You might as well, as long as you’re staying. Three carrots, three onions, and four large potatoes. And be damn sure you slice them thin. That’s specified.”

“Will that be enough for four servings?”

“Four servings! You and I and Farley make three. Or have you decided to invite someone else to share the ragout?”

“Well, it seems only fair to ask Jay. After all, he shared his with Farley when you and Terry were away, even if it was Terry who actually invited him, and it’s the least you can do to return the favor. How would you feel if you were in Jay’s place, with no one to prepare your dinner or anything?”

“By God, I’d prepare my own, just as I’m about to do.”

“Oh, don’t be such a Scrooge, Ben. Anyone would think a few vegetables mattered.”

“Bacon arid steak happen to be involved, too. Round steak, for your information, costs ninety-eight cents a pound.”

“Well, hell’s fire! I’ll tell you what I’ll do. I’ll give you a dollar, that’s what. You’ll make two cents profit on the deal.”

“Fan, I’m no tightwad, and you know it. It’s just that you’re so damn pushy, inviting people all over the place. If you want to know the truth, I was going to ask Jay anyhow. There’ll be enough for everyone.”

“Do you want me to ask him now?”

“No. What I want you to do is slice the onions and potatoes and carrots while I get the bacon and steak ready.”

“What if Jay can’t come? Don’t you think I’d better go ahead and ask him?”

“If he can’t come, there’ll be just that much more for the rest of us.”

Fanny tied a dish towel around her waist and started slicing the vegtables. Having to slice them thin was complicated by the dullness of Ben’s paring knife; and Ben, who had only to halve the bacon strips and trim and cut the steak into small pieces, was finished before her and didn’t offer to do anything thereafter but stand around and watch. To make matters worse, the onions made Fanny cry, and she had to stop now and then to wipe her eyes on the dish towel.

“Is it necessary to have so much onion?” she blubbered.

“Yes, it is,” Ben said. “That’s what Terry said the recipe called for, and that’s what we’re going to have. Besides, I happen to like onions.”

“Well, Jay doesn’t like them. I told you he complained Friday night because Terry had used too many.”

“If Jay wants any of my ragout, he’ll have to eat it the way I make it.”

The vegetables were finally sliced; and Ben, lacking an electric skillet, placed them and the meat in a heavy pot in the designated order. He added a small amount of water and put the pot on the stove. While he was doing this, Fanny was opening doors and looking into cabinets.

“What are you looking for?” Ben demanded.

“I thought you might have some gin. I like to have a martini before dinner when possible.”

“In this case, it isn’t. I don’t have any gin, and even if I did, I don’t have any vermouth.”

“I should think you’d keep a little gin on hand for your guests. Surely there’s something around to drink.”

“There isn’t even any beer. If you want a martini, go up and get your own makings.”

“I suppose I’ll have to. On the way I’ll invite Jay, if you don’t mind. Under the circumstances, he’d probably appreciate a drink.”

“Under the circumstances, he may have had a few dozen drinks already. In his place, I would.”

“Well, you’re weak.”

Fanny went across the hall to her first stop. She knocked on the door but got no answer. She knocked again, with no better luck. Perhaps Jay wasn’t in, Fan thought. On the other hand perhaps he was; it was entirely possible that he was either ignoring the knock or sleeping. There was a good chance, as Ben had said, that he had drunk himself temporarily into a trouble-free stupor. Nevertheless, it was still necessary to compel him, for his own good, to eat something. So Fanny tried the door, found it unlocked, and without hesitation opened it and went into the Miles apartment.

She stopped short, startled. Jay was in, all right. He was sitting in the living room where he must have heard her knocking on the door. At first Fan thought he had deliberately ignored her, which was annoying; but then she saw that he was sitting in a strange rigidity, staring with wide-open eyes that did not see her. Her second thought was that he was dead. But he wasn’t. He was breathing slowly and deeply. He seemed to be in some sort of trance.

“Jay,” she said, “you scared the daylights out of me! Why don’t you answer your door?”

She walked further into the room, leaving the door open behind her. He did not answer. His eyes, when she moved, did not follow her. Approaching him from the side, she passed a hand slowly before his eyes and then shook him roughly.

“Jay! Whatever is the matter? Snap out of it!”

His stare wavered and swung slowly round to her. Then he sighed and shuddered. The sigh seemed to deflate him, for he sagged all at once in the chair.

“Fanny? Is that you, Fanny?”

“Certainly it’s me. Who did you think it was?”

“I’m sorry, I didn’t hear you. Did you say something?”

“I said to snap out of it. Why are you sitting here this way?”

He pressed the tips of his fingers against both temples, as if to force his thoughts into some order and coherence.

“You must forgive me,” he said. “I’ve had a shock.”

“What kind of shock? What’s happened?”

“I heard about Terry.”

“Where is she? Is she coming back?”

“I didn’t hear from her directly. It was someone who must have got our unlisted number from Terry.”

“Someone? Who?”

“I’m not sure I should tell you. Oh, I suppose it won’t do any harm.... It was just a voice over the phone. A man’s, I think. It sounded muffled, very far away. Terry is being held for ransom. I was told what to do to get her back.”

“What the voice said is neither here nor there. What you must do, and at once, is notify the police.”

“Yes, of course.” Jay pressed his temples as he had done before; he seemed confused again. “I seem to remember that I already did. Yes, I’m sure I did. I called and asked for Captain Bartholdi, but they said he wasn’t there.”

“Did you leave word to have him call?”

“I don’t think so. I believe I said I’d call back. I wasn’t thinking very clearly. The voice warned me against calling the police—”

“Certainly. Kidnappers always warn against calling the police. How long ago did you receive the call?”

“How long? Yes, I remember looking. It was just four-thirty when I hung up.”

“Four-thirty! And it’s six now! Have you been sitting here like a stone all this time?”

“I suppose I have. I’d no idea so much time had passed.”

“Well, never mind now. Call Captain Bartholdi again.”

“You’re right. That’s what I should do.”

“Do you feel up to it? Do you want me to call for you?”

“No, no, I must do it myself. Thank you very much.”

He put both hands on the arms of the chair and hoisted himself to his feet. Turning, he walked with exorbitant care to the telephone. He had just lifted the instrument from its cradle and pointed a finger at the dial when Ben’s voice sounded crossly from the open doorway.

“Damn it, Fanny, what’s keeping you? I thought you were going upstairs to get some gin.”

Fanny whirled, an index finger bisecting her lips in a gesture commanding, for God’s sake, silence. From behind her came the ratchet-like sound of the dial, unnaturally loud.

“This is Jay Miles speaking. Captain Bartholdi, please... Captain Bartholdi? Jay Miles. I’ve had news of Terry... Yes, a telephone call... What?... I’m not sure. About an hour and a half ago, I think. I couldn’t reach you... Yes, everything. Complete instructions... No, no. No mistake... What?... All right, I’ll be here.”

He hung up and returned to his chair, easing himself into it as if his bones might snap under the effort. Now that he had reached Bartholdi, he seemed relieved of a great burden. But he also seemed left in a lassitude that made it difficult to take another decisive step, about anything at all.

“Captain Bartholdi’s coming out,” he said drearily.

Ben said, “Why? Will somebody please tell me what’s going on?”

“Surely it’s obvious,” Fanny said. “Terry has been kidnapped, although I never really believed she’d been. Jay has received a call from the kidnapper.”

Ben’s voice was all of a sudden dry and precise. “What did he want?”

“I assume he wants money. Isn’t that what kidnappers generally want? Is that right, Jay? Did the kidnapper demand money?”

Jay had removed his glasses. He held them by one ear piece in his right hand, his right arm dangling limply over the arm of the chair. His eyes were shut. He answered without opening them.

“Captain Bartholdi said not to talk about it until he gets here.”

“I wish he would hurry,” Fanny said. “How long will he be?”

“He’s on his way. I think you two had better not be here when he arrives.”

“Are you telling us to leave?”

“That,” said Ben, “is just what he’s telling us. Do you have to have it written out for you?”

“Well, I don’t see what harm it would do to have us here.”

“Excuse me.” Jay’s eyes were still shut. “You must excuse me.”

Clearly dismissed, and as clearly reluctant to accept the dismissal, Fanny nevertheless permitted herself to be impelled into the hall by Ben, who was somewhat rougher about it than she felt was necessary.

“I didn’t get a chance to invite him to share the ragout,” she said. “I’ll go back and do it.”

“To hell with the ragout,” Ben said. “What I’m interested in now is the gin. Jump upstairs like a good girl and get it, will you, Fan?”

20

Had it worked? Had it, after all, really worked? He had taken a long chance against the odds and the best judgment of his superiors; he had held from the beginning very little hope for success. And that wasn’t all of it. If the thing had leaked, or broken wide open, there would certainly have been some bad publicity accompanied, no doubt, by assorted nastinesses directed against the department. It might even have become necessary to lop off somebody’s head, and any head that rolled should have been, in all justice, his own. At that, it had been a close call.

There had been evidence of sniffiness on the part of the press; it was blind luck that no reporter had managed to nose his way to the neighborhood of the Skully place. The families of Charles and Vernon were not practiced in the art of deception.

Well, Bartholdi reflected as he drove toward The Cornish Arms, it would break now. With a bang. Before that happened, though, perhaps a kidnapper and murderer could be trapped. He felt, thinking this, a vast uneasiness. Withholding information from the public was one thing, but withholding it from the criminal engaged in the desperate business was another. What kind of kidnapper-murderer would have left his victim’s tomb unobserved for three full days and remained in ignorance of all that had happened in the meantime? What kind of egomaniac? There lay the slim chance. Delusions of grandeur so monstrous as to make the killer indifferent to ordinary caution. It took a nut, after all, to commit this type of crime.

Bartholdi drove into the alley and parked on the apron. There was room for five cars there, and two of the places were taken. Getting out, he stood for a moment in the early November darkness to survey the rear of the buff brick building. The wall was broken by the bedroom windows of the four apartments. There was light behind the blind of the bedroom window to his lower left as he faced the building. Ben Green or Farley Moran, or both; apparently in. The one above this was dark. Fanny Moran was apparently out. The window on the lower right, beyond the rear entrance, was dark; but there must be a light at the front, unless Jay Miles was waiting for him in the dark.

Bartholdi’s glance darted up the wall to the window above. The blind moved, erasing a thin crack of light that had been there an instant before. Someone in the apartment of Otis and Ardis Bowers was curious, Bartholdi thought. Watching and waiting. For what?

A car turned into the alley. It was an old car, but it ran quietly. Turning onto the apron beside Bartholdi, it parked and Farley Moran got out. He peered at Bartholdi over the top of Bartholdi’s car, which stood between them.

“Is that you, Captain?” he said. “What are you doing here?”

“Making a call on Jay Miles. He’s got some information for me.”

“What kind of information?”

“You may as well come along with me and find out.”

“Don’t tell me he’s heard from the kidnapper!”

“He has, as a matter of fact. You sound incredulous.”

“I never really believed in the kidnap theory, to tell the truth. There could have been so many other reasons for killing Terry.”

“And so many others capable of doing it?”

“I didn’t say that. After all, it takes a rather special kind of kook to kill, it seems to me.”

“Fortunately. Come on.”

Jay, opening his door in response to Bartholdi’s knock, evinced no surprise at seeing Farley, too. He seemed, indeed, to be beyond surprise, or any emotion. He sat down again and removed his glasses and began to polish them with an air of industry. Bartholdi, retaining his topcoat and holding his hat, sat down facing him. Farley remained standing just inside the door, feeling like an interloper.

“How do you feel?” Bartholdi asked Jay.

“All right.” Jay replaced his glasses and folded the handkerchief into a neat square as if it were a task of great importance. “Don’t worry. I won’t fall apart on you.”

“Can you remember exactly what was said to you on the telephone?”

“I think so.”

“Good. Begin at the beginning.”

“Well, the phone rang, and I answered it, and there was this voice. It was a man’s voice, I think, but I can’t be positive. It was muffled, a kind of whisper that was very penetrating. It seemed to come from a great distance. Maybe it was my imagination, I don’t know. Anyhow, it told me not to talk, only to listen, and that’s what I did.”

Jay paused, staring at the square of handkerchief he had smoothed on one knee, which still lay there. He seemed to be listening again to the strange, faraway whisper on the telephone. Bartholdi waited patiently.

“The voice told me that Terry was alive and unharmed and would be released after payment of fifty thousand dollars. The money was to be in unmarked bills of small denominations. I broke in to say that I didn’t have that kind of money. But the kidnapper, whoever he is, knows about Terry’s inheritance, as you suspected. He said the money could be got from the estate; it would require only a phone call on my part and a quick transfer of funds. I kept trying to stall, to see if I could recognize the voice, and I said the executor of the estate wouldn’t just take my word about the kidnapping. But that did no good, either. The kidnapper knows I reported Terry’s disappearance to the police. He said corroboration by the police would convince the executor. He seems to know everything. He’s been watching me all the time.”

His account was broken by a long pause.

Bartholdi kept asking himself questions that he could not answer.

Everything? Not quite. He doesn’t know, it seems, that we have found the body of Terry Miles. Why? Why should he be ignorant of the very thing he should know above all?

Jay’s voice, drained of life, picked up the thread of his account.

“I’m to have the money ready tomorrow. Tomorrow night, at midnight, it’s to be delivered by a third person. He made a point of saying that I mustn’t bring it. This third person is to start walking exactly at midnight along a certain road west of town. Somewhere along the road he will be contacted. There are to be no police in the area; the police are not to be notified. He warned me Terry will be killed if they are.” Surprisingly, he laughed. “What kind of monster could tell me a thing like that, knowing he’d killed her three days ago?”

“What road?” Bartholdi asked.

“West End Road, he said. I’ve been trying to think where it is, but I can’t.”

“I know it. It’s a narrow road, little more than a lane, about five miles long. It begins at an isolated intersection and runs eventually into another. It’s poorly maintained — hardly ever used. It’s lined on both sides with hedges and underbrush.”

“Anyhow, that’s where the money is to be delivered.” Jay sank back as if the account had depleted him of his last reserve of strength. His face, turned up to the light, was gaunt and livid. “The question is, what do we do now?”

Bartholdi said, “We do as we’ve been told. It won’t be necessary, of course, to arrange a transfer of funds. I’ll have a dummy package prepared for the contact to carry. I’ll have men stationed after dark near both ends of West End Road and at intervals between. We can’t have them swarming all over the place, of course — we mustn’t risk scaring our man off. But we’ll take all possible precautions. The contact man will be from headquarters.”

“No.” Jay sat up suddenly. “That won’t do.”

“Why?”

“Because I was told whom to send. Someone the kidnapper seems to know by sight.”

“Who was specified?”

“Apparently he didn’t know the name. His exact words were, ‘The fellow who went with you to headquarters.’”

Bartholdi turned to Farley, at the door. Farley was looking as if he had bitten into a sour orange.

“Oh, I don’t know,” Farley said. “I’m no bloody hero to go walking down a country road at midnight to meet a murderer. There may be a few cops scattered around, but how the hell do I know they’ll be where I may need them? A man could get hurt on an assignment like that.”

“That’s right.” Bartholdi nodded. “He could.”

He continued to look at Farley, who was trying not to look at Jay, who kept looking at his hands. After a moment Farley struck a fist into a palm bitterly.

“All right, damn it, I suppose I’ll have to do it. It’s what I deserve for not minding my own business. It’s Fanny’s fault, that’s who! She kept after me and after me — wouldn’t leave me alone—”

“That’s settled, then.” Bartholdi rose, slapping his hat against his thigh. “Speaking of Fanny, do you happen to know if your sister’s home?”

“I haven’t any idea.”

“She’s around somewhere.” Jay lifted his eyes from his hands, escaping the contemplation of his shame. “She and Ben were in here a while ago. I think they must be across the hall.”

“Do they know about the telephone call?”

“Yes. I saw no harm in telling them. Anyhow, I couldn’t pull my wits together.”

Bartholdi’s voice sharpened. “Do they also know your wife’s dead?”

“I haven’t told them that. I haven’t told anyone.”

“You, Mr. Moran?”

“Not me,” said Farley glumly.

“Good. I have some unfinished business concerning Mr. Green. I believe I’ll step across the hall and have a word with him.”

21

Fanny, as a matter of record, had already settled the business; in the process, she had a great many more words with Ben Green than one. She had, in fact, lost no time in initiating the settlement, and she was no sooner back from upstairs with her bottle of gin than she went to the heart of the matter.

“Ben,” she said, “it was all right to be close-mouthed and two-faced so long as everything was uncertain. But now things have changed, and you’d better come clean if you know what’s good for you.”

Ben, who had promptly relieved her of the gin and was splashing generous portions into a pair of glasses, looked at her with a ferocious scowl that was equal parts sullenness and anxiety.

“I don’t see why,” he muttered.

“If you don’t see why, it’s high time someone told you, and I’m just the baby who can do it. Terry has been kidnapped, which is a serious crime, and you’re obviously under suspicion through your own foolishness, if not for other reasons.”

“What the devil do you mean by that? Why should I want to kidnap Terry? Damn it, I didn’t even know she had any money,”

“That’s what you say. I happen to know, however, that you come from Glendale, which is near Los Angeles. It’s entirely possible that you knew all about it.”

“How do you know I come from Glendale? Isn’t anyone’s private life safe from your nosiness?”

“Never mind how I know. The point is — if I know, chances are ten to one Captain Bartholdi does, too. It stands to reason that he’s going to demand an accounting of where you were and what you were doing last weekend. As a matter of fact,” Fan finished ominously, “I am demanding it myself.”

“How do you know it won’t make matters worse for me?”

“That’s possible. Nevertheless, if you’re capable of kidnapping, I would like to know it now rather than later. I have no serious objections to most of your faults, but I’m naturally reluctant to marry a man who may show up on the list of the FBI’s ten most wanted men.”

“There you go with that marriage blather again. What makes you so sure I want to marry you? My guts would be constantly in the saucepan. Damn it, Fan, I’m just a simple guy who wants to become a teacher of history in some quiet little college somewhere, and here you’ve got me in trouble with the FBI!”

“I haven’t got you in trouble with anyone. You have. Come clean, Ben. If you were just off philandering somewhere, I promise to give you another chance.”

“Another chance to philander?”

“Not much! Anyhow, you’ll have no reason. It would be a poor substitute at best for what may be available if you’ll only start facing the inevitable.”

“Oh, hell! Let’s have a drink and forget it.”

“I’ll have a drink, thanks, but you won’t. So you might just as well leave it sitting right there on the cabinet.”

“So that’s the way it is! Listen, toots, if I don’t get a drink, you don’t get any ragout, and that’s that.”

“Suit yourself.”

“Come on, Fan, be reasonable. I need this drink.”

“You know how to get it.”

“If you aren’t the most corrupt female! Do you make it a practice to bribe people with kisses and gin? What would it take to get the big offer?”

“That wouldn’t be a bribe. It would be a reward.”

“Is that a promise?”

“It’s an evaluation.”

“All right, I give up. Hand me that drink.”

“Are you agreeing to confess?”

“I’m agreeing to tell you something that’s none of your business. I’ll have to have the drink first, though, to fortify me.”

“How do I know you won’t take the drink and then renege?”

“I’m only a philanderer and kidnapper and such minor things. I’m no liar.”

“All right. You may have the drink first.”

Ben threw his head back and then looked with regret at the empty glass where the drink had been.

“I went to Corinth,” he said.

“Corinth? Corinth is a town in Greece!”

“It’s also a small town upstate.”

“Why did you go there?”

“I went to see a girl.”

“Just what I suspected! Damn it, Ben, I won’t have you running all over the state to see other girls!”

“You’ve got it wrong. I do wish you’d quit jumping to conclusions. This girl is my kid sister.”

“I didn’t know you had a sister. What’s she doing in Corinth? Is she married or something?”

“No, she isn’t married or something. She’s only fifteen.”

“Why didn’t you ever tell me about her?”

“I never tell anyone about her. At least, I didn’t until you bribed me with one lousy drink of gin. She’s in an institution. A place for mentally retarded children.”

“Is that all? Why didn’t you say so? That’s nothing to be ashamed of.”

Ben had been staring into his glass with an air of depression. But now he looked up at her, and she was delighted to see that depression had changed to fierce pride.

“Ashamed? Who the hell’s ashamed of it? I’ve said over and over again that it’s a question of privacy. It’s bad enough for a little girl to be retarded without being made a goddamn conversation piece by people who have nothing better to do but chew it over.”

Fanny’s melting point had never been very high. She was always brought perilously close to tears by a hungry dog or a sad movie, and she had learned that the best defense was to take some sort of positive action, such as feeding the dog or leaving the movie. Now she went over to Ben and kissed him on the cheek and put an arm around him.

“Ben,” she said, “you dear little devil, I do believe there’s more to you than I suspected. Don’t you feel better for having told me?”

“No, I don’t. I don’t feel better at all.”

“Later you will. Wait and see. Did you bring your sister all the way here from California with you?”

“Certainly. I had to have her near enough to visit once in a while, didn’t I?”

“Is it expensive, keeping her in the hospital?”

“Not very. The hospital is supported by the state; I only have to pay a little extra. If it were expensive, I couldn’t afford it. My parents are dead, which is some more private information I’ve never told you, and they left barely enough to keep me here and her there for a few years if I’m careful.”

“Maybe I could help.”

“I don’t want any help.”

“Well, it’s commendable to be proud and independent and all that, but you mustn’t carry it too far. After we’re married, we’ll have to share things equally.”

“We aren’t going to be married, so forget it.”

“Why not? Don’t you want to?”

“Yes, I do, if you must know!”

“Then what’s the argument about? You can move in with me as soon as it’s done, and maybe for brief periods in the meantime.”

“How do you expect me to get married when I come from a family where mental retardation is likely to crop up in my children?”

“Ben Green, you’re just plain ignorant. Mental retardation isn’t hereditary.”

Ben glared at Fanny with mingled astonishment and hope. “It isn’t?”

“Of course not. It can happen to anyone, any time. Your education has really been neglected.”

“I... don’t want to talk about it any more now.”

“All right. We’ll talk about it later.”

“I wonder if the damn ragout is done.” But Ben’s shoulders seemed to have a new squareness about them. Fan wisely decided it was no time to comment. “Stick the potatoes and see, will you?”

She stuck the potatoes with a fork, and they were nearly done, but not quite.

“Not quite,” she said. “They need about fifteen more minutes. Mm! It smells good. I can hardly wait.”

“It would be nice, while we’re waiting, if we could have another drink.”

“Hereafter, my gin is yours any time you want to share it.”

They had another drink while they stood around in the kitchen waiting for the ragout, and after fifteen minutes Fanny stuck the potatoes again and pronounced them done. Ben got out a couple of plates, and Fanny served at the kitchen table. They had just pulled up to the steamy succulence of potatoes and onions and carrots and bits of steak and bacon when there was a sharp knocking on the hall door; and Fanny, assuming the role of woman of the house, went through the living room and admitted Bartholdi. The latter’s nose, as he entered, quivered.

“Something,” he said, “smells extremely good.”

“It’s Student’s Ragout,” Fanny said. “We were just sitting down to eat. Will you have some?”

“Thanks, but I just stopped in to have a word with Ben, and then I must be on my way.”

“We’ve been expecting you.” Fanny headed for the kitchen, Bartholdi following. “Ben, Captain Bartholdi would like to have a word with you.”

“The trouble with this ragout,” said Ben explosively, “is that it seems to be damn near impossible to eat it! Something or someone is always preventing.”

“Don’t let me interrupt your meal,” Bartholdi said. “You two go right ahead. I’ll pull up a chair and wait.”

He did so, dropping his hat on the floor beside the chair. Ben picked at his ragout as if Bartholdi’s appearance had killed his appetite.

“Are you sure you won’t have some with us?” Fanny said.

“Quite sure.”

“It’s fortunate that you won’t, to tell the truth. We planned to share it with Jay and Farley, and it’s doubtful that there’d be enough for five.”

“It’s doubtful,” Ben said, “that there will even be enough for four. Not that it matters. I suddenly don’t seem to want any.”

“Yes, you do,” Fanny said. “You are going to get a proper meal whether you want it or not. There will be plenty, anyhow. You insisted on putting in the usual amount of onions, which is too much for Jay, and so he’ll probably eat very little.”

“I just left Mr. Miles,” said Bartholdi, “and I’m sure he’s in no mood for eating anything, with onions or without.”

“That leaves only Farley. By the way, where is Farley?”

“He’s across the hall. I met him out back as I was coming in, and asked him to accompany me.”

“Do you think that’s fair? I wasn’t allowed to stay.”

“As for me,” said Ben, “I had no desire to stay. The less I have to do with this thing, the better I like it.”

“Which reminds me,” Bartholdi smiled. “It’s time we were establishing that you had nothing to do with it.”

“That’s already established,” Fanny said. “Ben has finally told me where he went last weekend.”

“Is that so? Suppose he tells me, too.”

“He went to visit his sister.”

“Is that right, Ben?”

“That’s right. In Corinth. She’s in the institution there.”

“She’s a retarded child,” Fanny said.

“I’m sorry, Mr. Green,” Bartholdi said. “However painful it is for you to discuss, you can surely see the necessity.”

“I suppose so.”

“How did you go to Corinth?”

“By bus.”

“What time?”

“The bus left the station at two fifty-five.”

“Can you prove you were at the institution that day?”

“I wasn’t there that day. The bus got in after visiting hours. I went there the next morning.”

“Oh? Where did you spend the night?”

“At the hotel. There’s only one in town.”

“I see. And what time next morning did you visit the institution?”

“Nine o’clock or thereabouts.”

“This can be verified?”

“Sure. There’s a register for visitors. I signed it.”

“You see?” Fanny said triumphantly. “Ben went to visit his sister.”

“Next time I go,” said Ben bitterly, “I’ll hire a brass band and carry a banner.”

Bartholdi, rising to leave, was sympathetic in principle. In practice, however, he held his sympathy in reserve until he was certain, after investigation, that it would not be wasted.

His melting point was considerably higher than Fanny’s.

22

“Oh!” Ardis Bowers’s mouth made the startled shape of the vowel she had sounded. “It’s Captain Bartholdi, isn’t it?”

“Yes,” said Bartholdi. “I don’t believe we’ve had the pleasure of meeting.”

Ardis, recovering, made it evident by her succeeding expression that the pleasure was not reciprocal. Her position in the doorway suggested an impediment. She did not bother to explain how she had learned his identity, and Bartholdi, for his part, was not sufficiently interested to ask.

“What is it you want, please?” Ardis demanded.

“I was downstairs and, since I was here, I thought I’d have a talk with you and Professor Bowers. May I come in?”

“I’m sure there is nothing Otis and I can tell you. However—”

“Thanks. I appreciate your cooperation.”

Bartholdi entered, and Otis Bowers rose to meet him from a chair under a reading lamp. He was holding a thick book in his hand, the index finger inserted among the pages to mark his place.

“This is my husband,” Ardis said. “Otis, Captain Bartholdi.”

“Good evening, Captain.” Otis shifted the book to his left hand, thereby losing his place, in order to offer Bartholdi the one that had been holding it. “Sit down, won’t you?”

Bartholdi kept his coat on and his hat in his hands. “As you know, I’ve been investigating the disappearance of Professor Miles’s wife.”

“If you want my opinion,” Ardis said, “you’re wasting your time.”

“Your opinion is welcome,” Bartholdi said. “Why do you think so?”

“Terry Miles is a tramp. She’s off somewhere on the usual business of a tramp, and she’ll show up again when she’s good and ready.”

“That’s an interesting opinion, but circumstances don’t seem to support it.”

“Well, I know nothing about circumstances, but I do know Terry, and that’s enough for me.”

“What circumstances?” Otis said. “Has there been a new development?”

Bartholdi stole a couple of seconds to study the male Bowers physiognomy. They gave Bartholdi all the time he needed to reach an irrelevant conclusion. In spite of its lonely hours and arid spaces, he concluded, the life of a bachelor had its negative compensations. He wondered if Otis Bowers was expressing a genuine curiosity, or was trying to create a desperate diversion.

“I was referring to the dinner Mrs. Miles left cooking, the fact that no clothes were taken, and her failure to leave any word of explanation.”

“There’s the Personal,” Ardis said. “Isn’t that the explanation?”

“I didn’t know you’d learned about that, Mrs. Bowers. May I ask how you did?”

“I read it in the papers. Newspapers are published to be read, you know.”

“But Personals often aren’t. Except by people with particular interests.”

“I’m curious about all sorts of things.”

“The Personal, I thought, was on the obscure side. It’s remarkable that you were able to interpret it so easily.”

“Nonsense. It was transparent. Anyone who knew Terry would have suspected immediately that it was directed to her.”

“Yes. And that’s a curious point. In fact, this whole matter of the Personal is curious. It’s curious, in the first place, that it should have been resorted to at all. It’s even more curious that it should have been made, as you said, so transparent.”

“I don’t agree. Terry is devious, but she isn’t very smart.”

“Maybe so. Anyway, I’ve made inquiries at the university library, and no one seems to remember Mrs. Miles’s being there at the time the ad specified. That doesn’t necessarily mean, of course, that she wasn’t there. It’s a busy place, and she could have gone unnoticed.” Bartholdi paused again. Then he suddenly said, “Did you happen to see her, Professor Bowers?”

“I?” Otis’s voice, reacting to the prod, was almost a yelp. “Not I! Why do you ask me?”

“Because you were on the scene. At least the girl at the charging desk said you went into the stacks about that time.”

“Did I? Yes, I recall now that I did. I had to consult a certain book. I used one of the carrels for perhaps fifteen or twenty minutes, then I left.”

“The girl at the desk doesn’t remember your leaving.”

“I didn’t go out past her. I went down the stairs of the stacks to the basement and out a rear door.”

“Did you leave the campus?”

“No. I went to the physics lab and worked on an experiment until rather late. I was alone in the lab, so I’m afraid you’ll have to take my word for it. When I finished, I went directly home.”

“Did you and Mrs. Bowers meet on the campus and come home together?”

“We did not,” Ardis said. “I got home about noon with a migraine headache. I took some aspirin and a sleeping pill and went to bed. I slept most of the afternoon.”

By the asperity of her tone, Bartholdi gathered that Otis, having placed himself under suspicion through carelessness, design, or both, was being deliberately left to save or hang himself as best he could. Ardis, judging from the set of her jaws, did not especially care which. Bartholdi was prompted to his next remark by a contrary imp impelled by a malice of its own.

“I see,” he said. “You were, as we say, Mr. Bowers, at the scene of the crime at the significant time.”

“Crime?” shrieked Ardis. “What crime?”

“Just a manner of speaking.” Bartholdi rose. “Thank you both.”

Otis went with him to the door. Half opening it, he whirled on Bartholdi and spoke in a rush — as if, having something painful to say, he meant to say it in one breath and get it over with.

“I know what’s on your mind, Captain! Fanny or Farley or Ben or someone has told you about Terry and me. Whatever they said, it must have been mostly untrue. I assure you there was never really anything between us. Now there is nothing at all. Absolutely nothing.”

“Oh?” said Bartholdi.

“It’s true. I assure you it is. I know things look bad because of that damn Personal. Because it was signed with the initial letter of my given name. I’ve been thinking about that, and I’m convinced it was done deliberately. As a rotten trick to get me in hot water — all over again. If my wife hadn’t seen the Personal, someone would have mentioned it to her. Do you know what I think? I think Terry had it put in the paper herself! She’s malicious enough to enjoy making trouble for people! She thinks it’s amusing!”

Bartholdi’s eyes, fastened on Otis’s serio-comic face, widened briefly in surprise. Otis’s explanation of the Personal was one that he had not thought of. It made a certain kind of sense. It not only explained why the item had been published, but also why it had been published in such transparent terms as to be readily understood by anyone familiar with the parties involved. And Terry’s real appointment, it was practically certain, had been the one with O’Hara that O’Hara had mentioned.

“You make her sound,” he said, “like a very unpleasant person.”

“She’s more than that. She’s dangerous.”

With a final nod of his head, like an exclamation point, Otis slammed the door. Bartholdi, retreating down the hall, was forced to agree. Terry Miles had been dangerous. And, dead, she was more dangerous than she had ever been alive.

The danger, however, was no longer dispersed. It was pointed, like a loaded gun, directly at her murderer.

Going down the stairs at the end of the hall, Bartholdi continued his descent to the basement. His nose told him, as he approached Orville Reasnor’s door, that the building superintendent had recently cooked his dinner. The smell of it hung heavily in the hall. Among other things, Bartholdi’s nose said, there was onion in it.

Orville, opening his door, brought his own odor with him; and if onion was still in it, it was not smellable. Orville’s perfume, Bartholdi decided, was compounded of pine-scented disinfectant and stale perspiration.

He identified himself and declined an invitation to enter. “I just want to ask you a question or two.”

“What about?” Orville’s tone clearly implied that he was an employee of infinite discretion. “Has Prof Miles finally got the police after that floozy wife of his? If he has, there’s no use asking me anything about it. I mind my own business.”

“What makes you think I’m looking for Mrs. Miles?”

“She’s missing, ain’t she? Dr. Miles was here Friday night with Mr. Moran looking for her, and she ain’t come back. Leastwise, I ain’t seen her.”

“I’m trying to find out where she’s gone.”

“Not knowing, I couldn’t say.”

“She left here, I understand, about the same time as Ben Green. I’m wondering if they could have gone away together.”

“I wouldn’t put it past either one of them. But it so happens that they didn’t.”

“Oh? You’re sure about that?”

“I saw Mr. Green leave — carrying a bag, he was — and there wasn’t nobody with him. I was working in the vestibule upstairs, and he walked right past me. He’s a snooty bastard. Talks when he takes a notion, which ain’t often.”

“What time was that, do you remember?”

“I couldn’t say. Some time in the afternoon. I’m no clock-watcher when I’m about my work.”

“Well, that seems to settle it.” Bartholdi sniffed, wishing he could somehow eliminate the olfactory evidence of Orville. “You had something good for dinner, eh? I love the smell of onions cooking.”

“I had liver. Onions go good with liver.”

“I thought for a minute you’d been making a Student’s Ragout.”

“Student’s what? Never heard of it. I don’t go for them fancy dishes. Plain eats is what I like.”

“I’m with you. You can’t go wrong on plain eats.”

On the apron behind the building, Bartholdi breathed gratefully pi the good cold November air. Remembering his thoughts after leaving Otis Bowers, he felt a stirring at the roots of his hair, an electric tingling in his flesh that had nothing to do with the cold.

Yes, Terry Miles was still dangerous. She was deadly dangerous to a frightened and desperate murderer; and in spite of irrelevancies and diversions and unconfirmed assumptions, Bartholdi was sure — as he had been sure for some time — who her murderer was.

23

The lane was a tunnel in darkness; the hedges hemmed in the road; the wind whispered in the hedges. Once the road had been graveled, but the gravel was gone, pressed into the clay bed or thrown aside by wheels. The clay had been softened by rains and rutted while soft; now it was frozen hard, and the ruts writhed treacherously underfoot.

Farley had approached the lane alone, after parting from Bartholdi some distance from where it began. He walked along at a measured pace, counting his steps. He had not been told to do this, but he did it for such comfort as it provided, having anticipated that what could be a five-mile walk along a lonely road on a dark night was nothing to bring home to one’s dreams.

“Take your time, Mr. Moran,” Bartholdi had said. “There’s no telling when you’ll be contacted — if you’re contacted at all — but I have a hunch it will be on your return trip. This kidnapper will want to wait as long as he can before he makes his move, just to be sure there’s no trap. Remember, you won’t be alone. My men have got to stay back some distance, of course, but one of them will always be close enough to protect you. Here, take this police whistle. After you’ve been contacted by the kidnapper and he’s left, give two blasts on it. The alarm will be passed along from station to station, and in a matter of seconds we’ll close in.

“The chances are at least even that the kidnapper will slip through, considering the terrain. That can’t be helped. So you’ve got to get a good look at him, if it’s at all possible. And don’t go being a hero, Mr. Moran.”

“Don’t worry,” Farley had said, “I won’t.”

“Be sure you’re safely away from him before you use the whistle, then hide yourself in a bush and stay put till one of my officers shows up. Here’s your package. It’s got nothing but paper in it, of course.”

The night was cold. The sky was remote, it’s blackness pricked by pinpoint stars. Farley heard the wind in the hedges; he heard from somewhere, dying, the fluty boom of an owl.

His foot struck something that rolled away in the darkness, and he sprang aside, heart in his mouth. His other foot jammed into a deep rut and he staggered, almost falling Pain shot up his leg; he had twisted his ankle.

The road felt like cement as he knelt on it. He rubbed the turned ankle, trying to massage the pain away. Finally, the pain dwindled to a throb... He could see, nearby, faintly on the dark clayey road, the object he had tripped over. He crawled ahead and picked it up. It was an orange from an Osage hedge. He cursed and hurled it away. It struck the frozen ground with a crash, like a rock, and bounded away.

Farley got up on his feet, testing his ankle cautiously. Limping, he walked on. His hands, ungloved, were cold, and he shoved them into the big patch pockets of his thick wool jacket. In one pocket bulged the dummy package. The whistle lay in the other.

He came suddenly on a concrete culvert spanning the dry bed of a shallow ravine that ran with water when the rains fell and the snows melted. The culvert was no more than a flat slab without railings. He sat down on the slab, dangling his legs into the ravine. All at once, it seemed, the entire earth had dropped into a profound silence, in which all living things crouched mute, listening for — what? He, too, was listening, leaning forward on the slab; then, becoming aware of what he was doing, the tension left him, and he laughed:

Farley, he mocked himself, you are about to fall under the spell of the witches and the goblins and that old black magic. Get with it, man!

The spell was instantly broken; the night was filled at once with a thousand small, comforting sounds. Rising, Farley went on. He had developed a blister, and the ankle prevented his going too briskly; but he came soon enough to the intersection — the end of the lane.

He had met no one on the way, he had seen no one, and now nothing remained but the tiresome ordeal of walking back. He waited for a few minutes, thinking that an officer might approach him, but nothing happened. He started back the way he had come.

Walking aggravated the pain in his ankle. He stopped every two or three hundred yards to massage the ankle, trying to determine by touch if it was swelling or not He cursed the fatuity of his mission as he limped from one stop to the next.

It was now his urgent desire to be done with it as soon as possible. But his progress was so slow because of his ankle that he had to fight a rapidly growing irritation.

Out of this mood, having paused once more to rub his ankle, he was suddenly jolted. Ahead of him somewhere, along the dark road, he heard the throb of an idling engine. A car had entered the lane and was parked, lights off, in the most dense shadow of the hedge.

He followed the sound, limping and silent, and soon came upon the car. It was so nearly absorbed by the shadows that he might have passed without seeing it. It was pulled off the road in the rough opening of a hedge that led to a field beyond, no doubt broken through by some fanner to give access to his machines. Farley leaned forward to peer into the interior of the car. Canted against the door on the right side of the front seat he made out what appeared to be the shadow of an enormous and grotesque head.

He felt about on the hard road until his fingers came in contact with some gravel. This he tossed at the car. The head, at the ping of stones on metal, flew apart as if riven by the sound. There was a frantic flurry of movement. Farley had barely time to jump aside. The headlights flashed on, the car backed with a rush from the opening in the hedge, and tore off in a shower of gravel.

Farley resumed his trek. His feet on the frozen clay bed of the road were numb with the cold. He began counting cadence again, limping along to the count; and after what seemed infinity, he reached the terminus of the road where he had started. He began trudging down the crossroad as he had been directed. He had gone perhaps fifty yards when Bartholdi materialized from the night.

“Nothing?” said Bartholdi.

“Not a damn thing.”

“A car entered the road a while ago. Did you see it?”

“Yes. A couple. They parked. I scared them off.”

“They were stopped at the other end.”

“What do suppose went wrong?”

“Who knows? Maybe the whole thing was a rehearsal. For whatever reason, we’ve been stood up.”

“Well, I’m tired, and I’m freezing, and I twisted an ankle. Do you need me any longer?”

“No, Mr. Moran, you did fine. There’s a police car over there. The driver will take you home.”

Bartholdi continued to stand there, thinking. An officer stepped out of the darkness.

“Dry run?” the officer said.

“Dry run.”

“What about the car that went in?”

“A couple making out.”

“In my day, we called it necking.”

“In your day, that’s all it was. Today...” Bartholdi sighed.

24

Bartholdi knew that he would not sleep. Instead of going home, he went to headquarters and sat alone in his office in a darkness that was compromised by a finger of light prying through a crack in his door from the hall outside.

His brain was as jumpy as if it had been injected with a cerebral aphrodisiac. It had happened before, and he always preferred on such occasions to sit in the dark. He indulged himself at these times in a harmless fantasy. His thoughts, he would imagine, were irrepressible imps that wriggled out at his head and scampered around with an abandon that was often embarrassing. Consequently, in order to secure a decent privacy for their performance, it was only proper to release them after dark, and when he was alone.

Now his liberated imps were uneasy and angry. He was convinced that a murderer was at that moment having a grim laugh at his expense. He was certain, indeed, of a number of things. He was certain that his quarry knew the police knew Terry Miles was dead; he knew, in spite of this, why they had been put through the antics of this dreary night.

His imps figured it out this way:

The kidnapper allegedly knew that Jay Miles had gone to the police. If so, why didn’t he also know that the body of Terry Miles had been found? Having Jay under such close observation, apparently following him from home to headquarters, would he have abandoned the tail just in time to remain in ignorance of their subsequent visit to the old Skully place? Is was conceivable, granting an egomaniac with delusions of grandeur and immunity, but it was not probable. No, it was not.

In the second place, the kidnapper himself was merely a theory. Evidence of his existence was hearsay. Bartholdi had only Jay Miles’s word that a kidnapper had made himself known. There had been no witnesses to the telephone contact.

It had been necessary to take the whole thing on blind faith, and Bartholdi did not count himself among the faithful blind. Yet he believed in a kidnapping of a sort.

He knew who the murderer was. He would have bet his pension and his sacred soul that he knew. But he could not, knowing, prove what he knew. He needed confirmation on a critical point.

From among his antic imps he culled the three that had directed his mind to its present state. Sternly, like a drill sergeant, he brought them to attention in rank and inspected them:

One newspaper too many.

A girl who slept too soundly.

Most important of all, a ragout with too many onions.

25

Later that day, which was a Wednesday, the story of Terry Miles was issued by Captain Bartholdi to the press. Too late for the morning edition of the Journal, it was lavishly treated in the evening edition — illustrated with garish photographs of the old Skully house and the bleak little room where the body was found, and of Terry and Jay, which were dug up from somewhere. And it was annotated with comment from the authorities in high places, and from young Vernon and Charles, who gave free rein to imaginations loosened at last from the threat of police displeasure. Vernon in particular revealed a talent for narrative embroidery.

Bartholdi, peppered by snipers from all sides, remained committed to his task. Early in the day he telephoned Jay to warn him of coming events; Jay, on the captain’s advice, arranged for the removal of Terry’s remains to a private mortuary from which, as soon as arrangements could be completed, they would be transferred to the west coast. Thereafter, still following Bartholdi’s advice, he locked his door and took his telephone out of its cradle. Even Fanny, who made two attempts, was unable to rouse him.

After dark, when he was at last on his way home, Bartholdi — having greater authority — was admitted. He remained with Jay behind a locked door for half an hour.

It was the following afternoon when Jay, expecting Bartholdi again, opened to find Brian O’Hara on his threshold. The gambler was meticulously dressed, from burnished black shoes to gray homburg, which he held at his side in a black-gloved hand. His face gave the impression of having been as carefully selected and donned for the occasion as his attire. Jay had the feeling that O’Hara, in rage and grief, had deliberately applied himself to the minutiae of his appearance as a sort of emotional camouflage.

“Oh,” said Jay. “I was expecting someone else.”

O’Hara voice had come out of the closet with his face and tie. “I tried your phone, but it was dead. May I come in?”

“If you must.”

Jay stepped aside, and O’Hara walked three steps into the room and stopped. He stripped off his gloves and held them with his homburg in his right hand.

“What I have to say will only take a minute,” he said. “It won’t be an expression of sympathy, I assure you.”

“Good. I’m relieved that you’re so sensitive to the situation.”

“There’s nothing to be gained by our being cute with each other. We know what the situation was last week. But now it’s changed, and what it is is something to be settled between us. Terry’s dead. I’ve been telling myself that — it’s hard to accept, but it’s true. She’s dead, and someone knocked her off. If it was you, I’ll find out. And if I find out before the police do, I’ll settle with you. I’m not making a threat. It’s a promise.”

“Is that all you came to say, O’Hara?”

“That’s all.”

“You might be surprised to know how little difference it makes to me. To me, Terry’s been dead for a long time. She was killed piecemeal, by you and others like you; and whoever killed her in the end, for whatever reason, was only finishing what the rest of you started. Now, if you have nothing more to say, I must ask to be excused. I’m expecting someone.”

O’Hara drew on his gloves and moved to the door, where he stopped. “Let’s hope — for your sake — I never have to see you or speak to you again.”

He opened the door and stood face to face with Bartholdi.

“How are you, O’Hara?” Bartholdi said. “I was about to knock.”

“And I was about to leave.”

“Don’t hurry because of me. My business isn’t private.”

“Mine was. And it’s finished, so I’ll be off.”

“I’d rather you wouldn’t, if you don’t mind. The business of all of us is substantially the same right now. We may as well settle it together.”

Bartholdi walked past O’Hara, followed by a short thin man with a golfer’s tan and gray hair so tightly curled on his head that it looked like raw wool. Jay, seeing Bartholdi’s companion, stepped forward and extended a hand.

“Hello, Mr. Feldman,” he said. “I’m glad to see you.”

The Los Angeles attorney took the hand and let it go. “I’m dreadfully sorry about all this, Jay. If there’s anything I can do—”

“There’s nothing.”

“You’re wrong,” Bartholdi said. “There’s a killer to talk about, and now is the time to do it. Did you invite the other tenants, Mr. Miles, as I asked?”

“The whole lot. Otis and Ardis Bowers. Farley and Fanny Moran. Ben Green. Even Orville Reasnor.”

“Good.” Bartholdi glanced at his watch. “O’Hara here is a bonus... We’re a few minutes early. I suggest you make yourselves comfortable while we’re waiting.”

They had just sat down when Fanny appeared, with Ben in tow. Fanny’s eyes were dime-bright with curiosity. It was apparent that, early as she was, she would have preferred being earlier, while Ben, for his part, would have preferred being later, or even absent.

“Well, here we are,” Fanny said. “Ben kept dragging his heels, but I saw to it that he didn’t sneak off and hide. Jay, why have you been avoiding everyone just when we wanted to help?”

“Come in and sit down, Miss Moran,” Bartholdi said, stepping between Jay and the question.

“Yes,” said Ben, “and, for God’s sake, shut up.”

“Don’t pay any attention to Ben,” Fanny said. “Did you know that we’re going to be married?”

“Like hell!” said Ben.

“Congratulations,” said Bartholdi. “Is your brother Farley coming?”

“He’s coming, but he had to go somewhere first. Ben, where did Farley have to go, and when will he be back?”

“I don’t know. He didn’t say.”

“Never mind,” Bartholdi said. “I know what he’s doing.”

“I don’t see why Farley always has to be the one who’s asked to do things,” Fanny said.

Bartholdi said, “Here are the others now.”

And so they were: Ardis and Otis Bowers and Orville Reasnor. They came into the room, Reasnor trailing a couple of paces as became a man who knew his place.

“I want to know what this is all about,” announced Ardis. “I don’t like being ordered around with no reason given.”

“You’ll see, Mrs, Bowers,” Bartholdi said. “Please sit down and be patient.”

“Be patient and be quiet,” Otis snapped to his wife with rare asperity. “Jay, I won’t even try to tell you how terrible I feel about all this.”

“Thanks,” said Jay. “I’d rather you didn’t.”

“Perhaps you all know Mr. O’Hara by reputation if not by sight,” Bartholdi said. “This other gentleman is Attorney Maurice Feldman, who has come on from Los Angeles. His time is limited — he’s got to return on the five o’clock jet. I specifically asked that you all be informed of that. Were you informed, Miss Moran?”

“Oh, yes,” said Fanny in a puzzled way. “So was Ben.”

“I told them all, as you instructed,” Jay said.

“Good. Then we’d better start.”

Bartholdi, pausing, divided a long look six ways, beginning with Fanny, as brightly inquisitive as a bird, and ending with O’Hara, as still as a stone. “What I’m going to do is to tell you who killed Terry Miles and take her murderer into custody.”

Even Fanny’s impetuosity was for the moment stilled.

“Practically from the beginning,” Bartholdi said, “I was convinced that Terry Miles was murdered by someone who knew her well — someone who saw her regularly. Three pieces of evidence — three clues, if you want — all pointed to this.

“First, there was the companion-newspaper carrying the Personal that was assumed, as was intended, to be addressed to the victim. I found it, you may remember, in the Miles’s kitchen, where it had been left with other newspapers, and where it went unnoticed by the murderer. The other paper had been planted in the living room, where it could easily be found, or pointed out if necessary.

“The only reasonable purpose of the Personal ad, I figured, was to draw attention away from this building, and to be attributed later to a kidnapper who was still to show his hand.

“Secondly, there was the casual remark of a certain young lady. After coming back to this building late last Friday night she had a nightcap, not prepared by her; and then, in spite of all the excitement, she got suddenly very sleepy and went to bed and slept like a log. This in itself would not be remarkable except that she was impressed enough by it to mention it afterward. The incident became significant when I considered the locations of the four apartments in the building in relation to one another. Was the sound sleep artificially induced — by sleeping pills in her drink, say — to insure non-interference with something that had to be done secretly and quickly nearby?

“Finally,” continued Bartholdi, “and of first importance, there was the ragout left simmering in the skillet. It’s common practice for a wife to prepare her husband’s dinner, even if she doesn’t intend to be there to eat it with him — yes, and even though she’s invited a guest to share it. But why, if Terry Miles did prepare her husband’s dinner, should she have prepared it in such a manner as to make her husband find it disagreeable, if not inedible? The ragout contained far too much onion for Mr. Miles’s well-advertised tastes — such an excess, in fact, that he was moved to complain about it openly and repeatedly during and after the meal. Did his wife put too many onions into the ragout out of malice? Hardly — not when she thought she was bound for an assignation; under such circumstances a woman would want, not to arouse her husband’s anger, but to keep conditions as normal as possible.

“The way it looked to me,” said Bartholdi, “Terry Miles did not prepare that ragout. Someone else did.” He paused, and in the pause he could see that he had them fast in his grip. “That ragout, if it had not been made by Terry Miles, must therefore have been prepared, cooked, and left simmering in the skillet by her murderer — only her murderer would want it thought that she was still alive; and the ragout, being an extension of her, so to speak, had to be left on the stove as if she had prepared it and left it there. She had announced her intention of making a ragout for dinner in the presence of a third party, who would certainly remember it later and mention it to the police. The murderer had no difficulty preparing it, because Mrs. Miles had recited the recipe. What he didn’t know, of course, was that when she made Student’s Ragout for her husband she modified the recipe and used far less onions than it called for.

“And that, together with all the other facts in this case, told me who the murderer was.”

Bartholdi fell silent, staring about him. The face of the murderer seemed to be hanging in midair before some of them; to others, apparently, it was a mere outline, still to be filled in with flesh and blood.

“The motive for Terry Miles’s murder was certainly the ransom to be collected after her supposed kidnapping,” Captain Bartholdi went on, “although the murderer had no intention of letting her live — she knew him and could identify him. What I needed was confirmation that the murderer could have had the one piece of information vital to his crime — that Terry Miles was an heiress; in other words, that there would be plenty of money available to ransom her. (Of course, his ransom plot never got off the ground; those two boys accidentally running across the dead woman in that empty house put a crimp in everything.)

“Who knew that Mrs. Miles had a fortune in her name? Her husband here knew — but Mr. Miles is eliminated as the kidnapper-murderer because he is the only suspect in this case who would have no reason to put too many onions in the ragout; in fact, every reason not to. Mrs. Miles knew. Attorney Feldman knew. But Mr. Feldman was in Los Angeles when all this was taking place, and there was all kinds of testimony to the effect that neither of the Mileses mentioned a word to anyone of Terry’s inheritance.

“Mr. Feldman has given me the link to the murderer’s knowledge about that inheritance.

“Some years ago a young pre-law student worked part time in Mr. Feldman’s law office in Los Angeles for experience and pocket money, Mr. Feldman tells me. Being in the office, the student had access to the information that Terry Miles was coming into her father’s considerable estate by the terms of his will. What’s more, this student left Los Angeles soon after Terry and Jay Miles got married, and moved east to Handclasp to enroll in the university here.

“So there was the last link. Terry Miles was murdered because she would have been able to name her kidnapper. She was murdered by the same man who planted the Personal ad as a red herring. By the same man who gave that sleeping dose to Fanny Moran — who lived directly over his apartment and might have been disturbed by what he had to do that night. Which was — after he was left alone with her early Friday afternoon and killed her — to keep her body hidden in his apartment until the night came and he could push the body out his rear window and transport it in his car to the old Skully house. Which he had rented beforehand, in disguise and under a phony name, so that he would have a place to hide the body while he tried to collect the ransom. By the same man who, Friday afternoon, prepared the ragout from the recipe Terry Miles had recited in his presence. By the same man who, made desperate by the ruin of his plans to collect ransom, because of the premature discovery of the body, had to go through the farce of playing the contactman for the ransom payment. By the only man who fits the entire picture.”

Bartholdi broke off and stood still, head cocked, diverted by the sound of a familiar action in the hall outside. He took out his old-fashioned pocket watch and carefully checked the time.

“In short,” Bartholdi concluded, “by the same man who has just slipped into his apartment across the hall under the illusion that his present danger is gone with the one man who can identify him as the former part-time officer clerk — the only suspect in this case who found it expedient not to be present with Mr. Feldman here. I’m afraid, you see, that I had Jay deliberately misinform you about Mr. Feldman’s commitment. He has no plane to catch this afternoon.”

No one moved or spoke until Jay Miles, his carefully disciplined tone broken by a kind of wonder, said, “But it’s incredible! How could he have lived here among us without ever arousing the least suspicion that he’s capable of such a thing?”

“There’s no questioning the facts, Mr. Miles. I learned a long time ago that you can’t always tell a killer from a psalm-singer.”

“But why didn’t he wait? In another year, Terry would have controlled her own money. All the complications with the estate could have been avoided.”

“We can hold Mr. O’Hara responsible for that. It must have been clear to the killer that Mrs. Miles’s marriage was about to end, and that O’Hara here would be next on her hitparade. Once she left here for good, the execution of the plan would have become much harder and more dangerous. Maybe impossible.”

“You had better go and get him,” O’Hara said suddenly, “if you don’t want me to save you the trouble.”

“There’s no hurry.” Bartholdi’s eyes engaged O’Hara’s, and for the first time there was in them a flicker of something like contempt. “I have men stationed outside, of course. And they can, if necessary, take you as easily as they’ll take Farley Moran.”

At that point, as though cued by the name, spoken at last, Fanny Moran rose.

“I believe,” she said, in a small, sick voice, “that I shall go upstairs.”

Ben Green climbed the stairs and entered Fanny’s apartment without knocking. She was seated in a chair by a window, staring out into the thickening darkness of the coming November night. He went over and placed a hand on her shoulder and stood beside her.

“Are they gone?” she asked.

“Yes, Fan.”

“I guess I’ve always known there was something wrong with him,” Fanny said. “I never liked him much, to tell the truth. It’s a hard thing to say. It was a feeling I had. A kind of — I don’t know — uneasiness, when I was with him.”

“Is that why you followed him to Handclasp? To try to look after him?”

“I’m not sure. I never asked myself. Maybe I didn’t really want to know. But I never dreamed he would come to as bad an end as this.”

“It’s the end, all right, and it’s bad, all right.”

“Yes.” She turned toward Ben Green and clutched his hand, and her voice was at once fiercely possessive and a plea for comfort. “Now, darn you, maybe you’ll stop being so sensitive about your family! The shoe’s on the other foot. Do you want to marry the half-sister of a murderer?”

“No,” said Ben Green. Fanny’s lower lip trembled; she began to blubber. “Fan... Fan, sweet bunch, don’t. Damn it all, that ‘no’ slipped out out of habit. I meant... yes!”

Content

Ellery Queen
The Devil’s Cook

Cast of Characters

1

2

3

4

5

6

7

8

9

10

11

12

13

14

15

16

17

18

19

20

21

22

23

24

25